GKJ-00303 |
Date | Description |
---|---|
IRG #61 2023-10-16 (Mon) 12:12 pm -0400 Recorded by CHEN Zhuang | Keep postponed. |
IRG #57 2021-09-14 (Tue) 9:14 am +0800 Recorded by CHEN Zhuang | postponed, may be non-cognate, additional evidence needed. |
Version | Description |
---|---|
2.0 | For 04782, change Status to Postponed |
2.0 | For 04782, add Discussion Record "Postponed, may be non-cognate, additional evidence needed, IRG 57." |
2.0 | For 04782, change IDS to ⿰𠪨鳥 |
2.0 | For 04782, add Discussion Record "IDS=⿰𠪨鳥, 2021-10." |
6.0 | For 04782, add Discussion Record "Kept postponed, IRG 61." |
Source Reference | Glyph |
---|---|
GKJ-00303 | 1.0 |
group | China (GKJ - Science and Technology Characters) |
a) Source reference | GKJ-00303 |
b) PUA Code of TTF | E05A |
c) KangXi Radical Code(Primary) | 196.0 |
d) Stroke Count(Primary) | 14 |
e) First Stroke(Primary) | 1 |
g) Total Stroke Count | 25 |
i) IDS (Ideographic Description Sequence) | ⿰⿸厂⿱里𡉀鳥 |
j) Similar/ Variants | N/A |
k) Ref. to Evidence doc | 說文解字 |
Review Comments
Consider add UCV 𠪨/廛 to j1 due to difference of a single stroke (the first dot). So it can be unified to 𪇮.
Thanks Henry who mentioned 𪇮.
𧓋 (C12501) ~ 𧔊 (C12501-001)
𧸪 (C13655-002) ~ 𧸳 (C13655)
𨞬 ~ 鄽 (GHZR: 4054.04)
⿰金𠪨 (C15168-002) ~ 𨮻 (C15168)
⿰𧾷𠪨 (B04971-005) ~ 躔 (B04971)
⿵門𠪨 (C15366-001) ~ 𨷠 (TB-2215) 𨷭 (TB-2219)
⿺走𠪨 (C13847-002) ~ 𧾡 (C13847)
So it's okay to add UCV 𠪨~廛.
Sorry. I may not explain the information I listed in detail.
I use the “~” symbol for what I identify as a Z-variant relation (广义异写) (that may be unifiable). The parentheses indicate the source of the variation relation, e.g., an intercharacter relation identified by GHZR, GZH, GKX, or an intercharacter relation identified by the Variant Dictionary (using the same glyph number).
In particular, encoding determinations made during the Extension B period shall not be regarded as disunification due to different abstract shapes. So all of the examples I listed seem to me to be examples of what could be used as unification.
P.S. I may use “>” for what I identify as a Y-variant relation (广义异构) (that may be disunifiable), use “≁” for non-cognate, [...] for abstract shape (or abstract IDS), |...| for actual shape (or actual IDS), {*... (...)} for phonetic symbol field.
thank you for the clarification of your notation, because of your liberal use of ~ elsewhere, I was under the impression that by ~ you simply meant to indicate variant.
It is better to show the meaning of the number in the brackets. I guess they are the number used in current online version of 異體字字典 (maybe I am wrong). Not all the reviewers know. When you show information clearer, other reviewers will be easy to do the double checks.
Thank you! I will change to 𧓋 (DCCV: C12501), in which DCCV represents Dictionary of Chinese Character Variants (異體字字典).
I'm still thinking about how to design a proper notation system that simplifies the presentation and clarifies the concepts in ORT reviewing, so the notation system is still unstable, sorry.