ROK Comments | WS2024v3.0

IRG Working Set 2024v3.0

Source: ROK
Date: Generated on 2025-06-15

Show Deleted | Show comments from version: 1.0 2.0 3.0 | Show comments with status: Show All New Only Unresolved Only

Unification

Showing 7 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
02220	02220 火 86.6.1 KC-10058 TS 10 · IDS ⿱匡火	Unification [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	KR will unify to 𪥎 (U+2A94E).
01966	01966 木 75.9.3 KC-10092 TS 13 · IDS ⿰木⿱臼土	Oppose Unification [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Disunify. Used personal name.
01966	01966 木 75.9.3 KC-10092 TS 13 · IDS ⿰木⿱臼土	Unification [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Disunify. Used as a personal name.
00008	00008 一 1.5.1 KC-10175 TS 6 · IDS ⿱干䒑	Oppose Unification [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Disunify. 1) Used personal name. 2) It is not necessary to unify Kaishu(楷書) with Guwen(古文).
02131	02131 水 85.11.1 KC-10190 TC-717B TS 14 · IDS ⿰氵梅	Unification [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Unify.
01411	01411 彳 60.7.1 KC-10377 TS 10 · IDS ⿰彳束	Oppose Unification [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Disunify.
02995	02995 糸 120.12.2 KC-10400 TS 18 · IDS ⿲糸⿱山王攵	Unification [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Unify.

