Please wait while loading

IRG Working Set 2021v4.0

Source: Conifer TSENG
Date: Generated on 2024-11-10

Hide Deleted | Show comments from version: 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 6.0 7.0
The Image/Source column is displayed as it was in WS2021 v4.0. The character may have a different status in the latest working set.

Unification

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
03767
03767
言 149.6.1
SAT-07005
TS 13 · IDS
UCV
MOE Variant Dictionary


Based on 干祿字書, [⿰言⿱大干] is a variant of 誇.
However, if adding a new UCV=[⿱大干]/𡗢/夸, I think it is a bit dangerous, such as U+29A43 𩩃 is a variant of U+5E79 幹 or U+9AAD 骭, but it has no meaningful relationship with 骻 (U+9ABB).
02043
02043
水 85.9.2
T9-773B
TS 12 · IDS
UCV
If add a new UCV 句~勾, TCA agree to unify.
03297
03297
舟 137.3.3
T9-7E3E
TS 9 · IDS
Unification
If UCV (UCV# 54? )is added, TCA agree. Because 凢 is often used as the variant of 凡.
04325
04325
雨 173.10.3
TB-672B
TS 18 · IDS
Unification
According to the new rules (same components, different structure), TCA agree to be a VS of U+2A777.
02761
02761
石 112.7.3
TB-696C
TS 12 · IDS
Disunification
Not suitable for S.1.5.i, it is not a question of more or less stroke.
01276
01276
廾 55.7.3
TC-482E
TS 10 · IDS
Disunification
There is no UCV rule for these two lower components(开 and 廾).
02021
02021
水 85.7.3
TC-4B4B
TS 10 · IDS 𠘧
Unification
Because of the common component(盁), TCA has agreed to change the proposed form to TC-7234. But EVIDENCE is unable to provide the Table produced by the Household System, and TCA can provide the BMP glyph and attributes printed by Tax Center(財稅中心) in 2004 as new evidence.

UCV
TCA suggest adding new UCV rule盈 / 盁 /⿱𠂊皿/ ⿱𠘧皿.
01768
01768
木 75.3.1
TC-7739
TS 7 · IDS
Disunification
丂~亍 is not a common variant relationship. TCA agree with Kushim Jiang veiws, not unify.
02586
02586
田 102.7.3
TD-2D6E
TS 12 · IDS
Oppose Unification
Are we going to make a new UCV rule 田 and 日?
01490
01490
手 64.10.1
TD-3B4D
TS 13 · IDS
Unification
According to the new rules (same components, different structure), TCA agrees to be a VS of U+20E83.
01902
01902
欠 76.10.1
TD-4A24
TS 14 · IDS 𥞤
UCV
If a new UCV rule is added, TCA agree.
02624
02624
疒 104.9.3
TD-512B
TS 14 · IDS 𠂊
UCV
If UCV (勇~⿱⺈男)is added, TCA agree to unify.
03173
03173
羽 124.8.3
TD-536C
TS 14 · IDS
UCV
If UCV is added, TCA agree to unify.
03378
03378
艸 140.10.1
TD-5447
TS 14 · IDS
Unification
According to UCV #307c, TCA agree to be a VS of U+2BB9D.
04533
04533
髟 190.6.1
TD-724B
TS 16 · IDS
UCV
If UCV is added, TCA agree to unify.

Reading is a reference in the literature, but it is not suitable as a source of recognition in the use of names, as reading is a matter for the person concerned to decide.
02801
02801
石 112.12.2
TE-2622
TS 17 · IDS
Unification
According to new UCV #307c, TCA agrees to unify, and TCA wants to keep 02801(⿰石萑).

