Ken LUNDE Comments | WS2021v1.0

IRG Working Set 2021v1.0

Source: Ken LUNDE
Date: Generated on 2024-10-10

Show Deleted | Show comments from version: 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 6.0 7.0

The Image/Source column is displayed as it was in WS2021 v1.0. The character may have a different status in the latest working set.

Unification

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
04228	04228 門 169.8.2 KC-06061 TS 8 · IDS ？	Unification	Agree with Eiso.
00701	00701 口 30.16.1 UTC-00372 TS 19 · IDS ⿰口頼	Unification	Agree to unify with 𡃤 (U+210E4) per UCV #324
00709	00709 口 30.16.2 UTC-00427 TS 19 · IDS ⿰口蕉	Unification	Agree
00569	00569 口 30.10.4 UTC-00441 TS 13 · IDS ⿰口窄	Unification	Agree with Eiso. UTC-00441 was included in the UTC's submission for IRG Working Set 2021, because U+9FFD (MC-00134) is not yet encoded, but is expected to be included in Unicode Version 14.0, which will be released in September. Shown is U+9FFD from the Unicode Version 14.0 Beta code charts.
00214	00214 人 9.14.3 UTC-00445 TS 16 · IDS ⿰亻㬱	Unification	Agree to unify with 僭 (U+50ED) by extending UCV #213
00196	00196 人 9.11.5 UTC-00498 TS 13 · IDS ⿰亻隆	Unification	Agree
00232	00232 人 9.17.1 UTC-00536 TS 19 · IDS ⿰亻⿱覀國	Unification	Agree
01028	01028 子 39.14.3 UTC-00623 TS 17 · IDS ⿰孑蜚	Unification	Agree
01386	01386 心 61.13.2 UTC-00631 TS 16 · IDS ⿰忄盟	Unification	Agree
01434	01434 手 64.4.1 UTC-00636 TS 8 · IDS ⿱切手	Unification	Agree
01450	01450 手 64.5.5 UTC-00637 TS 9 · IDS ⿱弗手	Unification	Agree
01442	01442 手 64.5.1 UTC-00638 TS 8 · IDS ⿰扌卉	Unification	Agree
01515	01515 手 64.11.4 UTC-00647 TS 14 · IDS ⿰扌庵	Unification	Agree
01528	01528 手 64.12.2 UTC-00652 TS 15 · IDS ⿰扌幂	Unification	Agree
01550	01550 手 64.13.2 UTC-00653 TS 16 · IDS ⿰扌罨	Unification	Agree
01545	01545 手 64.13.1 UTC-00656 TS 17 · IDS ⿱⿸厂𤞣手	Unification	Agree to unify with 擪 (U+64EA)
01572	01572 手 64.15.1 UTC-00659 TS 18 · IDS ⿰扌厲	Unification	Agree
01591	01591 手 64.17.1 UTC-00661 TS 20 · IDS ⿲扌束員	Unification	Agree to unify with 攋 (U+650B)
01705	01705 日 72.12.3 UTC-00667 TS 16 · IDS ⿰日禽	Unification	Agree
01835	01835 木 75.11.4 UTC-00671 TS 15 · IDS ⿰木窒	Unification	Agree
01946	01946 毛 82.7.4 UTC-00682 TS 11 · IDS ⿱冷毛	Unification	Agree
02045	02045 水 85.9.2 UTC-00689 TS 13 · IDS ⿱削水	Unification	Agree
02252	02252 火 86.14.4 UTC-00697 TS 18 · IDS ⿱辣灬	Unification	Agree
02277	02277 爪 87.6.1 UTC-00699 TS 10 · IDS ⿺爪圭	Unification	Agree
02541	02541 瓜 97.4.3 UTC-00701 TS 9 · IDS ⿰爿瓜	Unification	Agree
02662	02662 皮 107.8.1 UTC-00709 TS 13 · IDS ⿰皮奄	Unification	Agree
02666	02666 皮 107.11.5 UTC-00711 TS 16 · IDS ⿰皮巢	Unification	Agree
02684	02684 目 109.2.3 UTC-00712 TS 7 · IDS ⿰目乃	Unification	Agree
