Please wait while loading

IRG Working Set 2021v5.0

Source: Ken LUNDE
Date: Generated on 2024-10-10

Show Deleted | Show comments from version: 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 6.0 7.0
The Image/Source column is displayed as it was in WS2021 v5.0. The character may have a different status in the latest working set.

Unification

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
02899
02899
穴 116.7.2
GDM-00313
TS 12 · IDS
Oppose Unification
This ideograph was present in the first and second drafts of GB 18030-2022 Amendment 1, specifically in the Plane 10 repertoire at U+A015F and U+A0271, respectively. It was also included in the first draft of the CJK Unified Ideographs Extension I repertoire at U+2EC5E. At the end of June, per feedback from China, nearly 50 ideographs were removed from the Extension I repertoire, almost all of which were in this working set. One can reasonably conclude that China expected them to remain in this working set, otherwise they would not have been removed. If China had not requested that those ideographs be removed, this particular ideograph would already be encoded in Extension I, and this entire discussion would be moot.

Given the sheer amount of discussion, it would be prudent for the IRG to err on the side of disunification in this particular case. What I wrote in the previous paragraph can also not be ignored. Let us accept this ideograph and move on to more important issues in this working set.
04782
04782
鳥 196.14.1
GKJ-00303
TS 25 · IDS 𠪨
UCV
Will a new UCV be added to handle this unification?
03519
03519
虫 142.5.4
GKJ-00401
TS 11 · IDS
Unification
U+2EDBD
This ideograph is present in the CJK Unified Ideographs Extension I block at code point U+2EDBD. This block is now frozen and stable for Unicode Version 15.1. This character should therefore be removed. from this working set.

03698
03698
衣 145.4.1
SAT-06753
TS 10 · IDS 𧘇
Unification
Agree with UK.
04034
04034
酉 164.10.2
V0-4562
TS 17 · IDS
Unification
U+288BB
Is this to be unified with 𨢻 (U+288BB), which is a single-source V-source ideograph? There have been no comments thus far, hence the question.


Attributes

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
02899
02899
穴 116.7.2
GDM-00313
TS 12 · IDS
Radical
Change Radical to 40.0 (宀), SC=9, FS=4
03825
03825
貝 154.9.1
GDM-00316
TS 13 · IDS
Radical
Change Radical to 154.1 (贝).
04595
04595
魚 195.8.1
GKJ-00221
TS 19 · IDS &S8-01;
Residual Stroke Count
SC = 7
Total Stroke Count
TS = 18
IDS
⿰魚&S7-01;
IDS
For the right-side component, see #00005 in this working set.
04892
04892
黍 202.11.3
GKJ-00241
TS 23 · IDS
Radical
Add Radical 195.0 (魚) as secondary radical with SC=12 and FS=3
04653
04653
魚 195.15.4
GKJ-00256
TS 26 · IDS
Residual Stroke Count
SC = 16
Total Stroke Count
TS = 27
04888
04888
麥 199.11.3
GKJ-00264
TS 22 · IDS
Radical
Add Radical 195.0 (魚) as secondary radical with FS=1
04683
04683
鱼 195′.15.1
GKJ-00287
TS 23 · IDS
Residual Stroke Count
SC = 16
Total Stroke Count
TS = 24
04186
04186
金 167.15.4
言 149.16.3
GKJ-00507
TS 23 · IDS
Radical
I agree with Henry.
03887
03887
足 157.8.3
GKJ-00513
TS 15 · IDS 𧾷
Radical
Add 167.0 (金) as secondary radical, SC=7, FS=2
04808
04808
鸟 196′.8.1
GKJ-00769
TS 13 · IDS
Radical
Add Radical 173.0 (雨) as secondary radical with SC=11 and FS=3
03927
03927
身 158.8.1
GKJ-00954
TS 15 · IDS
Residual Stroke Count
SC = 6
Total Stroke Count
TS = 13
IDS
⿰身亚
04537
04537
髟 190.9.3
GKJ-00990
TS 19 · IDS
Radical
Add Radical 182.0 (風) as secondary radical with SC=10 and FS=1.
04222
04222
門 169.6.4
GZ-0801301
TS 15 · IDS
Residual Stroke Count
SC = 8
Total Stroke Count
TS = 16
03719
03719
衣 145.10.2
GZ-1102402
TS 15 · IDS
Total Stroke Count
TS = 16
03701
03701
衣 145.5.2
GZ-2461502
TS 10 · IDS
Total Stroke Count
TS = 11
03966
03966
辵 162.7.1
GZ-3481505
TS 10 · IDS
Total Stroke Count
TS = 11
03699
03699
衣 145.4.3
GZ-5131401
TS 9 · IDS
Total Stroke Count
TS = 10
03875
03875
足 157.5.3
SAT-06785
TS 12 · IDS 𧾷𢩥
Residual Stroke Count
SC = 6
Total Stroke Count
TS = 13
IDS
⿰𧾷⿱千兀 might be a better IDS.
03732
03732
襾 146.8.3
TC-6C5A
TS 14 · IDS
Radical
Add 175.0 (非) as secondary radical, SC=6, FS=1
04434
04434
風 182.9.3
TE-3264
TS 18 · IDS
Radical
Add Radical 186.0 (香) as secondary radical.
03950
03950
車 159.12.4
TE-3857
TS 19 · IDS
IDS
⿰車戠 (remove leading 〾)
04716
04716
鳥 196.8.1
TE-3A3A
TS 19 · IDS
Residual Stroke Count
SC = 7
Total Stroke Count
TS = 18
04492
04492
香 186.12.1
TE-3F68
TS 21 · IDS
Radical
Add Radical 27.0 (厂) as secondary radical with SC=19 and FS=3
03900
03900
足 157.4.3
UK-20221
TS 18 · IDS 𧾷
Residual Stroke Count
SC = 11
00196
00196
人 9.11.5
UK-20297
UTC-00498
TS 13 · IDS
Residual Stroke Count
Agree with #13718
04411
04411
頁 181.6.4
UK-20442
TS 15 · IDS
Radical
Add Radical 137.0 (舟) as secondary radical with SC=9
04431
04431
風 182.9.1
UK-20497
TS 18 · IDS
Radical
Add Radical 177.0 (革) as secondary radical with FS=3.
04315
04315
雨 173.8.3
UK-20712
TS 16 · IDS
IDS
Change IDS to ⿱雨⿰⿸⿰丿𠃌𠃌⿺几彡
04473
04473
饣 184′.10.3
UK-20802
TS 13 · IDS
Radical
Add Radical 194.0 (鬼) as secondary radical with SC=3
01631
01631
文 67.14.5
UTC-00664
TS 18 · IDS
Radical
I disagree with #13813. The current specified radical is the most intuitive. Adding Radical #108 as a secondary radical is acceptable.
04242
04242
門 169.14.5
V0-4925
TS 22 · IDS
Residual Stroke Count
SC = 13 ?
Total Stroke Count
TS = 22 ?
04485
04485
香 186.2.5
VN-F0640
TS 11 · IDS
Radical
Add Radical 19.0 (力) as secondary with SC=9 and FS=3.
00005
00005
一 1.6.5
VN-F0BEA
TS 7 · IDS &S8-01;
Radical
Change Radical to 212.0 (龍), SC=-9 (negative), FS=0
04240
04240
門 169.11.4
VN-F1690
TS 19 · IDS
Radical
Add Radical 15.0 (冫) as secondary radical with SC=17
04830
04830
鹵 197.13.4
VN-F1855
TS 24 · IDS
Radical
Add Radical 61.0 (心) as secondary radical with SC=20 and FS=2
03836
03836
貝 154.15.1
VN-F1903
TS 21 · IDS 𬑉
Total Stroke Count
TS = 22
03983
03983
辵 162.11.3
VN-F19B0
TS 15 · IDS
Radical
Radical 82.0 (毛) is much more intuitive for this ideograph.
04443
04443
食 184.5.2
VN-F1C0B
TS 13 · IDS
Residual Stroke Count
SC = 6
Total Stroke Count
TS = 14
04478
04478
首 185.7.1
VN-F1C15
TS 16 · IDS
Radical
Add Radical 151.0 (豆) as secondary radical with SC=9 and FS=4
04050
04050
里 166.7.3
VN-F1C9E
TS 14 · IDS
Radical
Change Radical to 101.0 (用), SC=9, FS=3 (unchanged)
04289
04289
隹 172.9.4
VN-F1CAD
TS 17 · IDS
Radical
Radical 8.0 (亠) with SC=15 would be much more intuitive
04252
04252
门 169′.14.1
VN-F1CB7
TS 17 · IDS 𫔭
Radical
Change Radical to 187.0 (馬), SC=7, because it i much more intuitive.
03863
03863
走 156.10.5
VN-F1CBE
TS 17 · IDS
IDS
⿺走⿰己豸 would be a more faithful IDS based on the enclosing structure.


