Agree, TS=8

Agree with Lee to update the FS as 3.

Agree, FS=3

SC=16, TS=17

⿽见丨

⿹了丶

⿰尾童

SC=6, TS=12


IRG N2862R #6Hc

⿱艹汨

The evidence shows it is the variant of 荡/蕩, and the top component of 昜 is 日 not 曰, so 汨 is more suitable.

3

⿵门⿱𰁜大

Based on three pieces of evidence (2 submitted and 1 new), the glyph should be ⿵门⿱𰁜大 not ⿵门奕. Evidence 1 shows the Putonghua reading is luán, that means the top of the inside part is 𰁜, the variant of 䜌 not 亦.

In PRC conventions, 𰁜 and 亦 are not the same. So, the theoretical traditional form should be ⿵門⿱䜌大 not ⿵門奕.

We can find 峦塘 and 栾塘 in 永福县.

⿱竹𫜹

FS=3

SC=13, TS=17

IDS has not been updated to ⿵门屯

Add ⿰贝睿 for UTC-03291.

⿰氵棑 will be better?

FS=2

IDS has not been changed to ⿺風卜 yet.

Change Radical to 5.0 (乙), SC=4, FS=1

Based on the evidence, Component ⺄ is the variant of Component 雨 (⻗), and 支 is the phonetic element (老借 ci, cei, 新借 cih).

cf.
U+2B86E 𫡮



U+31380 𱎀



U+31388 𱎈

SC=3, TS=11 if Comment #9949 been accepted.

⿰⿹节丿⿹节丿

⿰扌𤉽?

The radical comes from 上 (1.2), so the current FS value (1) is OK now.

IDS has not been updated to ⿰亻𭆹.

The better IDS is ⿰氵𫯓.

The semantic element is 氵(<水), the phonetic element is 𫯓 (S=多, P=來).



If the submitter hopes to keep the current IDS, it is also OK.

We need a rule to confirm the radical of the structure ⿰磨X

Rad=石
WS2024-02723 ⿰磨木 (L:S, R:P)

02723

石 112.15.4

木 75.16.4

GZ-3352502

TS 20 · IDS ⿰磨木

R(2)=75.0 (木), SC(2)=16, FS(2)=4, IRG 63.

WS2024-02724 ⿰磨古 (L:S, R:P)

02724

石 112.16.4

麻 200.10.1

VN-F03D6

TS 21 · IDS ⿰磨古

WS2024-02727 ⿰磨告 (L:S, R:P)

02727

石 112.18.4

GZ-3761101

TS 23 · IDS ⿰磨告

Rad=麻
WS2024-02724 ⿰磨古 (L:S, R:P)

Rad=rad of X
WS2024-02723 ⿰磨木 (L:S, R:P)
U+287D6 𨟖 (L:P, R:S)
U+31426 𱐦 (L:P, R:S)
U+32389 𲎉 (L:P, R:S)

See Comment #12723 under WS2024-02723.

02723

石 112.15.4

木 75.16.4

GZ-3352502

TS 20 · IDS ⿰磨木

R(2)=75.0 (木), SC(2)=16, FS(2)=4, IRG 63.

The following characters with the structure ⿺亮X shows the radicals are all #8 (亠).

U+30060 𰁠


U+31399 𱎙


U+32412 𲐒
[WS2021-00124]

亮 reads liengh (老借) and lieng (新借); 展 reads cienj (老借) and canj (新借).

FS=2

IDS has not been changed to ⿺风朋 yet.

⿺荒无

⿰氵𤉹

⿲彳𮱨攵

Update to ⿱䶹囷 after the glyph been modified to match the evidence.

⿳宀十𣌢

⿱𫇦殘

⿰馬誊

⿱⿰彖攵皿

⿰牛華

IDS has not been changed to ⿱𡙁田.

⿱⿻十𠈌回

⿰𠯳頁

⿸疒不

不 in the submitted IDS is U+F967

⿱敬日

⿺廴己

Comments #90 and #5395 has not been resolved yet.

⿱日必

See the radical

IDS has not been updated to ⿱宀夐.

⿴〇⿻冂𠃊

Add the secondary radical as 164.0 (酉), SC=19, FS=3

The radical of 釁 is 酉.