Attributes

Showing 68 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
02402	02402 犬 94.17.5 KC-10002 TS 21 · IDS ⿰犭翼	Total Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change TS=20.
04259	04259 馬 187.13.3 KC-10006 TS 23 · IDS ⿰馬⿱𠔉言	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	An additional IDS is OK.
02590	02590 皿 108.13.3 KC-10008 TS 18 · IDS ⿱⿰彖夂皿	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿱⿰彖攵皿.
01981	01981 木 75.16.5 KC-10010 UK-30619 TS 20 · IDS ⿰木隱	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change SC=17, TS=21.
04014	04014 阜 170.14.1 KC-10013 TS 22 · IDS ⿰阝臺	Total Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change TS=17.
01679	01679 手 64.16.2 KC-10017 TS 20 · IDS ⿰扌冀	Total Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change TS=19
02768	02768 示 113.13.2 KC-10019 TS 18 · IDS ⿰礻戢	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿰示戢.
01481	01481 心 61.10.1 KC-10025 TS 14 · IDS ⿰忄畟	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change FS=2, TS=13.
02450	02450 玉 96.11.5 KC-10029 TS 16 · IDS ⿰王務	Total Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change TS=15.
02353	02353 牛 93.12.1 KC-10030 TS 16 · IDS ⿰牜華	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	An additional IDS is OK. Change FS=2
01796	01796 日 72.11.2 KC-10037 TS 15 · IDS ⿰日將	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change FS=5
02504	02504 田 102.11.1 KC-10043 TS 16 · IDS ⿱爽田	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿱𡙁田.
02504	02504 田 102.11.1 KC-10043 TS 16 · IDS ⿱爽田	IDS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change IDS=⿱𡙁田.
03376	03376 艸 140.22.1 KC-10048 TS 28 · IDS ⿱艹霽	Total Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change TS=26.
03367	03367 艸 140.18.1 KC-10049 TS 24 · IDS ⿱艹燾	Total Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change TS=22.
02761	02761 示 113.11.4 KC-10066 TS 16 · IDS ⿰礻淵	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿰示淵. Change SC=12. Change TS=17.
02744	02744 示 113.9.1 KC-10074 TS 14 · IDS ⿰示若	FS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change FS=2.
01791	01791 日 72.11.1 KC-10078 TS 15 · IDS ⿰日曼	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change FS=2
01529	01529 心 61.17.2 KC-10090 TS 21 · IDS ⿰忄闊	Total Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change TS=20
01966	01966 木 75.9.3 KC-10092 TS 13 · IDS ⿰木⿱臼土	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change SC=9, TS=13.
03359	03359 艸 140.16.2 KC-10094 TS 22 · IDS ⿱艹默	Total Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change TS=20.
03359	03359 艸 140.16.2 KC-10094 TS 22 · IDS ⿱艹默	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Could change IDS to ⿱艹⿺黑犬? KR requests IRG to discuss.
03276	03276 艸 140.8.3 KC-10095 TS 18 · IDS ⿱艹秃	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change SC=7, TS=11.
00606	00606 口 30.13.1 KC-10097 TS 16 · IDS ⿱⿻丅𠈌回	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿱⿻十𠈌回.
04159	04159 頁 181.7.3 KC-10098 TS 16 · IDS ⿰⿱勿口頁	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	An additional IDS is OK.
01268	01268 山 46.11.2 KC-10101 TS 14 · IDS ⿰山畟	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change SC=10, TS=13.
02636	02636 目 109.15.1 KC-10103 TS 20 · IDS ⿰目莊	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change SC=11, FS=2, TS=16.
02515	02515 疒 104.4.1 KC-10105 TS 9 · IDS ⿸疒不	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿸疒不.
01516	01516 心 61.14.1 KC-10107 TS 17 · IDS ⿰忄蓍	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change FS=2
01809	01809 日 72.13.1 KC-10119 TS 17 · IDS ⿱敬曰	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿱敬日.
02750	02750 示 113.9.2 KC-10121 TS 14 · IDS ⿰礻則	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿰示則.
03480	03480 衣 145.13.1 KC-10123 TS 19 · IDS ⿱敬衣	FS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change FS=2.
02563	02563 白 106.9.1 KC-10128 TS 14 · IDS ⿰白英	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change FS=2
01371	01371 廴 54.3.5 KC-10134 TS 6 · IDS ⿰廴己	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿺廴己.
01744	01744 日 72.5.4 KC-10138 TS 9 · IDS ⿱曰必	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿱日必.
02751	02751 示 113.9.3 KC-10141 TS 14 · IDS ⿰礻急	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿰示急.
02745	02745 示 113.9.1 KC-10145 TS 14 · IDS ⿰礻勃	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿰示勃.
02746	02746 示 113.9.1 KC-10149 TS 14 · IDS ⿰礻郁	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿰示郁.
02764	02764 示 113.12.1 KC-10150 TS 17 · IDS ⿰礻雲	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿰示雲.
02763	02763 示 113.11.5 KC-10152 TS 16 · IDS ⿰礻翏	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿰示翏.
02769	02769 示 113.14.2 KC-10153 TS 19 · IDS ⿲礻⿱山糸攵	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿰示𢾰.
01976	01976 木 75.14.4 KC-10157 TS 18 · IDS ⿰木宲	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change SC=10, TS=14.
02728	02728 示 113.2.3 KC-10161 TS 7 · IDS ⿰礻八	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿰示八.
02735	02735 示 113.6.3 KC-10162 TS 11 · IDS ⿰礻䏌	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿰示䏌.
01823	01823 日 72.18.1 KC-10163 TS 22 · IDS ⿰日藎	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change FS=2
03288	03288 艸 140.9.2 KC-10165 TS 13 · IDS ⿳艹吅山	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	An additional IDS is OK.
03093	03093 羽 124.13.1 KC-10166 TS 19 · IDS ⿰羽敬	FS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change FS=2
02505	02505 田 102.12.3 KC-10169 TS 17 · IDS ⿱田敏	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change SC=11, TS=16.
00008	00008 一 1.5.1 KC-10175 TS 6 · IDS ⿱干䒑	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	An additional IDS=⿻王丷 is OK.
04236	04236 香 186.18.1 KC-10181 TS 27 · IDS ⿰香薰	FS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change FS=2.
03746	03746 車 159.10.1 KC-10197 TS 17 · IDS ⿰車莫	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change FS=2, SC=11, TS=18.
02736	02736 示 113.6.3 KC-10201 TS 12 · IDS ⿰礻各	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿰示各.
02736	02736 示 113.6.3 KC-10201 TS 12 · IDS ⿰礻各	Total Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change TS=11
02290	02290 火 86.16.2 KC-10224 TS 20 · IDS ⿰火嶲	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change SC=15, TS=19.
01772	01772 日 72.8.3 KC-10242 TS 12 · IDS ⿰日始	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change FS=5
04234	04234 香 186.11.3 KC-10252 TS 20 · IDS ⿰香參	FS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	FS=5 ?
01695	01695 攴 66.4.1 KC-10256 TS 8 · IDS ⿰赫攵	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change SC=14, TS=18.
02142	02142 水 85.11.4 KC-10258 TS 14 · IDS ⿰氵寀	IDS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change IDS=⿰氵宷. KR will change glyph as IDS=⿰氵宷.
03879	03879 金 167.7.4 KC-10260 TS 15 · IDS ⿱初金	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change SC=8, TS=16.
02174	02174 水 85.14.2 KC-10265 TS 17 · IDS ⿰氵嗽	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS= ⿰氵𠻳.
02192	02192 水 85.18.1 KC-10266 TS 21 · IDS ⿰氵薩	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change FS=2
02795	02795 禾 115.8.1 KC-10276 TS 13 · IDS ⿰禾亟	Residual Stroke Count [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change SC=9, TS=14.
03460	03460 示 113.6.3 KC-10298 TS 11 · IDS ⿰示旭	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿰示旭.
03460	03460 示 113.6.3 KC-10298 TS 11 · IDS ⿰示旭	Radical [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change Radical to 113.0 (示), TS=11.
03186	03186 肉 130.13.3 KC-10332 TS 17 · IDS ⿰月遂	FS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change FS=4
01108	01108 宀 40.14.3 KC-10375 TS 17 · IDS ⿱宀敻	IDS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Change IDS=⿱宀夐.
01261	01261 山 46.10.4 高 189.3.2 KC-10385 TS 13 · IDS ⿱高山	Radical [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree.
02995	02995 糸 120.12.2 KC-10400 TS 18 · IDS ⿲糸⿱山王攵	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS=⿰糸𢽠.

