SAT-07099 |
Date | Description |
---|---|
IRG #58 2022-03-15 (Tue) 11:28 am +0800 Recorded by CHEN Zhuang | postponed for SAT statistics. |
IRG #58 2022-03-17 (Thu) 9:00 am +0800 Recorded by CHEN Zhuang | Not unified to 缾 U+7F3E, Evidence accepted, (should not be unified to the modern form.) |
Version | Description |
---|---|
3.0 | For 03136, add Discussion Record "Not unified to 缾 U+7F3E, evidence accepted, should not be unified to the modern form, IRG 58." |
Source Reference | Glyph |
---|---|
SAT-07099 | 1.0 |
group | SAT |
a) Source reference | SAT-07099 |
b) PUA Code of TTF | F1FE |
c) KangXi Radical Code(Primary) | 121.0 |
d) Stroke Count(Primary) | 8 |
e) First Stroke(Primary) | 3 |
g) Total Stroke Sount | 15 |
i) IDS (Ideographic Description Sequence) | ⿰𦈢𰏤 |
j) Similar/ Variants | Similar: 缾/ |
k) Ref. to Evidence doc | SAT-07099-01.jpg;SAT-07099-02.jpg |
l) Optional info | N/A |
m1)Previous IRG WS | N/A |
m2)Sequence No of Previous IRG WS | N/A |
Review Comments
Unify to 缾 (U+7F3E); add new UCV 𰏤 = 并
𰏤 (3) vs 并 (100+)
⿰扌𰏤 = [ {{WS2017-01438}} ]
(6) vs 拼 (50)
⿰木𰏤 = [ {{WS2017-01724}} ]
(1) vs 栟 (4)
⿰氵𰏤 (1) vs 洴 (7)
⿰糸𰏤 = [ {{WS2017-03431}} ]
(4) vs 絣 (25)
⿱艹⿰氵𰏤 (1) vs 蓱 (5)
⿰石𰏤 = [ {{WS2017-02992}} ]
(2) vs 硑 (0)
⿰𦈢𰏤 (this) (1) vs 缾 (7)
⿺辶𰏤 = [ {{WS2017-04305}} ]
(4) vs 逬/迸 (44)
They are mostly minority compared to 幷 variants, but has significantly high proportion of headword usage. Moreover, outside those two forms, we could not find a character with 𢆙 component in the literature. With that, we can conclude that 𰏤 in fact represents the classical form 慧琳 preferred: equivalent of 𢆙, but not replacement of 幷. The view is also supported by occasional remarks by 慧琳 that suggests 𰏤 is the more correct glyph over 幷 (see below).