⿰⿱罒⿺⿽十二二毛 or ⿰⿱罒𠦂毛

Add the secondary radical as 8.0 (亠), SC=10, FS=4

It is the variant of 𢼶 and 𣁊.

⿰亻⿱山⿻龰⺕

⿰犭⿱山黒

SC=15, TS=18?

This rule has been added to IRG N2862.

⿹⺄月 will be better.

⿰⿱⺈田炎

The secondary IDS as ⿰⿳亠回且包 to match the glyph.

As Comment #12324 shows, we need to count the stroke counts as 肙.

SC=7, FS=2, TS=10

If IRG agrees, I will add the following rule.
Add 肙/䏍, FS=2, SC=7

Change Radical to 104.0 (疒), SC=7, FS=5?

See Comment #12601 under WS2024-02316.

Change Radical to 104.0 (疒), SC=9, FS=4?

See Comment #12601 under WS2024-02316.

Change Radical to 104.0 (疒), SC=10, FS=4?

See Comment #12601 under WS2024-02316.

Change Radical to 104.0 (疒), SC=11, FS=2?

See Comment #12601 under WS2024-02316.

⿰忄⿻人口

⿱𦲶一

⿰𧾷⿱山⿻龰⺕

⿰忄⿱山母

There are three sources under U+21D0B 𡴋.



GKX-0305.11: ⿱屮母
T4-262D, JMJ-034444: ⿱䶹母

On the other hand, SAT-10062 is ⿱山母, which is the same as TC-313C, and SAT-10062 and TC-313C are both related to 每.

If SAT has plan to unify SAT-10062 (⿱山母) to U+21D0B 𡴋 per UCV #96 (lv. 2), it is OK to keep current IDS.

⿰扌⿱穴友

It is also normalized the glyph to match IDS and Evidence 2 not 3.

⿰𧾷花

IDS is also needed to updated.

⿰禾𥹺

⿰火⿳日龷⿺⿽十仌仌 or ⿰火⿳日艹⿻丅⿱从丛 or ⿰火⿳日龷⿻丨⿱从丛

⿳厶⿲〾刃工氏⿳一⺍？

The component at the bottom is unclear.

Change Radical to 28.0 (厶), SC=15, FS=5, TS=18

口 is not here after updating the glyph.

⿰𠯓刂

IDS has not been changed to ⿷匸拖.

IDS has not been changed to ⿰口⿱艹⿰𮍌卜.

⿰口⿱𱖴水

also ⿰口⿺⿱田儿其

⿲口馬𬯵

⿱雨旣

or normalize the glyph to match current IDS.

SC=16, TS=24

Count the value for ⿱雨勳.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼一.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as the same as 10, so TS=11.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼太.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as the same as 10, so TS=14.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼孔.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as the same as 10, so TS=14.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼日.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as the same as 10, so TS=14.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼右.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as the same as 10, so TS=15.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼玉.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as the same as 10, so TS=15.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼向.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as the same as 10, so TS=16.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼安.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as the same as 10, so TS=16.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼曲.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as the same as 10, so TS=16.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼虫.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as the same as 10, so TS=16.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼志.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=17.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼折.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=17.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼灴.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=17.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼灼.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=17.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼辛.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=17.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼制.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=18.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼定.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=18.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼幸.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=18.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼青.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=18.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼俞.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=19.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼兹.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=19.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼律.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=19.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼炫.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=19.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼炳.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=19.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼皇.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=19.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼勑.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=20.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼朒.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=20.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼烘.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=20.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼烜.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=20.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼烟.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=20.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼舀.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=20.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼蚓.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=20.

The current glyph shows ⿺⿱田儿⿰⿳人乛口牛, which matches the evidence.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼執.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=21.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼𡝤, ⿺鬼婁.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=21.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼張.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=21.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼絃.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=21.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼蛇.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=21.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼𬊒.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=21.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼景.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=22.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼晶.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=22.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼淼.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=22.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼華.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=22.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼軸.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=22.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼項.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=22.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼𤊄.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=22.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼𪿢.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=22.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼𭴼.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=22.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼暉.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=23.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼對.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=24.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼精.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=24.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼緊.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=24.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼億.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=25.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼震.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=25.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼磪.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=26.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼融.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=26.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼醜.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so SC=17, TS=27.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼爍.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=29.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼瓊.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=29.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼識.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=29.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼𡅗.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=32.

