Conifer TSENG Comments

IRG Working Set 2024v4.0

Source: Conifer TSENG
Date: Generated on 2026-04-15

Show Deleted | Show comments from version: 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 | Show comments with status: Show All New Only Unresolved Only

Unification

Showing 6 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
01098	01098 宀 40.11.1 T13-3E27 TS 14 · IDS ⿱宀規	Unification	Both characters are variants of "窺". Based on UCV rule #354i, TCA agrees to unify to 𡪽 (U+21ABD).
01747	01747 日 72.6.1 T13-3E38 TS 10 · IDS ⿰日臣	Oppose Unification	Although both are variants of "昧", the right-side components differ considerably in shape and no UCV Rule is applicable; therefore, TCA does not agree to unification with 𣆜 (U+2319C).
03575	03575 貝 154.4.1 T13-3E5E TS 11 · IDS ⿰貝互	Oppose Unification	Not Unify to貾 (U+8CBE). See: 1. WS21-03746 2. https://hc.jsecs.org/irg/ws2015/app/?id=01354
04033	04033 雨 173.5.3 T13-3F2A TS 13 · IDS ⿱雨仙	Unification	Thank you for the information. TCA will apply for a horizontal extension for this character in the future.
04050	04050 雨 173.8.4 T13-3F37 TS 16 · IDS ⿱雨炎	Unification	Thank you for the information. TCA will apply for a horizontal extension for this character in the future.
02446	02446 玉 96.11.2 TB-7021 TS 15 · IDS ⿲王⿱山𡈼攵	UCV	TCA agrees to add the UCV Rule, with the following conditions: 1.The components "攵" and "攴" should be treated as separate unification groups under Level 1. 2.The unification of "攵" and "攴" together should be classified as Level 2.

Attributes

Showing 14 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
01108	01108 宀 40.14.3 KC-10375 TS 17 · IDS ⿱宀敻	IDS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	⿱宀夐(U+5910)
03757	03757 車 159.11.5 SAT-09336 TS 18 · IDS ⿰車⿱尸免	IDS [ Unresolved from v3.0 ]	Agree with the comment #1795, IDS=⿰車⿸尸免.
00267	00267 刀 18.7.3 T13-3D36 TS 9 · IDS ⿰⿱斤口刂	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Agree to change the IDS to ⿰𠯓刂.
00314	00314 匸 23.8.1 T13-3D39 TS 10 · IDS ⿷匚拖	IDS [ Unresolved from v3.0 ]	Change the IDS to ⿷匸拖.
00551	00551 口 30.11.2 T13-3D4D TS 14 · IDS ⿰口⿱艹卧	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Agree to change the IDS to ⿰口⿱艹⿰𮍌卜.
00645	00645 口 30.14.1 T13-3D58 TS 17 · IDS ⿰口⿱⿰土冝水	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Agree to change the IDS to ⿰口⿱𱖴水.
00689	00689 口 30.15.2 T13-3D64 TS 18 · IDS ⿰口魌	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change the IDS to ⿰口⿺⿱田儿其 since it'll match the character shape better.
04299	04299 鬼 194.4.3 TB-6362 TS 14 · IDS ⿺⿱田儿午	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	Change IDS to ⿺鬼午.
03330	03330 艸 140.13.2 TB-7D6D TS 17 · IDS ⿱艹⿵門未	IDS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	Agree IDS to ⿵菛未.
04570	04570 鳥 196.17.2 TB-7E79 TS 28 · IDS ⿱艹⿸厂⿱⿰亻住鳥	IDS	Change IDS to ⿱艹⿸雁鳥.
01095	01095 宀 40.10.2 TD-392E TS 13 · IDS ⿳宀日衣	IDS	Agree IDS change to ⿱宀𮲢(U+2ECA2).
00174	00174 人 9.14.3 TD-6749 TS 16 · IDS ⿰亻敻	IDS	Agree IDS change to ⿰亻夐(U+5910).
00941	00941 土 32.12.5 UK-30283 TS 15 · IDS ⿰土逯	IDS [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	⿰土𨓻？
01664	01664 手 64.13.3 VN-F0228 TS 16 · IDS ⿰扌粤	IDS [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	IDS change to ⿰扌粵. 粵=U+7CB5

