IRG Working Set 2024v1.0

Source: John Knightley
Date: Generated on 2026-02-14

Unification

Showing 2 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
00055	00055 丿 4.4.5 GZ-3452101 TS 5 · IDS ⿱乃久	Oppose Unification	The different pronunciations imply that these are non-cognate and therefore should not be unified. 𰀬 has the reading ying1. The pronunciation of GZ-3452101 comes from the top part, 乃, usually nai3 in Chinese.
01446	01446 心 61.6.1 GZ-4511202 TS 10 · IDS ⿱西心	Oppose Unification	Agreed non-cognate therefore not unifiable.

Attributes

Showing 37 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
02604	02604 目 109.7.3 GPGLG-1006 TS 5 · IDS ⿰目针	Total Stroke Count	Agreed 12.
03024	03024 纟 120′.5.1 GPGLG-1015 TS 1 · IDS ⿰纟号	Total Stroke Count	Agree TS 8
02605	02605 目 109.8.1 GPGLG-3058 TS 5 · IDS ⿰看夭	Total Stroke Count	Agreed 13
01803	01803 日 72.12.1 GPGLG-4019 TS 16 · IDS ⿰劳星	Residual Stroke Count	Agree SC=13, TS=17
03059	03059 网 122.9.3 GPGLG-5012 TS 14 · IDS ⿰后𬙙	Residual Stroke Count	Agreed 10
		Total Stroke Count	Agreed 15
02482	02482 甘 99.12.2 GZ-0052201 TS 17 · IDS ⿰甘暑	Residual Stroke Count	Agree SC=13, TS=18
04558	04558 鳥 196.10.4 GZ-0091202 TS 21 · IDS ⿰笔鳥	IDS	Agree change IDS to ⿺笔鳥.
02366	02366 犬 94.6.5 GZ-0132101 TS 9 · IDS ⿰犭⿰龵阝	Residual Stroke Count	Agree SC=7, TS=10
03397	03397 虫 142.6.2 GZ-0132401 TS 12 · IDS ⿰虫⿰龵阝	Residual Stroke Count	Agree SC 7
		Total Stroke Count	Agree TC 13
03273	03273 艸 140.8.1 GZ-0221301 TS 12 · IDS ⿰芋白	Radical	Agree Change Radical to 106.0 (白), SC=7, FS=2. Consider retaining original radical as second radical.
04170	04170 風 182.2.3 GZ-0341301 TS 11 · IDS ⿰風卜	IDS	Agrred change IDS to ⿺風卜.
02352	02352 牛 93.11.4 GZ-0472201 TS 15 · IDS ⿰犂之	Total Stroke Count	Agreed TS=16, SC=12
02663	02663 石 112.5.4 GZ-0532301 TS 9 · IDS ⿰石齐	Residual Stroke Count	Agreed SC=6, TS=11.
03446	03446 虫 142.16.2 GZ-0611201 TS 6 · IDS ⿰虫赞	Total Stroke Count	Agreed TS=22
01159	01159 尸 44.13.5 GZ-0722101 TS 16 · IDS ⿰尼常	IDS	Update IDS to ⿺尼常.
01827	01827 曰 73.5.5 GZ-0862101 TS 9 · IDS ⿱曰召	Radical	Agreed change radical to 72.0 (日)
		IDS	Agreed change IDS to ⿱日召
03343	03343 艸 140.14.4 GZ-1222203 TS 17 · IDS ⿱艹滴	Total Stroke Count	Agreed TS=18
02589	02589 皿 108.13.2 GZ-1621102 TS 18 · IDS ⿰防盘	Radical	Agreed change to Radical 170 (阝), SC=15, FS=4.
03424	03424 虫 142.10.4 GZ-2441501 TS 16 · IDS ⿰虫𦰩	Residual Stroke Count	Agreed SC=11
		Total Stroke Count	Agreed TC=17
03366	03366 艸 140.17.4 GZ-3362401 TS 21 · IDS ⿰温茂	Radical	Agreed change radical to 85.0 (水), SC=18, FS=2
02632	02632 目 109.13.1 GZ-3392303 TS 18 · IDS ⿰目墓	Residual Stroke Count	Agreed SC=14
		Total Stroke Count	Agreed TC=19
00979	00979 夊 35.12.5 GZ-3552510 TS 15 · IDS ⿱好美	Radical	Agree Change Radical to 38.0 (女), SC=12, FS=5
04569	04569 鳥 196.15.3 GZ-3842501 TS 26 · IDS ⿲外辱鳥	IDS	Since 𬷨 is the phonetic and 外 is the meaning the IDS ⿰外𬷨 is clear to those who are familiar with 𬷨, however this does not align with the current radical.
01944	01944 木 75.11.4 GZ-3982201 TS 15 · IDS ⿰染会	IDS	Change IDS to ⿰染⿱𠆢𠫓
03293	03293 艸 140.9.4 GZ-4021105 TS 12 · IDS ⿱艹悔	Residual Stroke Count	Agreed SC=10, TS=14
00253	00253 凵 17.12.5 GZ-4022108 TS 14 · IDS ⿰出屋	IDS	The IDS should remain as it is because, strange as it may seem at first sight, the established convention is to use 出 (U+51FA) not 岀 (U+5C80) in such cases.
04124	04124 雨 173.20.2 GZ-4122404 TS 28 · IDS ⿰露來	Residual Stroke Count	Agreed SC=21, TS=29
00242	00242 冫 15.7.4 GZ-4231104 TS 99 · IDS ⿰冫弟	Total Stroke Count	Agreed TS=9
03467	03467 衣 145.9.3 GZ-4881101 TS 14 · IDS ⿰衤括	Total Stroke Count	Agree TS=15
04148	04148 韋 178.9.4 GZ-4901401 TS 19 · IDS ⿰韋迷	Residual Stroke Count	Agree SC 10
		Total Stroke Count	Agree TC 19
03306	03306 艸 140.10.4 GZA-618185 TS 13 · IDS ⿰荒无	Total Stroke Count	Agree TS=14