Add the alternative IDS as ⿺鬼灝.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=34.

⿱艹夻 looks better

Add the secondary radical as 44.0 (尸), SC=8, FS=3

The reading is also the same as 斗.

For the structure ⿺尾X, we have three situations for the radicals: 1) 尸, 2) 毛, 3) the radical of X.

Rad.=尸
U+5C57 屗
U+21C6D 𡱭
U+21C88 𡲈
U+21C89 𡲉
U+21C8A 𡲊
U+21C8B 𡲋
U+21CA4 𡲤
U+21CA5 𡲥
U+21CA7 𡲧
U+21CA8 𡲨
U+21CAA 𡲪
U+21CAB 𡲫
U+21CB8 𡲸
U+21CBC 𡲼
U+21CC0 𡳀
U+21CC3 𡳃
U+21CCA 𡳊
U+21CD3 𡳓
U+21CD4 𡳔
U+21CD5 𡳕
U+21CD6 𡳖
U+21CD7 𡳗
U+21CDD 𡳝
U+21CE6 𡳦
U+21CEA 𡳪
U+21CF1 𡳱
U+21CF2 𡳲
U+21CF3 𡳳
U+2AA15 𪨕
U+2AA19 𪨙
U+2AA1D 𪨝
U+2AA1F 𪨟
U+2BD5E 𫵞
U+2BD63 𫵣
U+2D567 𭕧
U+2D568 𭕨
U+3037A 𰍺
U+30384 𰎄
U+30385 𰎅
U+316C1 𱛁
U+316C2 𱛂

Rad.=毛
U+2DBE2 𭯢

Rad.=the rad. of X
U+20868 𠡨
U+209EE 𠧮
U+219A5 𡦥
U+22F59 𢽙
U+23341 𣍁
U+25591 𥖑
U+25700 𥜀
U+28914 𨤔
U+2A450 𪑐
U+2BBE8 𫯨
U+2BC35 𫰵
U+2CA0A 𬨊
U+319C7 𱧇
U+32A0E 𲨎
U+33339 𳌹

Rad.=尸 & the rad. of X
U+5C58 屘
U+3273A 𲜺

Add the secondary radical as 1.0 (一), SC=17, FS=3 (to follow the radical of 且)

For the structure ⿱𦥯X, there are two situations for the radicals: 1) the radical of X, 2) 臼

Rad=rad of X
U+56B3 嚳
U+58C6 壆
U+5B78 學
U+5DA8 嶨
U+6FA9 澩
U+71E2 燢
U+7910 礐
U+89BA 覺
U+89F7 觷
U+96E4 雤
U+9C5F 鱟
U+9DFD 鷽
U+9ECC 黌
U+3F47 㽇
U+4077 䁷
U+4441 䑁
U+4BB8 䮸
U+20539 𠔹
U+20FDF 𠿟
U+216A3 𡚣
U+23C53 𣱓
U+246F1 𤛱
U+25023 𥀣
U+2574A 𥝊
U+263D7 𦏗
U+2C2E1 𬋡
U+2C830 𬠰
U+2E0AE 𮂮
U+325E2 𲗢
U+326C9 𲛉
U+328FC 𲣼
U+32C06 𲰆

Rad=臼
U+244DF 𤓟
U+2698E 𦦎
U+26991 𦦑
U+26997 𦦗
U+2699B 𦦛
U+269A0 𦦠
U+269AF 𦦯
U+269B5 𦦵
U+269C0 𦧀
U+2C6FD 𬛽
U+2E373 𮍳

Add the secondary radical as 10.0 (儿), SC=9, FS=3

Looks the variant of 魁, and the radical of 魁 is the outside component 鬼.

For the structure ⿺免X, there are two situations for the radicals: 1) 儿, 2) the radical of X.

Rad.=儿
U+204BE 𠒾
U+204C4 𠓄
U+204CD 𠓍
U+2A782 𪞂

Rad.=the rad of X
U+52C9 勉
U+2188E 𡢎
U+231B6 𣆶
U+251C5 𥇅
U+2831C 𨌜
U+28F7A 𨽺
U+2BC32 𫰲
U+2CDD6 𬷖
U+2ECEA 𮳪

IRG N954AR shows below.



IRG N1105 shows below.