Glyph Design & Normalization

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
03735
03735
見 147.2.4
VN-F07B9
TS 9 · IDS 𬼀
Glyph design
Agree with UK about representative glyph and IDS: #9473


Editorial

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
04597
04597
魚 195.8.1
GKJ-00259
TS 19 · IDS
Editorial issue
Unclipped evidence was provided, so should this still be postponed?
04683
04683
鱼 195′.15.1
GKJ-00287
TS 23 · IDS
Editorial issue
Why is this character still postponed?
04937
04937
鼠 208.11.3
鳥 196.13.3
GKJ-00302
TS 24 · IDS
Editorial issue
The primary and secondary radicals should be swapped so that the primary radical agrees with U+32387 𲎇.
04741
04741
鳥 196.9.5
GKJ-00339
TS 20 · IDS
Editorial issue
Why is this character still pending if it has been unified?
04700
04700
鳥 196.6.1
GKJ-00341
TS 17 · IDS
Editorial issue
There appears to be some unfinished business here. Whether the components are top/bottom or left/right is not clear, and needs to be resolved.
04862
04862
鹿 198.8.1
GKJ-00701
TE-3A4D
TS 19 · IDS 鹿
Editorial issue
Given that these were unified, shouldn't secondary SC (9), FS (4), and TS (20) values be added per #3851 and #3855, and #3856?
04668
04668
鱼 195′.6.3
GKJ-00759
TS 14 · IDS
Editorial issue
Per #13165, this character should have been withdrawn.
04744
04744
鳥 196.10.1
SAT-07198
TS 21 · IDS 𣪊
Editorial issue
Some action seems to be needed for this character.
04338
04338
雨 173.11.3
TE-7835
TS 19 · IDS
Editorial issue
Does this postponed character need to be revisited? The last comment was from Version 1.0.
04733
04733
鳥 196.9.2
UK-20658
TS 20 · IDS
Editorial issue
Is this character still postponed?
04490
04490
香 186.10.3
UK-20885
TS 19 · IDS
Editorial issue
Is this still postponed?


Data for Unihan

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
04356
04356
雨 173.14.4
UK-20710
TS 22 · IDS
Unihan data
👀
04008
04008
辵 162.36.2
UTC-03214
TS 40 · IDS
Unihan data
kJapanese あまのはしだて
00411
00411
厂 27.54.1
UTC-03221
TS 56 · IDS
Unihan data
kJapanese あまのはしだて


Submitter Request

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
01615
01615
攴 66.12.1
UTC-03224
TS 16 · IDS
Withdraw
The UTC agrees to withdraw this character.