Evidence

Showing 10 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
03168	03168 肉 130.10.2 GCCPP-00019 TS 14 · IDS ⿰月罢	New evidence	《新華詞典》（大字本）2001年修訂版
03048	03048 缶 121.8.1 GDM-00461 TS 14 · IDS ⿰缶青	New evidence	鄭玉姍著，《上博（一）·孔子詩論》研究，《古典文獻研究輯刊》六篇·第30冊，花木蘭文化出版社，2008.
02939	02939 米 119.7.2 GZHSJ-0052 TS 13 · IDS ⿱米里	New evidence	（清）邢澍撰，《金石文字辨異．去聲．問韻．糞字》引〈北齊治疾方〉
03066	03066 羊 123.2.5 GZHSJ-0089 TS 8 · IDS ⿰羊又	New evidence	《古文字詁林》第10冊，上海教育出版社，p1112.
03344	03344 艸 140.14.4 GZHSJ-0178 TS 18 · IDS ⿳艹冖殘	New evidence	(唐)皮日休、陸龜蒙撰，《松陵集》(毛氏汲古閣明末[1621-1644])，卷一
00787	00787 口 30.21.3 T13-3D74 TS 24 · IDS ⿰口𪛊	Misidentified glyph	Based on the original evidence, the component appears to consist of three "口" (mouths). However, we have found clearer evidence showing only two "口". Therefore, TCA will update the glyph to "⿲口𠎤斤" accordingly. Another version《道藏經》明正統10年刊([内府]
01427	01427 彳 60.14.3 T13-3E2C TS 17 · IDS ⿰彳𫑨	Unclear evidence response	The form "⿲彳魚阝" is also found in other clear edition. Since there is textual evidence for both variants, TCA will maintain the current glyph and will not make any changes at this time. ▼章黼: 《直音篇》, 練川明德書院明萬曆34年[1606]
03575	03575 貝 154.4.1 T13-3E5E TS 11 · IDS ⿰貝互	New evidence	（遼）釋行均撰，《龍龕手鑒》卷三 (虛竹齋清[1644-1911])
00193	00193 儿 10.8.1 TB-5959 TS 10 · IDS ⿺元全	Evidence	The glyph displayed on the company's website (for its name) differs from its official Business Registration record with the Administration for Commerce, MOEA. However, only the registered version carries legal validity, as it serves as the authoritative standard for banking, tax filings, and other official transactions. Therefore, the glyph will remain unchanged. Furthermore, this character is also used in land administration records; the company name is merely one example of its usage. ▼地政專屬第11字面字碼對照表, 2006.11
03009	03009 糸 120.13.5 UTC-03246 TS 19 · IDS ⿰糸𭆤	Evidence	In other versions of the 萬葉集—such as the 嘉暦傳承本, 活字無訓本 and 校本萬葉集—the character is rendered as "縿". 万葉集 : 嘉暦伝承本巻第11 活字無訓本萬葉集卷11 校本萬葉集卷第十一

Glyph Design & Normalization

Showing 8 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
03397	03397 虫 142.6.2 GZ-0132401 TS 12 · IDS ⿰虫⿰龵阝	Glyph design	Does the right part of this character take the form of "⿰龵阝" or "邦"?
01159	01159 尸 44.13.5 GZ-0722101 TS 16 · IDS ⿰尼常	Glyph design [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	According to evidence 1, the glyph is written as [⿺尼常].
03227	03227 舟 137.10.4 KC-10045 TS 16 · IDS ⿰舟玆	Glyph design	Per comments #10842 and #12081, change the glyph and IDS of KC-10045 to ⿰舟兹.
03359	03359 艸 140.16.2 KC-10094 TS 22 · IDS ⿱艹默	Glyph design	Per #8088 and #9291, the glyph for KC-10094 should be changed to ⿱艹默.
01367	01367 广 53.12.4 SAT-09315 TS 15 · IDS ⿸广⿰垔大	Glyph design [ Unresolved from v1.0 ]	In evidence 3, the right component of the character is 火. Please confirm whether the right component should be 火 or 大 .
00286	00286 刀 18.11.4 SAT-09934 TS 13 · IDS ⿰⿱䒑⿻⿰厶口土刂	Glyph design [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	《龍龕手鑑．刀部》《重訂直音篇．卷五．刀部》 "⿰㘴刂" is a variant of "剉". The glyph in Evidence 2 & 3 should better match the 剉斬 description.
00973	00973 土 32.19.5 SAT-10267 TS 22 · IDS ⿱⿰弓⿱𠆢爾土	Glyph design [ Unresolved from v2.0 ]	According to the description in the Evidence, 從弓從[⿱人壐]聲, the glyph should be as ⿰弓⿱𠆢壐.
04349	04349 鬼 194.10.3 T13-4030 TS 17 · IDS ⿺⿱田儿𤙣	Glyph design	After consulting our expert, based on the documentary form, the glyph will not be changed. The expert's opinion is as follows:

Other

Showing 5 comments.

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
03410	03410 虫 142.8.1 GCW-00220 TS 14 · IDS ⿰虫𲁑	Comment	（清）錢繹撰，《方言箋疏》卷八 "⿰虫覔" is a variant of 𧐎. 異典《正字通》申集中·虫部
04239	04239 馬 187.4.2 SAT-10016 TS 12 · IDS ⿹&H6-03;⿰八巾	Other [ Unresolved from v3.0 ]	《集韻．平聲．支韻》 The glyph SAT-10016 is thought to have evolved from "⿹&H6-03; ⿲中丶丶".
03638	03638 足 157.5.3 SAT-10050 TS 12 · IDS ⿲足㚈	Other [ Unresolved from v3.0 ]	A variant of 𧿘 (U+27FDB).
03162	03162 肉 130.9.4 UK-30692 TS 13 · IDS ⿰月养	Other	Evidence shows two simplified forms for 䑆: ⿰月养 and ⿰月奍. However, the form ⿰月奍 (seen in Evidence 2) also functions as a variant of 勝. 《新刻洪武元韻勘正切字海篇群玉》(羣玉海篇)卷三 (《淮南子·說林訓》：土勝水，非一圤塞江。一作墣。)
03257	03257 艸 140.6.3 UTC-03392 TS 10 · IDS ⿱艹𦘱	Other	略字 - Wikipedia The Ryakuji (略字, abbreviated form) of "藤" can be seen as "⿱艹卜 (U+2B1E5) " or "⿱艹𦘱". The component "卜" is likely derived from the Katakana "ト". See comment #11545 in #01144.