Maybe we need to follow the later one?

Add the secondary radical as 96.0 (玉), SC=9, FS=1

For the structure ⿱玨X, there are two situations for the radicals: 1) 玉, 2) the radical of component X

Rad=玉
U+73E1 珡 (variant of 琴)
U+7434 琴 (musical instrument)
U+7435 琵 (musical instrument)
U+7436 琶 (musical instrument)
U+7439 琹 (variant of 琴)
U+745F 瑟 (musical instrument)
U+24996 𤦖
U+24997 𤦗
U+249C2 𤧂 (variant of 琴)
U+249C6 𤧆 (variant of 琴)
U+24A0D 𤨍
U+24A58 𤩘
U+24A5F 𤩟 (variant of 琴)
U+2AEF4 𪻴 (variant of 琴 and 珍)
U+2B73B 𫜻 (musical instrument)
U+2DE65 𭹥 (musical instrument + variant of 筑)
U+2DE78 𭹸 (musical instrument + variant of 箜)
U+2DE92 𭺒
U+2DE95 𭺕
U+30877 𰡷 (variant of 琴)
U+30886 𰢆 (variant of 琴)
U+30887 𰢇 (variant of 琴)
U+3088C 𰢌 (variant of 琴)
U+31BD0 𱯐 (variant of 柬)
U+32BDE 𲯞 (variant of 拜)

Rad=the rad of X
U+22708 𢜈 (variant of 琴 and 慧)
U+235DC 𣗜 (variant of 琴)
U+28A16 𨨖 (variant of 琴)
U+2ABE5 𪯥 (variant of 斑 and 瑟)
U+2D310 𭌐
U+2D481 𭒁 (variant of 瑟)
U+2D8D1 𭣑
U+327D7 𲟗 (variant of 弄)

Rad=玉=the rad of X
U+32BEC 𲯬

FS=4, use 4De

SC=10, TS=16, the right component is counted as 𥁕.

The following characters with the structure ⿺亮X shows the radicals are all #8 (亠).

U+30060 𰁠


U+31399 𱎙


U+32412 𲐒
[WS2021-00124]

Change Radical to 149.0 (言), SC=16, FS=5

Add the secondary radical as 9.0 (人), SC=21, FS=5

For the structure ⿱䜌X, there are three situations for the radicals: 1) the radical of X, 2) 言, 3) 糸

Rad=rad of X
U+535B 卛
U+5971 奱
U+5B4C 孌
U+5B7F 孿
U+5DD2 巒
U+5F4E 彎
U+6200 戀
U+6523 攣
U+66EB 曫
U+6B12 欒
U+7053 灓
U+77D5 矕
U+81E0 臠
U+883B 蠻
U+947E 鑾
U+9E1E 鸞
U+3618 㘘
U+3748 㝈
U+3869 㡩
U+3ABB 㪻
U+3F4B 㽋
U+20673 𠙳
U+2082A 𠠪
U+20A2B 𠨫
U+20B93 𠮓
U+20B96 𠮖
U+22376 𢍶
U+23035 𣀵
U+239B1 𣦱
U+244D6 𤓖
U+24ADC 𤫜
U+2503A 𥀺
U+268CF 𦣏
U+269BD 𦦽
U+26AF2 𦫲
U+277CF 𧟏
U+2829F 𨊟
U+283F6 𨏶
U+293F9 𩏹
U+2965F 𩙟
U+29ABE 𩪾
U+2A23D 𪈽
U+2AB57 𪭗
U+2D4DD 𭓝
U+2DBEE 𭯮
U+2E382 𮎂
U+2E72D 𮜭

Rad=言
U+8B8A 變
U+27B8C 𧮌

Rad=糸
U+261E5 𦇥
U+261F7 𦇷
U+30AF9 𰫹

The radicals of U+9FBB 龻 and U+470C 䜌 are both 言, so the radicals 糸 are not better.




Note that the top component is the phonetic element in this character.

FS=3?

See similar question in WS2024-04416.

04416

魚 195.10.3

VN-F0677

TS 21 · IDS ⿰魚耗

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=17.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as the same as 10, so TS=16. UK glyph matches.

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=24.

SC=16, TS=19

It is OK to keep current T glyph, but it is better to count ⿱田儿 as 鬼 the same as 10, so TS=22. UK glyph matches.