Evidence

Showing 13 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
01339	01339 干 51.7.5 GPGLG-1011 TS 8 · IDS ⿱比年	Evidence	New evidences accepted, thank you.
01842	01842 月 74.9.1 GPGLG-2025 TS 13 · IDS ⿰月胡	Evidence	Thank you for the new evidence.
01620	01620 手 64.9.4 GPGLG-3043 TS 12 · IDS ⿰扌弯	Evidence	Thank you for the interesting new evidence.
00138	00138 人 9.9.1 GPGLG-3059 TS 11 · IDS ⿰亻查	Evidence	New evidence accepted, thank you.
01838	01838 月 74.4.2 GPGLG-3060 TS 8 · IDS ⿰月见	Evidence	Thank you for the new evidence.
03602	03602 贝 154′.4.2 GPGLG-4017 TS 8 · IDS ⿰贝介	Unclear evidence response	The character 介 appears 134 times in this book including twice on the same page with reading gaiq aka gai tone 5 (highlighted by green boxes below)
		New evidence	New evidence accepted, thank you. Both the Zhuang and Buyi meanings are the same, as is the pronunciation it's just that they have different Latin script orthographies.
01443	01443 心 61.5.4 GZ-0032501 TS 8 · IDS ⿰忄艾	Evidence	Thank you for the new evidence.
00007	00007 一 1.4.4 GZ-0061503 TS 5 · IDS ⿱比一	New evidence	Thank you, new evidence accepted.
00087	00087 二 7.4.5 GZ-0111301 TS 6 · IDS ⿰云八	Evidence	New evidence accepted, thank you.
00254	00254 刀 18.2.3 GZ-0651705 TS 4 · IDS ⿰刀㐅	Evidence	New evidence accepted, thank you.
01557	01557 手 64.2.1 GZ-1951203 TS 5 · IDS ⿰扌十	Evidence	Thank you for the new evidence.
00418	00418 口 30.7.2 GZ-2501206 TS 10 · IDS ⿰口闲	New evidence	New evidence accepted, thank you.

Glyph Design & Normalization

Showing 11 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
04558	04558 鳥 196.10.4 GZ-0091202 TS 21 · IDS ⿰笔鳥	Glyph design	Agree glyph should be modified to ⿺笔鳥 to match the evidence.
03623	03623 走 156.5.1 GZ-0292201 TS 12 · IDS ⿺走本	Glyph design	Agree the lower-right stroke of "本" should be changed.
02465	02465 瓜 97.8.1 GZ-0452402 TS 14 · IDS ⿺瓜茂	Glyph design	Glyph already normalized to ⿺瓜茂, consider new UCV for 茂 and 𫇮.
03202	03202 自 132.7.5 GZ-0501401 TS 13 · IDS ⿰自𠬶	Glyph design	Agreed glyph design should be updated.
01159	01159 尸 44.13.5 GZ-0722101 TS 16 · IDS ⿰尼常	Glyph design	Agreed update glyph to ⿺尼常.
01827	01827 曰 73.5.5 GZ-0862101 TS 9 · IDS ⿱曰召	Glyph design	Agreed glyph should be modified.
00121	00121 人 9.6.5 GZ-1471201 TS 8 · IDS ⿰亻⿳与一八	Glyph design	Agreed, the last stroke should be changed.
02126	02126 水 85.10.4 GZ-1572501 TS 13 · IDS ⿱浅石	Glyph design	As stated at submission the glyph is normalized in accordance with UCV#247.
03077	03077 羊 123.8.4 GZ-1911102 TS 14 · IDS ⿰羊羌	Glyph design	Yes, this is what is meant here by normalized.
		Glyph design	Agreed the 5th stroke should be 横 instead of 提.
01944	01944 木 75.11.4 GZ-3982201 TS 15 · IDS ⿰染会	Glyph design	Yes the right component is not 会, it is a simplified form of ⿱𠆢镸. The glyph should be modified to match the evidence.

Data for Unihan

Showing 3 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
00024	00024 一 1.12.2 GZ-1122101 TS 13 · IDS ⿰丁堂	Unihan data	kZhuang should be dangz* not dangz.
00064	00064 丿 4.16.2 GZ-2712501 TS 17 · IDS ⿰娄乖	Unihan data	kZhuang should be laeu* not laeu as <方> as a "dialect" in this case Wuming not standard Zhuang which would be laeux aka laeu tone 4 (NB use of * to mark non-standard Zhuang is Unihan convention).
00003	00003 一 1.3.3 GZ-3932501 TS 4 · IDS ⿰㐅丂	Unihan data	kZhuang should be nyauq* not nyauq.