Please wait while loading

IRG Working Set 2024v5.0

Source: John Knightley
Date: Generated on 2026-11-22

Show Deleted | Show comments from version: 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 | Show comments with status: Show All New Only Unresolved Only

Attributes

Showing 7 comments.

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
00783
00783
口 30.20.4
UK-30866
TS 23 · IDS ⿰口襪
Residual Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v3.0 ]
Agree SC=21
Total Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v3.0 ]
Agree TC=24
00456
00456
口 30.8.4
UK-30898
TS 11 · IDS ⿰口衫
Residual Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v3.0 ]
Agree SC=9
Total Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v3.0 ]
Agree TC=12
00541
00541
口 30.11.1
UK-30903
TS 14 · IDS ⿰口⿰革匕
IDS
[ Unresolved from v4.0 ]
Agree with comment #14433 to change IDS to ⿰口⿰革𠤎.
02389
02389
犬 94.10.4
VN-F0354
TS 13 · IDS ⿰犭竜
Radical
Agree with comment #14543 the current radical is the intuitive radical and therefore the radical should not be changed.
03452
03452
虫 142.18.4
VN-F0525
TS 24 · IDS ⿰虫⿱炏冡
IDS
IDS still to be updated.

Evidence

Showing 7 comments.

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
03232
03232
舟 137.14.3
UK-30453
TS 20 · IDS ⿰舟㥯
New evidence
Form an IRG prospective no further action required, thank you for the new evidence.
01974
01974
木 75.14.1
UK-30454
TS 18 · IDS ⿰木遠
New evidence
Thank you for the new evidence.
02525
02525
疒 104.7.5
UK-30551
TS 12 · IDS ⿸疒即
New evidence
New evidence accepted, thank you.
00177
00177
人 9.17.1
UK-30604
TS 19 · IDS ⿰亻𩋘
Evidence
As the note included in the submission suggests the reading is considered to be nò̤ .
03240
03240
色 139.8.3
UK-30640
TS 14 · IDS ⿰采色
Unclear evidence response
The word means vegetable, the left hand component is the bottom half of 菜 as evidences 1 and 2 clearly show when referring to evidence 3. As comment #12895 points out all 3 evidnces agree as to what thw semantic component. Whilst paper quality and age mean that in evidence 3 the left 采 U+91C7 looks rather like 釆 U+91C6 context makes it clear.
00630
00630
口 30.13.3
UK-30896
TS 16 · IDS ⿰口筴
Evidence
Based on context the reading in Cantonese of this character is haap which make sense as 筴 is an enter tone with a similar sound in Cantonese.
00798
00798
口 30.22.5
UK-30924
TS 25 · IDS ⿰口巒
Evidence
The sumitted character corresponds to -um so only the final of the phonetic component is used. 施 iis 'se' and 三 is 'sam' so only the 'um' of se-sam-um.

Glyph Design & Normalization

Showing 7 comments.

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
01821
01821
日 72.17.2
UK-30028
TS 21 · IDS ⿰日𣋓
Glyph design
Agree to update glyph,
03905
03905
金 167.11.3
UK-30087
TS 19 · IDS ⿰金徙
Glyph design
Agree update glyph
02129
02129
水 85.10.5
UK-30178
TS 13 · IDS ⿰氵剝
Normalization
Agree to normalise, update both glyph and IDS,
00520
00520
口 30.10.4
UK-30381
TS 13 · IDS ⿰口宸
Glyph design
[ Unresolved from v4.0 ]
Agree to update glyph per comment #13763.
00447
00447
口 30.8.2
UK-30891
TS 11 · IDS ⿰口虲
Normalization
Disagree normalization.
00541
00541
口 30.11.1
UK-30903
TS 14 · IDS ⿰口⿰革匕
Glyph design
[ Unresolved from v4.0 ]
Agree to update glyph per comments #12178 and #13811.
02854
02854
竹 118.4.1
UK-30934
TS 10 · IDS ⿱竹𭀖
Glyph design
[ Unresolved from v3.0 ]
As comment #11549 observes, that the note at time of submission stated that not all evidences included the dot.

Other

Showing 1 comments.

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
00716
00716
口 30.16.2
UK-30722
TS 19 · IDS ⿱北嘜
Other
Thank you for comment #14650, even though the meaning given to the table is /ok/ and this is clearly the reading based on Cantonese pronunciation for the characters in the table with 屋 as a component, the correct reading of UK-30722 is not the same.