LI Yuan Comments | WS2024v3.0

IRG Working Set 2024v3.0

Source: LI Yuan
Date: Generated on 2025-06-15

Show Deleted | Show comments from version: 1.0 2.0 3.0 | Show comments with status: Show All New Only Unresolved Only

Unification

Showing 2 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
03621	03621 赤 155.12.1 VN-F056E TS 19 · IDS ⿰赤雄	UCV [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	As Eiso mentioned in #8545, it may be necessary to add the following UCV: ⿰公隹 and 雄.
03637	03637 足 157.5.2 VN-F0573 TS 12 · IDS ⿰𧾷申	Unification [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #341.

Attributes

Showing 32 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
03664	03664 足 157.9.3 GCCPP-00031 TS 16 · IDS ⿰𧾷叟	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #3306.
03554	03554 讠 149′.10.1 GDM-00472 TS 12 · IDS ⿰讠荅	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #3297, FS=2.
03786	03786 车 159′.12.3 GDM-00475 TS 15 · IDS ⿰车鲁	Total Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #3311.
03952	03952 长 168′.13.5 GPGLG-2032 TS 17 · IDS ⿰雷长	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	FS=1.
04278	04278 骨 188.8.1 GPGLG-3061 TS 18 · IDS ⿰骨虎	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	FS=2.
04223	04223 饣 184′.8.3 GPGLG-3064 TS 11 · IDS ⿱饱壬	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	SC=9.
04223	04223 饣 184′.8.3 GPGLG-3064 TS 11 · IDS ⿱饱壬	Total Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	TS=12.
03606	03606 贝 154′.6.4 GZ-1111302 TS 10 · IDS ⿰贝当	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #1709.
04140	04140 面 176.11.1 GZ-1941401 TS 19 · IDS ⿰面竟	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	FS=4.
03702	03702 車 159.4.1 GZ-2912503 TS 11 · IDS ⿱六車	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #1731.
03603	03603 贝 154′.4.2 GZA-618020 TS 8 · IDS ⿰贝夫	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #3301.
04168	04168 頁 181.15.3 GZHSJ-0005 TS 24 · IDS ⿳⿴臼同冖頁	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	SC=14.
04168	04168 頁 181.15.3 GZHSJ-0005 TS 24 · IDS ⿳⿴臼同冖頁	Total Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	TS=23.
03541	03541 言 149.15.5 SAT-09695 TS 22 · IDS ⿰言墮	IDS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Support HKSAR's comment, the glyph should be modified to ⿰言墮.
03638	03638 足 157.5.3 SAT-10050 TS 12 · IDS ⿲足㚈	IDS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #445.
03695	03695 身 158.15.3 SAT-10131 TS 22 · IDS ⿰身臧	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #3309.
04031	04031 雨 173.5.1 T13-3F2C TS 13 · IDS ⿱雨巨	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	SC=4, TS=12.
04068	04068 雨 173.11.2 T13-3F44 TS 19 · IDS ⿱雨乾	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	FS=1.
04069	04069 雨 173.11.2 T13-3F45 TS 19 · IDS ⿱雨救	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	FS=1.
04099	04099 雨 173.15.1 T13-3F5D TS 23 · IDS ⿱雨橫	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	SC=16.
04099	04099 雨 173.15.1 T13-3F5D TS 23 · IDS ⿱雨橫	Total Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	TS=24.
03617	03617 赤 155.8.3 TD-6472 TS 15 · IDS ⿰赤臾	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #3303.
03630	03630 走 156.8.1 TD-647C TS 15 · IDS ⿺走者	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #1716.
03596	03596 貝 154.13.1 UK-30019 TS 20 · IDS ⿱⿰孝成貝	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #3300.
03632	03632 走 156.8.5 UK-30090 TS 15 · IDS ⿺走岩	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #1717.
03615	03615 贝 154′.15.3 UK-30630 TS 19 · IDS ⿰署负	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #3302.
03611	03611 贝 154′.12.3 UK-30644 TS 16 · IDS ⿰空贫	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #1711.
03690	03690 身 158.9.1 UK-30773 TS 16 · IDS ⿰身致	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	SC = 10, TS = 17. (According to No. 35 of IRGN954AR_StrokeC_FirstS, 攵 is counted as 4 strokes.)
03619	03619 赤 155.12.1 VN-F056C TS 17 · IDS ⿰赤都	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #1714.
03620	03620 赤 155.12.1 VN-F056D TS 17 · IDS ⿱都赤	Total Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #1715.
03675	03675 足 157.12.1 VN-F0589 TS 18 · IDS ⿰𧾷逵	Total Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #3307.
03682	03682 足 157.15.2 VN-F0597 TS 22 · IDS ⿰𧾷賞	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	FS=5.

Evidence

Showing 10 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
03794	03794 辵 162.5.2 GCW-00227 TS 8 · IDS ⿺辶田	Evidence [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #3313.
03781	03781 车 159′.5.5 GDM-00474 TS 9 · IDS ⿰车加	Evidence [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	The glyph shown in Evidence 2 is identical to the traditional character "𰹐".
03515	03515 言 149.4.3 GZHSJ-0041 TS 11 · IDS ⿰訁卆	Evidence [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	In evidence2, the glyph does not match the proposed IDS ⿰訁卆. Please verify.
03530	03530 言 149.9.3 KC-10122 TS 16 · IDS ⿰言复	Evidence [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	In the evidence, the middle component appears to be closer to "日".
03767	03767 車 159.12.1 SAT-09344 TS 19 · IDS ⿰車𫟛	Evidence [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	In comment #5660, should the context of the mentioned "⿰車𫟛" evidence be provided? Additionally, are 佛説須摩提女經 and 須摩提女經 the same scripture?
03527	03527 言 149.8.4 SAT-09780 TS 15 · IDS ⿰言⿱白上	Evidence [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	In evidence2, the lower part of the glyph appears closer to "匕" than to "上".
03667	03667 足 157.10.2 SAT-09798 TS 17 · IDS ⿰𧾷𤴗	Evidence [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	The uploaded evidence includes two glyph variants of "𤴗"—one with a short horizontal line and one with a dot. Should a UCV be added for these two glyph variants?
03575	03575 貝 154.4.1 T13-3E5E TS 11 · IDS ⿰貝互	Evidence [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	In the evidence, the right-side component of the glyph only appears similar to "互" but is not actually "互"; it is a variant form of "氐". I have some doubts about whether it is appropriate to encode this glyph directly as "互". The data shown below for "低" in HNG could serve as a reference. https://search.hng-data.org/search/%E4%BD%8E
03536	03536 言 149.12.1 UK-30532 TS 19 · IDS ⿰言厥	Evidence [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	In the evidence, the "厂" component in the right part "厥" does not extend to cover the "欠" part.
04085	04085 雨 173.13.3 UTC-03243 TS 21 · IDS ⿱雨𪫕	Evidence [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Would you please provide a more detailed name for the literature used as evidence?

Glyph Design & Normalization

Showing 1 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
03623	03623 走 156.5.1 GZ-0292201 TS 12 · IDS ⿺走本	Glyph design [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree the lower-right stroke of "本" should be changed.

Other

Showing 2 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
03562	03562 豆 151.5.1 GCW-00224 TS 12 · IDS ⿱𫇦豆	Other [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree with comment #1509.
03807	03807 辵 162.9.3 SAT-09332 TS 13 · IDS ⿺辶⿱𠆢束	Comment [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	error form or variant ?