03089	03089 糸 120.10.5 UTC-00723 TS 16 · IDS ⿱能糸	Unification	Agree
03495	03495 虍 141.5.3 UTC-00742 TS 11 · IDS ⿺虎下	Unification	Agree
02246	02246 火 86.13.5 UTC-00766 TS 17 · IDS ⿱隆灬	Unification	Agree
01546	01546 手 64.13.1 UTC-00768 TS 17 · IDS ⿱靴手	Unification	Agree
00353	00353 勹 20.7.3 UTC-00778 TS 9 · IDS ⿱勿正	Unification	Agree
01556	01556 手 64.13.3 UTC-00787 TS 16 · IDS ⿰扌鼠	Unification	Agree
02747	02747 石 112.5.1 UTC-03168 TS 10 · IDS ⿰石东	Disunification	According to the document that requested that this ideograph be added to UAX #45 for a future submission to the IRG, https://www.unicode.org/L2/L2018/18064-add-uax45-chars.pdf, this ideograph is the simplified form of U+254DD 𥓝, and that U+2C483 𬒃 is the simplified form of 02778 of IRG Working Set 2021 (aka UTC-03169).
02747	02747 石 112.5.1 UTC-03168 TS 10 · IDS ⿰石东	Unification	Agree with Eiso
02778	02778 石 112.9.1 UTC-03169 TS 14 · IDS ⿰石柬	Unification	Agree
04238	04238 門 169.11.3 UTC-03180 TS 19 · IDS ⿵門⿱自夲	Unification	Further discussion is necessary before unification with 闑 (U+95D1) can be considered
01363	01363 心 61.11.1 UTC-03181 TS 15 · IDS ⿱⿵𡗗⿱丿罒心	Unification	Further discussion is necessary before unification with 憃 (U+6183) can be considered
03505	03505 虫 142.3.3 UTC-03182 TS 9 · IDS ⿰虫千	Oppose Unification	Disagree to unify with 虷 (U+8677) per new evidence
03804	03804 豸 153.3.3 UTC-03183 TS 10 · IDS ⿰豸千	Unification	Further discussion is necessary before unification with 豻 (U+8C7B) can be considered
04553	04553 鬼 194.5.1 UTC-03184 TS 15 · IDS ⿺鬼戊	Unification	Further discussion is necessary before unification with 魆 (U+9B46) can be considered
02380	02380 犬 94.8.3 UTC-03186 TS 11 · IDS ⿰犭𫤘	Unification	Further discussion is necessary before unification with 猊 (U+730A) can be considered
03787	03787 言 149.13.3 UTC-03187 TS 20 · IDS ⿲訁⿳丿罒工殳	Unification	Further discussion is necessary before unification with 譭 (U+8B6D) can be considered
00155	00155 人 9.8.1 UTC-03188 TS 10 · IDS ⿰亻靣	Unification	Agree to unify with 偭 (U+506D); agree to remove NUCV #317
00450	00450 口 30.5.5 UTC-03197 TS 8 · IDS ⿰口毋	Oppose Unification	Disagree to unify with 呣 (U+5463) per Henry's comments
00359	00359 勹 20.15.3 UTC-03200 TS 17 · IDS ⿰勿愛	Unification	Agree
01760	01760 月 74.14.1 UTC-03203 TS 18 · IDS ⿰月赫	Unification	Agree
00722	00722 口 30.16.5 UTC-03218 TS 19 · IDS ⿰口壁	Unification	Agree
00031	00031 丿 4.5.2 UTC-03219 TS 6 · IDS ⿸𠂝丶	Unification	Agree
00913	00913 土 32.15.1 UTC-03228 TS 18 · IDS ⿰土𮧌	Unification	Further discussion is necessary before unification with 墻 (U+58BB) or U+2BBB0 𫮰 can be considered
01259	01259 广 53.9.3 UTC-03230 TS 12 · IDS ⿱𠂊⿸广？	Unification	Agree to unify with 𫝖 (U+2B756)