These two characters are a good case in which reading is based.
02950
02950
竹 118.11.1
TE-2668
TS 17 · IDS 𭅗
Unification
According to new UCV #307c, TCA agrees to unify, and TCA wants to keep 01856 (TE-2360, ⿰木⿱竹𭅗).
Unification
Is it possible to add a new UCV rule or modify #307c, when the same component, different structure could unify?
TCA found some examples as below:

WS2021-2097 ⿰氵蒿 VS 薃 U+8583


WS2021-01288 ⿰霖彡VS 霦 U+9726
WS2021-04325 ⿱雨倪 VS 𪝷 U+2A777


WS2021-02950 ⿱𥫗⿰木𭅗 VS WS2021-01856 ⿰木⿱𥫗𭅗
03102
03102
糸 120.12.2
TE-267D
TS 18 · IDS
Unification
According to UCV #307c, TCA agree to be a VS of U+2700A.
03427
03427
艸 140.13.4
TE-2766
TS 17 · IDS
Unification
According to UCV #307c, TCA agree to be a VS of U+6FF8.
03992
03992
辵 162.13.2
TE-292B
TS 17 · IDS
Unification
According to UCV #307c, TCA agree to unify with 𱾨 (U+31FA8).
03108
03108
糸 120.13.2
TE-367E
TS 19 · IDS
Unification
According to UCV #307c, TCA agree to be a VS of U+2706D.
03642
03642
虫 142.13.3
TE-3773
TS 19 · IDS
Unification
According to UCV rule #457, TCA agree to be a VS of U+87F9.
02980
02980
竹 118.15.1
TE-415D
TS 21 · IDS
Unification
According to the new rules (same components, different structure), TCA agrees to be a VS of U+255D6.
02982
02982
竹 118.16.1
TE-446F
TS 22 · IDS
Unification
According to the new rules (same components, different structure), TCA agrees to unify, and TCA wants to keep 01601(⿰扌簷).
03988
03988
辵 162.12.2
TE-6E7C
TS 16 · IDS
Unification
According to new UCV #307c, TCA agrees to unify to 𮑋 (U+2E44B).


Attributes

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
00506
00506
口 30.8.3
T9-7A3D
TS 11 · IDS
Radical
Agree to change the Radical to 135.0(舌).
00420
00420
又 29.9.1
TC-5644
TS 11 · IDS
Radical
Agree to change the Radical to 155.0(赤).
04009
04009
邑 163.3.5
TC-766C
TS 6 · IDS
IDS
To the comment #5442:
Prefer to use two IDSes (⿰子阝, ⿰孑阝) for this case.
00188
00188
人 9.10.4
TD-2261
TS 12 · IDS 𠈌
Radical
Keep radical 9.0(人), and add the second radical as 8.0 (亠).
02093
02093
水 85.13.2
TD-6B79
TS 16 · IDS
Radical
Agree to change the radical to 140.0艸.
00997
00997
女 38.11.1
TD-7A64
TS 14 · IDS
IDS
Maybe we chould use two IDSes for this case, ⿰女硏 and ⿰妬幵?
00660
00660
口 30.14.2
TE-214D
TS 17 · IDS
IDS
Keep 〾⿰口署, it is easier to understand.
01309
01309
彳 60.15.3
TE-2C27
TS 18 · IDS
IDS
Agree to change the IDS. (remove 〾)
04947
04947
齒 211.8.1
TE-354A
TS 20 · IDS
Radical
Agree to use 211.2 for 歯.
01029
01029
子 39.16.4
TE-787D
TS 19 · IDS 广𫲲
Radical
Agree to change the Radical to 53.0 (广).


Evidence

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
04595
04595
魚 195.8.1
GKJ-00221
TS 19 · IDS &S8-01;
Evidence
畢沅,《山海經新校正》(清光緒3年[1877],浙江書局),卷八

04698
04698
鳥 196.5.2
GKJ-00377
TS 16 · IDS
Evidence
MOE Variant Dictionary
04814
04814
鸟 196′.10.5
GKJ-00393
TS 15 · IDS
Evidence
The same book gives 阴” 骘” (the lower part is 马).