FS=5? cf. WS2024-03745

03745

車 159.9.5

UK-30341

TS 16 · IDS ⿰車盈

IRGN2750WS2024v2.0Unified&Withdrawn
Unified to 03742, IRG 63.

⿰車弓/⿰車𠔃

Based on the above discussion, I will add one more entry to the Consolidated SC and FS guidelines for IWDS.

Add 飠/𩙿/食, FS=3, SC=9

For this case, the semantic element is 做, the phonetic element is 乞 (老借 haet, Cantonese is hat1; 新借 giz), so the radical 人 is from the right part 做, that means FS=3 is better to match the first stroke of 乞.

For this case, the semantic element is 作, the phonetic element is 乞 (老借 haet, Cantonese is hat1; 新借 giz), so the radical 人 is from the right part 作, that means FS=3 is better to match the first stroke of 乞.

⿸鹿虚

Support HKSAR to update the IDS to ⿱𭸾金 as Comment #3317 shows.

As Comment #11967 shows, there are two situations for the structure ⿹㇯鸟一X: one is the radical of X, the other one is 鸟.

Rad=X
U+51EB 凫
U+5C9B 岛
U+67AD 枭
U+8885 袅
U+32C39 𲰹

Rad=鸟
U+2EE54 𮹔

Also ⿰吿挽.

吿 V1-4E5F

No need to update the glyph.

Change Radical to 48.0 (工), SC=4, FS=5 and move 19.0 力 as the secondary one.

The top component is 巨, and the initial consonant (声母, phụ âm đầu/輔音頭) is l- (related to 來母 in middle Chinese), and the initial consonant of this one is s-, that means its previous form is consonant cluster. Based on the Vietnamese RS conventions, the most proper radical should be 工 (the radical of 巨).

*kl- → s-

U+22028 𢀨 V0-3D45 48.12
cự 巨 & lang 郎 = *klang → sang



U+2AA64 𪩤 V4-4723 48.8
cự 巨 & liệt 列 (>lít) = *klít → sít



U+2AA6A 𪩪 V4-4734 48.19
cự 巨 & liễm 歛 (>lượm) = *klớm → sớm



U+31719 𱜙 VN-F016C 48.10
cự 巨 & luân 侖 (>lỏn) = *klon → son


* the variant of U+22027 𢀧

⿱鄉日

⿰月𲬥

⿰木𲬥

⿰氵𲬥

See Comment #12723 under WS2024-02723.

02723

石 112.15.4

木 75.16.4

GZ-3352502

TS 20 · IDS ⿰磨木

R(2)=75.0 (木), SC(2)=16, FS(2)=4, IRG 63.

⿰虫𲬥

IDS has not been updated to ⿰𧾷邦 yet.

Also
⿰&Z5-01;免

Then SC=9 based on Comment #8938.

Use 4Pc, SC=9, TS=14

Re Comment #1475


IRG N2862R #7Dd shows the value should be 7.

吴川历史文化丛书编委会; 钟德: 《吴川方言》 (《吴川历史文化丛书》), 广州: 广东人民出版社, 2021.10, ISBN 978-7-218-14901-1, p. 524

This evidence support current glyph, so it is OK to keep it as-is as Comment #12037.

▲ 吴川历史文化丛书编委会; 钟德: 《吴川方言》 (《吴川历史文化丛书》), 广州: 广东人民出版社, 2021.10, ISBN 978-7-218-14901-1, p. 527

The submitted evidence shows one 疏 (소) related to 洪淳穆 (홍순목, 1816 - 1884) in 1866. I also found one more piece related to 洪淳穆. He used the word as 乖盭 (괴려).


▲ 승정원일기 2478책 (탈초본 121책) 헌종 14년 10월 26일 병인 21/24 기사 1848년 道光(淸/宣宗) 28년

The evidence shows several person names as 柳楳～ (유매～), 李審 (이심), 蘇受益 (소수익), 禹有錫 (우유석), 王枝明 (왕지명), 朴斗萬 (박두만), 金乭山 (김돌산). And I found other one page shows several person names as 柳楳, 李⿱⿻十𠈌回, 李審, 蘇受益, 禹有錫, 王枝明, 朴斗萬, 金乭山, but I can’t find the original picture.