Attributes

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
01583	01583 手 64.15.5 UTC-00394 TS 18 · IDS ⿰扌⿱辟力	IDS	Agree to change IDS to ⿰扌劈.
02242	02242 火 86.13.3 UTC-00398 TS 17 · IDS ⿰火⿱保𧘇	IDS	Change IDS to ⿰火⿱保衣 to match first evidence and representative glyph.
		Residual Stroke Count	Change SC from 13 to 15.
		Total Stroke Count	Change TC from 17 to 19.
00577	00577 口 30.11.1 UTC-00455 TS 14 · IDS ⿰口⿱𡥅皿	IDS	Per the discussion above, change the IDS to ⿰口掹.
01760	01760 月 74.14.1 UTC-03203 TS 18 · IDS ⿰月赫	Radical	Agree with Eiso.

Evidence

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
00020	00020 丨 2.3.1 SAT-01301 TS 4 · IDS ⿰丨キ	Misidentified glyph	I agree with the UK. This is clearly a katakana ligature, and should be submitted as a regular character, to be treated like U+30FF ヿ KATAKANA DIGRAPH KOTO.
00020	00020 丨 2.3.1 SAT-01301 TS 4 · IDS ⿰丨キ	New evidence	This evidence is page 2 of 国字の字典 (1990) that also shows U+30FF ヿ KATAKANA DIGRAPH KOTO highlighted in green.
00021	00021 丨 2.4.1 SAT-01303 TS 5 · IDS ⿰丨云	New evidence	There are a non-trivial number of ideographs that include jamo as components, and this hybrid katakana (ト) + ideograph (云) is really no different. This evidence is page 2 of 国字の字典 (1990).
01545	01545 手 64.13.1 UTC-00656 TS 17 · IDS ⿱⿸厂𤞣手	New evidence	Below are evidence images from Dr. Cheung Kwan-him that support unification with U+64EA 擪:
00578	00578 口 30.11.1 UTC-03216 TS 14 · IDS ⿰口梃	New evidence	New evidence from "Cantonese Dictionary: Cantonese-English, English-Cantonese," Parker Po-fei Huang, Yale University Press (1970), p446.

Glyph Design & Normalization

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
00486	00486 口 30.7.5 UTC-00332 TS 10 · IDS ⿰口𥁀	Glyph design	The upper-right component of the representative glyph will be changed from 力 to 刀 to match the evidence and IDS.
01583	01583 手 64.15.5 UTC-00394 TS 18 · IDS ⿰扌⿱辟力	Normalization	Agree to normalize glyph to use 刀 as the lower-right component.
00577	00577 口 30.11.1 UTC-00455 TS 14 · IDS ⿰口⿱𡥅皿	Glyph design	Two of the three pieces of evidence, the latest having been added by Eiso, show ⿰口掹 as the glyph, so the glyph will remain unchanged. Will add another comment to change IDS.
02003	02003 水 85.5.2 UTC-00456 TS 8 · IDS ⿰氵𠕄	Glyph design	Agree with Andrew and Eiso.

Data for Unihan

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
02778	02778 石 112.9.1 UTC-03169 TS 14 · IDS ⿰石柬	Simp variant	U+2C483 𬒃
02877	02877 禾 115.8.4 UTC-03209 TS 13 · IDS ⿰禾斉	Trad variant	U+7A67 穧
02877	02877 禾 115.8.4 UTC-03209 TS 13 · IDS ⿰禾斉	Trad variant	Agree with Jaemin disagreeing with me, and hereby retract my suggestion to associate U+7A67 穧 as this ideograph's kTraditionalVariant property value.