陳永正編,《中國方術大辭典》(廣東:中山大學出版社, 1991年)




p.369
04074
04074
金 167.7.1
GKJ-00492
TS 15 · IDS
Evidence
The source name could be from《重訂直音篇》卷5金部.
https://ctext.org/library.pl?if=gb&file=18574&page=9#box(302,293,1,2)
04093
04093
金 167.10.2
GKJ-00508
TS 18 · IDS
New evidence
重訂直音篇,卷5 金部
04196
04196
金 167.17.3
GKJ-00520
TS 25 · IDS
Evidence
(明)蘇祐,(明)楊循吉纂修, 《吳邑志》(明嘉靖[1522-1566]) 卷十四 物產
The submitted character might be a misprint form of 鏃?
02390
02390
犬 94.9.3
GKJ-00555
TB-5027
TS 12 · IDS
Evidence
Thank you for evidence.
03764
03764
言 149.4.1
GKJ-00627
TS 11 · IDS
New evidence
《謐齋金文拓本》
https://catalog.digitalarchives.tw/item/00/1b/b3/6d.html

04914
04914
鼠 208.6.1
GKJ-00658
TS 19 · IDS
Evidence
Could you confirm the meaning of “(444, 548)” in evidence 1?
03813
03813
豸 153.13.3
GKJ-00659
TS 20 · IDS
Unclear evidence
鄭子田著,《中國原始社會研究》(永祥印書館,1945年), P43.


According to the context, the author quoted "教熊羆『貔』貅貙虎" in 史記.五帝本紀 as an explanation, and it is very likely that "貔" is wrongly written as "豸鼠".

Suggest pending for additional evidences.
03789
03789
言 149.19.4
GKJ-00680
TS 26 · IDS 鹿
Evidence
Agree with #6000 and #9680. Consider pending with additional evidences.
03782
03782
言 149.11.4
GKJ-00696
TS 18 · IDS 鹿
Unclear evidence
Agree with WANG Yifan.

正字通,吳源起清畏堂, 康熙24 [1685] 序].
the character at this position is also 註.
04824
04824
鸟 196′.16.4
GKJ-00738
TS 21 · IDS
Evidence
(明)李時珍撰, 《本草綱目》(清順治十五年(1658)張朝璘刻本) 卷四十八
本草綱目 gives as “䴊”.


Agree with the comment #6325, suggest pending for additional evidences.
04424
04424
页 181′.6.3
GKJ-01020
TS 12 · IDS
Evidence
Agree with the comment #10073. If the source of the submitted character is 揚雄《方言》, U+310A5 is enough.
00186
00186
人 9.11.3
GZ-0542402
TB-4931
TS 13 · IDS
Evidence
Thank you for evidence.
00171
00171
人 9.9.3
KC-00160
TC-5166
TS 11 · IDS
Evidence
Thank you for evidence.
01438
01438
手 64.5.1
KC-05112
TC-323B
UTC-00638
TS 8 · IDS
Evidence
Thank you for evidence.
02004
02004
水 85.5.3
KC-05231
TC-3E43
TS 8 · IDS
Evidence
Thank you for evidence.
04449
04449
食 184.8.1
SAT-07200
TS 16 · IDS
New evidence
(遼)釋行均撰,《龍龕手鑑》,食部第十八
00968
00968
女 38.5.5
T9-7569
TS 8 · IDS
Evidence
TCA has found the handwritten form of this character.
02916
02916
立 117.9.4
T9-776C
TS 14 · IDS
Evidence
Thank you for evidence.
01658
01658
日 72.4.5
T9-7937
TS 8 · IDS
Evidence
Thank you for evidence.
02072
02072
水 85.11.2
TB-5021
TS 14 · IDS 浿
New evidence
TCA can provide the BMP glyph and attributes printed by Land System in 2006 as new evidence.

00496
00496
口 30.8.2
TB-5C55
TS 11 · IDS
Unclear evidence response
CMEX does not have the applicant's handwriting on the hand. However, we have found earlier BMP for the applicant. From the Changjie(倉頡) attribute provided, it was "日", not "月".

02492
02492
玉 96.10.1
TB-5D6F
TS 15 · IDS
Evidence
The pronunciation of " liú " was provided in the application for the code by the user unit (Landsystem). They have provided the original BMP and attributes.