If 柳楳 is one person, the following character in the submitted evidence should mean the other person 李𤲷 or 李嗇 (이색). The following picture shows the the time.

▲ https://sjw.history.go.kr/id/SJW-F05040300-03900

If yes, it is not better to normalize the glyph to ⿱爽田, and the current reading is incorrect.

Comment #1821 has not been resolved yet.

Support Comment #14361 to update the G glyph.

Based on Section A.2.2 of the new version of GB/T 11460 (plan number: 20241890-T-469), 仓 should not do the 避让.



See below.

The glyph and IDS have not been updated to ⿺笔鳥 yet.

Normalize to ⿰犭邦?

As Comment #4166 shows, is it better to normalize the glyph to ⿰火邦 to follow PRC convention?

Comment #6088 has not been resolved yet.

Normalize to ⿰虫邦 to match PRC conventions?

Normalize the glyph to ⿱敝牙? See Comment #6233.

Normalize to ⿰扌剥 to match PRC conventions?

⿰忄乂?

Comments #4468 and #7835 have not been resolved yet.

The second horizontal stroke (横) of the bottom left component 牛 should not be 避让 to become 提. The glyph shown on the evidence has been matched PRC conventions.

The glyph has not been updated yet.

The last stroke of the inside part 支 is 点/反捺 currently, which does not match the evidence.

Normalize the glyph to ⿰飠丈 to follow PRC conventions, and UCV #248 support this normalization.


The semantic element is 食/飠 (<養, bottom), and the phonetic element is 丈 (老借 form is ciengh, 新借 form is cang).

The glyph has not been updated yet to ⿺尼常.

Reply to Comment #14420.

The submitted character is a Zhuang character. In Comment #14420, U+3037C 𰍼 and U+3165C 𱙜 are also Zhuang characters.




For U+3165C 𱙜 (reads as ndi*), the semantic element is 好, and the phonetic element is 尼 (新借niz).

For U+3037C 𰍼 and the submitted character, we need to know an unencoded character first.
⿺尼冷 reads nit, and the semantic element is 冷, the phonetic element is 尼.

▲ 《古壮字字典》, p. 383
Therefore, the rationale of U+3037C 𰍼 (reads as dot) and the submitted character (reads as ciengz*) are that the semantic elements are both the omitted form of ⿺尼冷, and the phonetic elements are 夺 (新借doz, 老接dued) and 常 (新借cangz, 老借ciengz).

That means the structures for these characters are stable, and match the rationale. Therefore, the glyph must be updated to match the submitted evidence. Other characters (⿰尼X) are not related to this type.

The last stroke should be the dot.

Normalize the glyph to ⿱艹剑?

The Zhuang reading is gemq. The Zhuang reading of 剑 is giemq (老借), gen (新借). It is close to gemq.

莶 is not a very common character, and reads cim1 in Cantonese, so the closest Zhuang reading should be ciem (老借, the same as 签), which is not similar to gemq.

The Zhuang word coenggemq means Chinese chives (韭菜), and previous character is 萗 with Radical #140.0.

The most proper form should be ⿱艹剑.

The glyph has not been updated yet.

Normalize the glyph to ⿰令衮 to follow the PRC conventions?

If yes, the IDS should be updated correspondingly, but the SC and TS should be kept.

Support Comment #4775

Glyph to be updated or not?

The glyph has not been updated to ⿰麥員 yet.

And, IDS should be ⿰麥員.

中华书局宋体 shows the glyph of U+F6F52 as below. See #7634

Support Comment #10984. See G5-733B glyph for U+501D 倝.

Normalize the glyph to match the current IDS as ⿱爽田.

U+21641 𡙁 is the unifiable variant of U+723D 爽 per UCV #108, but there is no K-Source reference for U+21641 𡙁 now.





It is better to use ⿱爽田 to match ROK conventions. The Korean reading provided by the submitter is 상, which is the same as 爽.

Normalize to ⿰木戩? 晋 and 晉 are UCV #388.

There is no K-Source under 戬, but K1-6B79 is under 戩.

The evidence shows ⿱艹黙, and we trust 默 and 黙 are unifiable.

The K-Source for U+9ED8 默 is K0-5979, but U+9ED9 黙 is K6-1021.





Suggest normalizing the K glyph to ⿱艹默.