Evidence

Showing 5 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
03593	03593 貝 154.11.1 KC-10053 TS 18 · IDS ⿰貝㒼	Unclear evidence [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	The right component is 㒼.
01966	01966 木 75.9.3 KC-10092 TS 13 · IDS ⿰木⿱臼土	New evidence [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]
01966	01966 木 75.9.3 KC-10092 TS 13 · IDS ⿰木⿱臼土	New evidence [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	『朝鮮王朝實錄⋅世祖實錄』, 世祖 5年(1459) 4月 16日
00393	00393 口 30.5.3 KC-10299 TS 8 · IDS ⿱叱山	Evidence [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	It is possible that 奴𰇿(U+301FF)山 is a person’s name. But the glyph is different. KR wants to keep SN00393.
01265	01265 山 46.11.1 KC-10372 TS 15 · IDS ⿰山莭	Evidence [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	In the evidence, the upper right part of the character is 艹(grass). The character in the first two websites seems an misreading.

Glyph Design & Normalization

Showing 14 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
02768	02768 示 113.13.2 KC-10019 TS 18 · IDS ⿰礻戢	Glyph design [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	KR will change glyph as U+6222(戢).
02504	02504 田 102.11.1 KC-10043 TS 16 · IDS ⿱爽田	Glyph design [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	KR will change glyph as IDS=⿱爽田.
03227	03227 舟 137.10.4 KC-10045 TS 16 · IDS ⿰舟玆	Glyph design [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	KR will change the glyph as ⿰舟玆.
03376	03376 艸 140.22.1 KC-10048 TS 28 · IDS ⿱艹霽	Normalization [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	KR will change the glyph as suggested.
01973	01973 木 75.14.1 KC-10071 TS 18 · IDS ⿲木晋戈;⿰木戬	Glyph design [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	KR will change glyph as U+6229(戩).
03359	03359 艸 140.16.2 KC-10094 TS 22 · IDS ⿱艹默	Normalization [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	黙 will normalize to 默. KR will add new normalization rule.
03276	03276 艸 140.8.3 KC-10095 TS 18 · IDS ⿱艹秃	Glyph design [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	KR will change the glyph as suggested.
02985	02985 糸 120.9.3 KC-10168 TS 15 · IDS ⿰糸衍	Glyph design [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	KR will change the glyph as suggested.
04106	04106 雨 173.15.4 KC-10217 TS 23 · IDS ⿱雨潗	Normalization [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	KR will change the glyph as suggested.
02826	02826 禾 115.23.1 KC-10231 TS 28 · IDS ⿰禾靁	Normalization [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	KR will change the glyph as suggested.
02192	02192 水 85.18.1 KC-10266 TS 21 · IDS ⿰氵薩	Glyph design [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	KR will change the glyph as suggested.
01109	01109 宀 40.15.1 KC-10307 TS 18 · IDS ⿳宀王⿰玉玉	Glyph design [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	The upper part means 宝, therefore KR will change IDS to ⿱宀𬍼.
02286	02286 火 86.15.1 KC-10370 TS 19 · IDS ⿰火震	Normalization [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	KR will change the glyph as suggested.
04079	04079 雨 173.12.4 KC-10398 TS 20 · IDS ⿱雨湒	Normalization [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	KR will change the glyph as suggested.

Editorial

Showing 2 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
02793	02793 禾 115.7.3 KC-10061 TS 12 · IDS ⿰禾谷	Editorial issue [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	The person in the evidence for WS2024-02793 is different from the person in the two pieces for WS2017-03140. KR wants to keep SN02793.
02750	02750 示 113.9.2 KC-10121 TS 14 · IDS ⿰礻則	Editorial issue [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	KR consider not 衤 but 示.

Other

Showing 2 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
01744	01744 日 72.5.4 KC-10138 TS 9 · IDS ⿱曰必	Comment [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Different glyph. Used the personal name.
00393	00393 口 30.5.3 KC-10299 TS 8 · IDS ⿱叱山	Comment [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	U+2D1DD seems related with SN00393. However the glyphs are different.