«
UK-10052
UK-10053
UK-10054
»
01372
Trad
戈 62.6
㇑ (2)
10

UK-10053
IRGN2480WS2017v6.1 Pending
Keep postponed, IRG 52.
pending unified to U+ 621C, irg51.
Attributes:



Review Comments

Type
Description
Submitter
Unification
UNIFICATION
WS2017 v1.1
Japan
2018-04-20 00:00:00
#777
RESPONSE
RESPONSE
WS2017 v1.1
Disagree. UK-10053 is the variant of 城 according to the evidence, and 戜
(U+621C) is read as dié, 説文:利也,一曰提也. They are non-cognate.
Andrew WEST
UK
2018-05-20 08:42:07
#1377
Other
COMMENT
WS2017 v1.1
The footnote is wrong; it is indeed 戜 (U+621C).
CHEN Zhixiang
China
2018-05-23 08:47:47
#1627
Other
COMMENT
WS2017 v2
CHEN Zhixiang
China
2018-08-31 08:23:22
#3386
RESPONSE
RESPONSE
WS2017 v2
> Unify with U+621C
Disagree. UK-10053 is the variant of 城 according to the evidence, and 戜 (U+621C) is read as dié, 説文:利也,一曰提也. They are non-cognate and have different glyph shapes, so are not unifiable.
Andrew WEST
UK
2018-10-21 17:35:19
#3294
RESPONSE
RESPONSE
WS2017 v2
> Vulgar variant of U+57DF
Disagree. UK-10053 is the variant of 城 according to the evidence, and 戜 (U+621C) is read as dié, 説文:利也,一曰提也. They are non-cognate.
Andrew WEST
UK
2018-10-21 18:01:11
#3372
Unification
UNIFICATION
WS2017 v3
U+621C, S.1.5.i
The actual shape in the inscription (班簋) is like below (character in the center). Though its left hand component is somewhat obscure, it is identifiable as 呈 via similar glyphs on 戜者簋 etc. Despite the footnote, latest study has found this unlikely to be a variant of 城, which has median initial, while 呈 lateral. 説文 was compiled on post-Qin orthography, which as such unable to attest cognacy in pre-Qin writing where word-character correspondence is not fixed and non-phonetic components are liberally replaced. The meaning of the word is still disputed, so it should be either unified to 戜 according to the structure, or withdrawn as premature transcription.
I would also like to point out that various typographical and theoretical errors seen in the source literature make it generally unsuitable for new character proposal.

References:
http://www.guoxuedashi.com/yzjwjc/?bh=4341
http://www.guoxuedashi.com/kangxi/pic.php?f=xinjinwb&p=1719
http://www.gwz.fudan.edu.cn/Web/Show/1858
WANG Yifan
SAT
2019-01-04 04:13:06
#3563
Unification
UNIFICATION
WS2017 v3
Keep pending.
Eiso CHAN
Individual
2019-04-27 12:05:17
#4856

Discussion Record

DateDescription
IRG #51
2018-10-23 (Tue)
5:02 pm +0700
Recorded by Henry CHAN
PENDING
Pending for double verification by China
IRG #52
2019-05-15 (Wed)
4:12 pm +0800
Recorded by CHEN Zhuang
Keep postponed

Glyph Changes

Source ReferenceGlyph
UK-10053
2.0
Note: glyph data for version 1.1 is not available.

Raw Info
0 - Seq. No.01372
1 - Discussion RecordKeep postponed, IRG 52. pending unified to U+ 621C, irg51.
2 - Kangxi Radical62
3 - Stroke Count6
4 - First Stroke2
5 - T/S (0/1) Flag0
6 - IDS⿹戈⿱口土
7 - Total Strokes10
8 - G Source
9 - G Image
10 - G Similar Ideographs
11 - G Ref. to Evidence doc
12 - G Page No. in the document (optional)
13 - G Row No. in the Page (optional)
14 - G Position in the Row (optional)
15 - G file name of evidence image
16 - G Optional Information
17 - K Source
18 - K Image
19 - K Similar/ Variants
20 - K Ref. to Evidence document
21 - i1) Page No. in the evidence document (optional)
22 - i2) Row No. in the page (optional)
23 - i3) Position No. in the row (optional)
24 - K file name of evidence image
25 - K Revised information (2018.03.16)
26 - K Real Glyph
27 - UK SourceUK-10053
28 - UK ImageUK-10053.bmp
29 - UK Similar/ Variants
30 - UK Ref. to Evidence doc008
31 - UK Title and YearA Source Book of Ancient Chinese Bronze Inscriptions (2016)
32 - UK Page No.page 61
33 - UK PNG ImageUK-10053.png
34 - UK Font code pointU+F551
35 - UK Mapping to traditional or simplified character
36 - UK SJT-11239-2001
37 - UK Notes
38 - SAT Source
39 - SAT Image
40 - SAT Similar Ideographs
41 - SAT References to evidence documents
42 - SAT optional information
43 - T Source
44 - T Image
45 - T Similar/ Varianonets
46 - T References to evidence documents A
47 - T References to evidence documents B
48 - T File name of evidence image
49 - T Real Glyph
50 - UTC Source
51 - UTC Image
52 - UTC Similar Ideographs
53 - UTC References to evidence documents
54 - UTC SJ/T 11239-2001
55 - V Source
56 - V Image
57 - V Related
58 - V Reading
59 - V Evidence
60 - V Evidence File
61 - V Code Point
62 - V Note
63 - WS2015 SN
64 -