⿰糹𧗠?

The evidence shows ⿰禾逹 or ⿰木逹. The submitter should show the normalization rule.

On the evidence, the previous sub-sentence shows “山稻種於乾田” (n./plant v. prep. n./place), so this sub-sentence shows “泉～種於寒水”, that means “泉～” is also a kind of plant. It is not easy to know what it is.

The current glyph (outside part of the right part of the right bottom part) has not followed ROK conventions as K0-5F31 shows.

Comment #3663 has not been resolved yet.

Based on the first evidence, the last stroke of the left part is 提, that means the component should be 避讓.

This glyph has matched the evidence and follow Japan conventions, so it is OK to keep it. It is due to SAT.

The glyphs on Evidence 2 and Evidence 3 are different.

Support Comment #2425.

The new evidence on Comment #9875, the right part of this character follows 戹 like 阸, 𩚬, 㧖, 呝.

IDS and evidence show ⿰𦾔阝, and glyph shows ⿰舊阝. Should the glyph be modified or normalized?

Evidences 2 & 3 show the glyph as ⿰弓⿱𠆢壐.

If TCA wants to normalize the glyph to ⿰口爓, that will be OK; if not, the current glyph could be kept. When other sources do the horizontal extension, ⿰口爓 could be unified here.

Is it possible to normalize the middle part to follow TCA conventions, cf. U+7FCC 翌?

The other solution is to modify the glyph to match the IDS as the normalization.

The first stroke of 壬 in TCA (and HKSAR, MSAR) conventions is the horizontal stroke 横, not 撇.

The bottom component of the right part is 儿 not 几 for TCA conventions.

Does TCA plan to normalize the glyph if possible?

See U+8794 螔, U+892B 褫, U+8B15 謕, U+29E9B 𩺛 and so on.

Evidence 1 shows the right part is U+4E38 丸 (T1-443A). The second stroke is ㇈ (HZWG).



Evidence 2 shows the right part is the new component *U+2FAE6 (TCP-00136) in IRG N2878R2 ⺄ (related to 飞).


Also see U+57F6 埶, U+57F7 執, U+5B70 孰 and so on.

The IDS and the evidence show ⿰氵𮗺, but the current glyph is ⿰氵⿱攵言.

The glyph should be updated.

Reply to Comment #11042.

Two pieces of evidence show the semantic element is 刀 (knife). The meaning of this character is also “knife”.

刀 and 力 is also UCV pair. UCV #141b supports this choice.

That means ⿰刀也 is the best choice.

Respond to Comment #11166, which is a good question.

Evidence 1 shows ⿰口⿱垖十, and Evidence 2 shows ⿱⿰口垖十.

Evidence 1 shows the reading is 火刀切, that means f-(-o2) + (d-)-ou1 = fou1;
Evidence 2 shows the reading is 科高切, that means f-(-o1) + (g-)-ou1 = fou1.

Evidence 2 shows the English phrase is “suffocation by drowning”, and the corresponding Cantonese load word is “沙～鷄𠱸 拜 地簍𡨴”. The English word “suffocation” reads /ˌsʌfəˈkeɪʃən/, and “沙～鷄𠱸” reads saa1 fou1 gai1 seon2, which the corresponding Chinese meaning is “窒息”.

埠 reads fau6 and bou6 in Cantonese, fouh in Zhuang (老借).

Therefore, the normalization is acceptable.

Three pieces of evidence shows the corresponding English word is “heavy” (/ˈhevi/), and Evidence 3 shows the corresponding Katakana form is ヘヷ𛄨, so the word reads he1 wi4 in Cantonese.

㗾 reads hoe1 or hoe4 in Cantonese as Comment #11715 shows. 靴 reads like he1 in other sub-dialects of Chinese Yue-dialects.

Therefore, Comment #12178 is reasonable.

The right part of the current V glyph has matched the common design of the 豸 component. cf. U+8C79 U+8C7A

I still support to keep current form as the Vietnamese conventions.

The current glyph is ⿰糹⿺辶𥭗, and the evidence shows the same glyph.

I guess Tao Yang means the right part.

For Component 穴, see V1-614C for U+7A7A 空 and V1-614D for U+7A7F 穿.




For Component 䍃, there are ⿱𱼀缶 and ⿱爫缶.