02792
02792
石 112.11.3
TB-6250
TS 16 · IDS
Evidence
The pronunciation of " dùn " was provided in the application for the code by the user unit (Landsystem). They have provided the original BMP and attributes.

02761
02761
石 112.7.3
TB-696C
TS 12 · IDS
New evidence
TCA can provide the BMP glyph and attributes printed by Land System in 2006 as new evidence.

01067
01067
寸 41.7.4
TC-4743
TS 10 · IDS
New evidence
Because of the common structure, if IRG can accept our new evidence, TCA will agree to change the proposed form to TC-473B (NOT TC-3927).
Because evidence is unable to provide the Table produced by the Household System, and TCA can provide the BMP font printed by the MOI in 2004 as new evidence:
00836
00836
土 32.8.2
TC-5428
TS 11 · IDS
New evidence
We do not have the applicant's handwriting on the hand. However, TCA can provide the BMP glyph printed by MOI in 2004 as new evidence.

00975
00975
女 38.8.2
TC-6B46
TS 11 · IDS
New evidence
We do not have the applicant's handwriting on the hand. However, TCA can provide the BMP glyph and attributes printed by Tax Center(財稅中心) in 2004 as new evidence.
03456
03456
艸 140.15.2
TC-7C61
TS 21 · IDS
New evidence
Because of the common structure, TCA has agreed to change the proposed form to TE-4239, so EVIDENCE is unable to provide the Table produced by the Household System, and TCA can provide the BMP glyph printed by the MOI in 2004 as new evidence.

02489
02489
玉 96.9.4
TD-4022
TS 13 · IDS
New evidence
The reading was given by the user.

BMP font printed by MOI (2004):

04692
04692
鳥 196.4.3
TD-6722
TS 15 · IDS
New evidence
The reading was given by the user. It is a phonetic script.
BMP font printed by MOI (2004):
02398
02398
犬 94.9.4
TD-7521
TS 12 · IDS 𬙬
New evidence
Printed in 2007 by MOI including BMP:
02236
02236
火 86.13.2
TE-252E
TS 17 · IDS
Evidence
The reading was given by the user.
03083
03083
糸 120.10.2
TE-2725
TS 16 · IDS 𧆠
New evidence
Because of the common component, TCA has agreed to change the proposed form, so EVIDENCE is unable to provide the Table produced by the Household System, and TCA can only provide the BMP form used by the MOI in the early days as Evidence.


New evidence
The whole page evidence as below:
03090
03090
糸 120.11.1
TE-2728
TS 17 · IDS
New evidence
These two characters belong to different places of residence (as can be seen from the evidence provided by TCA) and the BMP shapes are also different. (printed by MOI in 2004):


02968
02968
竹 118.12.4
TE-2F2B
TS 18 · IDS 𪲪
New evidence
TCA can provide the BMP font printed by MOI in 2004 as new evidence.
03031
03031
米 119.12.5
TE-2F3A
TS 18 · IDS
New evidence
TCA can provide the BMP font printed by MOI in 2004 as new evidence.
03038
03038
米 119.13.4
TE-3679
TS 19 · IDS 𭵝
New evidence
TCA can provide the BMP glyph and attributes printed by MOI in 2004 as new evidence.

02944
02944
竹 118.10.2
TE-6F79
TS 16 · IDS
New evidence
TCA can provide the BMP font printed by MOI in 2007 as new evidence.
01183
01183
山 46.13.1
TE-7132
TS 16 · IDS
New evidence
TCA can provide the BMP font printed by MOI in 2007 as new evidence.
02013
02013
水 85.6.3
TF-7E7C
TS 9 · IDS
New evidence
User thought it’s a phonetic script. Please look at the evidence.
04501
04501
馬 187.6.4
UK-20091
TS 16 · IDS
Evidence
Depending on the context, it might be 𩣰?
04495
04495
馬 187.4.4
UK-20092
TS 14 · IDS
Evidence
The new evidence from 九家集注杜詩(#6539), it could be an error form of 魴.

