GKJ-00222 |
| Date | Description |
|---|---|
| IRG #59 2022-10-20 (Thu) 11:40 am +0800 Recorded by CHEN Zhuang | pending for additional evidence |
| IRG #59 2022-10-20 (Thu) 11:49 am +0800 Recorded by CHEN Zhuang | move back to M set, new evidences accepted. |
| IRG #57 2021-09-16 (Thu) 10:39 am +0800 Recorded by CHEN Zhuang | Postponed for further investigation |
| Version | Description |
|---|---|
| 2.0 | For 04587, add Discussion Record "Postponed for further investigation, IRG 57." |
| 2.0 | For 04587, change Status to Postponed |
| 4.0 | For 04587, change Status to OK |
| 4.0 | For 04587, add Discussion Record "Evidence accepted, IRG 59." |
| Source Reference | Glyph |
|---|---|
| GKJ-00222 |
| group | China (GKJ - Science and Technology Characters) |
| a) Source reference | GKJ-00222 |
| b) PUA Code of TTF | E009 |
| c) KangXi Radical Code(Primary) | 195.0 |
| d) Stroke Count(Primary) | 7 |
| e) First Stroke(Primary) | 1 |
| g) Total Stroke Count | 18 |
| i) IDS (Ideographic Description Sequence) | ⿰魚两 |
| j) Similar/ Variants | N/A |
| k) Ref. to Evidence doc | 韻經五卷 |
Review Comments
Here is the full evidence from 《韻經·十一梗》
▲韻經. 明嘉靖十八年(1539)長水書院刻本.
http://read.nlc.cn/allSearch/searchDetail?searchType=all&showType=1&indexName=data_892&fid=GBZX0301015813
韻經 is a rime dictionary, which means ⿰魚两 must rhyme with 邴寎蛃. If the phonetic component of ⿰魚两 is 两, it clearly does not rhyme with 蛃. I doubt ⿰魚两 is an error form of 𩶁.
““丙”与“两”二字形音义关系密切,使用时代互补,皆可证金文“两”为“丙”的分化字,
其量词用法继承自量词“丙””(p.36)
李建平、龙仕平2018 量词“丙”“两”的语源及其历时演变《古汉语研究》2018年03期,pp.32-38.
https://www.cnki.com.cn/article/cjfdtotal-ghyy201803004.htm
《韻經》五卷,成書于嘉靖十七年(1538),張之象編輯。全書正文包含了古韻和今韻兩部分内容,其古韻參照吳械的《韻補》和楊慎的《轉注古音略》,繼承中又有自己的創見,今韻依據詩韻,并結合實際語音,分韻為一百一十六部。
https://cdmd.cnki.com.cn/Article/CDMD-10394-1015720357.htm
Although ⿰魚两 is obviously the variant of 𩶁, there is no rule for unification of 丙 and 两. As a head character of a dictionary, it has an independent status other from the ones occasionally appear in the text.
▲ 韻經(明萬曆刊本)卷3 folio 7a
Suggest to move this character in M-set.