⿱𱼀缶
U+6416 搖 V1-5756 (no U+6447 摇)
U+9059 遙 V1-6956 (no U+9065 遥)

⿱爫缶
U+55C2 嗂 V2-8A79
U+7464 瑤 V1-5F35 (no U+7476 瑶)
U+8B20 謠 V1-6757 (no U+8B21 謡)
U+9DC2 鷂 V0-484E
U+4058 䁘 V3-3479
U+213DF 𡏟 V2-7331
U+24053 𤁓 V0-3B72
U+24060 𤁠 V2-7B22
U+31924 𱤤 VN-F02AD
U+31A4B 𱩋 VN-F0822
U+32947 𲥇 VN-F191D
U+32AB7 𲪷 VN-F19CB
U+33450 𳑐 VN-F1C3B

Use VN Norm. Rule 1-4 to normalize the glyph.

Consider normalizing to ⿰𧾷面. There is V2-9136 under 面, but no V-source under 靣.

The evidence shows the reading of the right part is diện, which must be 面.

It is better to consider to normalize the right part as 禿 as V1-6130 shows.



There is no V-source reference under U+79C3 秃 now.

The glyph on the evidence match the PRC conventions, but not the Vietnamese conventions.

Remove the hook of the end of the left part to follow Vietnamese conventions. See the left part of the following characters.
U+5F11 V1-5447


U+6BBA V1-5B46


U+2ACBD V4-4B33

The glyph on the evidence match the PRC conventions, but not the Vietnamese conventions.

Remove the hook of the end of the left part to follow Vietnamese conventions. See the left part of the following characters.
U+5F11 V1-5447



U+6BBA V1-5B46



U+2ACBD V4-4B33

Evidence 3 is the evidence for WS2024-00965:GCW-00091, which should be removed.

Evidence 1 has not been removed yet.

Remove ji4 as the Mandarin reading. All pieces of evidence meant to láng (Putonghua) and long4 (Cantonese).

Remove Evidence 7 and 8, which are related to U+2CBE1 𬯡

The evidence for this character and WS2021-03520 don’t show the usage for the geographic names, but the G-Source for this character is GDM. Could we need to know how to use this one for the geographic names?

Remove U+F29C9 as the variants.

Resubmitted character, see WS2017-03140.
[ {{WS2017-03140}} ]

KC05501 shows ⿰禾厚 in db.history.go.kr.



But, now KC05501 is used under U+2E086 𮂆.



KC10116 is also ⿰禾厚.


Maybe the better reference for U+2E086 𮂆 is KC08090.

koreanhistory.or.kr shows the glyph as ⿰衤則.

See WS2021-01439
[WS2021-01439]

The note shows “Similar and synonym: 𢶧”.

U+22DA7 𢶧 is a TF-Source character, so we don’t know how to confirm its usage.

In the online version of TCA-CNS 11643, 11-542F shows the glyph as ⿰石釆, and the reading is also cǎi.



Based on UCV #336, TCA could do the horizontal extension in future.

⿹节丿 is a common vulgar variant of 第 in Guangdong and Guangxi. We need to encode it in future.

The phonetic element must be 韋 (viz? The 老借 form of 位 is vih, and the 新借 form of 韦 is veiz, and 位 is vei), but it is not easy to understand the semantic rationale of the right part 迷. 《古壮字字典》 shows two relative entries, one is used for the Zhuang word “maex” (wife), the other one is used for the Zhuang word “mwh” (period, time). On the other hand, the 老借 form of 迷 is maez, the 新借 form is miz.

If we can’t clarify the right part, it is better to keep current radical without more radicals.

The current Korean reading looked not right, that should be 신, because this character is the variant of 顖(囟) according to the evidence.

As Comment #13154 under WS2024-04233 shows, the submitted evidence of two characters are related.

There is a person named 姜馞 / 강발 there, but I can’t confirm if they are the same person.

When I searched 姜馞, I found one page, but I still not get more useful information now.

[The following comment is raised by Mr. Ma Shijie.]

Similar to U+2157F 𡕿

The character mentioned in Comment #11568 is ⿱研土 (TB-6751).

Is it also the variant of 婣?

cf. 渕/𲒓/𰔂 vs 淵

The provided reading is bīn, which looks more like ⿱艹邠.

The variant of 徵?