《後漢書》(金陵书局清同治八年[1869]), 卷三十三 朱馮虞鄭周列傳第二十三
03870
03870
足 157.4.1
UK-20186
TS 11 · IDS 𧾷
Evidence
愛山書院。光緖癸未[1884]。重校刊。同治9-13年重修。
The other edition gives 竑弢.


Agree with the comment #5171.
01362
01362
心 61.11.1
UK-20252
TS 15 · IDS
New evidence
《康熙字典》心部.12畫
(武英殿本:1920頁)
(同文書局本:402頁)


Glyph Design & Normalization

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
04574
04574
魚 195.4.1
GKJ-00261
TS 15 · IDS
Glyph design
The glyph should be updated to ⿰魚天.
02888
02888
禾 115.12.5
T9-7C5F
TS 17 · IDS
Glyph design
TCA will provide new TTF font.
01695
01695
日 72.11.3
TB-4B46
TS 15 · IDS
Glyph design
TCA will pass your suggestion to MOE/ MOI.


Editorial

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
04295
04295
雨 173.4.2
UK-20811
TS 12 · IDS
Editorial issue
Based on the comment #7974,this character should be withdrawn.


Other

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
04786
04786
鳥 196.15.1
GKJ-00361
TS 26 · IDS
Comment
鷖, 鷗鳥也. The submitted character might be mixed with “鷖” and “鷗”.
04205
04205
金 167.29.3
GKJ-00828
TS 37 · IDS
Comment
Based on these evidences, the submitted character was originally from 化學指南(1873) by 畢利幹(Anatole Billequin). Could you provide the clear evidence of the original glyph in this book?
03743
03743
見 147.14.3
GKJ-00995
TS 21 · IDS
Comment
A variant of 覰?
00001
00001
一 1.0.0
SAT-05947
TS 1 · IDS
Comment
From the pronunciation of 廣韻 and 集韻, "厥" is "居月切" (same with 孓).
Possibly, the reading given by 慧琳 was wrong.
01642
01642
方 70.9.3
TB-5029
TS 13 · IDS 便
Comment
The reading biān was provided by user.
01657
01657
日 72.4.3
TB-5D3F
TS 8 · IDS
Comment
These two characters are not related, and their origins are in the Land system(TB-5D3F) and the household system(TC-3C54) separately.
02102
02102
水 85.14.1
TB-606C
TS 17 · IDS 𬚟
Comment
The reading provided by the user is "zhuī ". Look at the evidence.


Perhaps TCA could ask the experts to discuss the possibility of adding a reading (yǎ, because 𬚟 is a variant of 雅).
01833
01833
木 75.11.4
TB-6D6E
TS 15 · IDS
Comment
TCA agrees with your comment. However, the reading provided by the user is "jiǎo". Look at the evidence.
Other
Perhaps TCA could ask the experts to discuss the possibility of adding a reading (zhān).
03006
03006
米 119.4.5
TC-4E64
TS 10 · IDS
Comment
For the comment #12959:
Thank you for the new evidence.
01349
01349
心 61.9.4
TD-7640
TS 13 · IDS 𦍍
Comment
TCA will not submit both two characters, we choose TD-7640 because this character used by more people.
02106
02106
水 85.14.3
TE-244F
TS 17 · IDS
Comment
Not unify, no UCV rule.
04039
04039
酉 164.13.1
TE-3E26
TS 20 · IDS
Other
The reading not filled in by the household staff.
03900
03900
足 157.11.3
UK-20221
TS 18 · IDS 𧾷
Comment
扈蹕→⿰𧾷扈蹕, it could be a phenomenon of "偏旁同化". Such as 展轉→輾轉.
https://baike.baidu.com/item/%E5%81%8F%E6%97%81%E5%90%8C%E5%8C%96/683399
04534
04534
髟 190.8.1
UK-20454
TS 18 · IDS
Comment
A variant of 髼(U+9AFC)?


元.龔瑨, 〈王會圖賦〉(《古今圖書集成本》)