Please wait while loading

IRG Working Set 2021v2.0

Consolidated Comments
Filter By Source: Sort By: Show Deleted:

Unification

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
00278
00278
冫 15.7
9 · ㇐ (1)
GDM-00237
Unification
TAO Yang
China
Most of the CJK characters in Unicode are variants of another character as a large number of the characters proposed in WS2021. So, this is not an argument for unification.
Oppose Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
Agree with Tao Yang.
00105
00105
二 7.9
11 · ㇑ (2)
GDM-00296
Unification
Kushim JIANG
Individual
Unify to “亚尔”.

The name comes from གཡག་ར་གཞུང་ཆུ (Yag-ra-xung-qu, gyag-ra-gšuń-cʰu by myself). Yag for ‘male yak’, Ra for ‘goat’, Xung for ‘main’, Qu for ‘river’. The correct translation should be ‘亚克惹雄曲’, ‘亚尔惹熊曲’ is a just-so-so translation. But ‘亚尔’ is definitely not a character.
02899
02899
穴 116.7
12 · ㇑ (2)
GDM-00313
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
U+7A93
U+25997
Single example of an idiosyncratic way of writing 窓, not sufficient evidence for encoding. Unify with 𥦗 by UCV #22.
Oppose Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
The radical of 𥦗 is 穴 while the radical of ⿱宀总 is 宀, which means the change is important enough.
04626
04626
魚 195.11
22 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00216
Ucv
HUANG Junliang
Individual
⿳一⿰忄舟一 / 𢛢
04645
04645
魚 195.13
24 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00226
Oppose Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
Agree with above comments.
04582
04582
魚 195.6
17 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00263
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
U+311AE
unify to 𱆮 (U+311AE)?

This character looks like the variant of 鮮.
Unification
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
U+311AE
U+9BAE
U+300A
U+65AF
Agree with Eiso that the character unifies to 𱆮 (U+311AE), but it isn't the variant of 鮮. According to 《揅經室集》, ⿰魚芊 shares the same meaning with 斯.

《揅經室集》
https://ctext.org/library.pl?if=gb&file=41001&page=23
04693
04693
鳥 196.4
15 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00351
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
U+2EB2E
Unify to 𮬮 (U+2EB2E)
03668
03668
虫 142.19
25 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00444
Unification
Eddie LI
Individual
KC-07866 ?
03633
03633
虫 142.12
18 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00466
Unification
Eddie LI
Individual
U+8776
蝶?
Oppose Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
It's not better to unify to 蝶 (U+8776), because the component is too different.
04177
04177
金 167.14
22 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00515
V4-5642
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04058
04058
金 167.2
7 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00533
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+30F55
unify to 𰽕 (U+30F55)
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+30F55
Agree. Add a extension to 𰽕 (U+30F55).
02427
02427
犬 94.12
15 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00534
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2486E
unify to 𤡮 (U+2486E)
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree.
02326
02326
犬 94.2
5 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00535
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2DDF8
unify to 𭷸 (U+2DDF8)
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2DDF8
Agree. Add a extension to 𭷸 (U+2DDF8).
02368
02368
犬 94.8
11 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00540
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+730D
unify to 猍 (U+730D)
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree.
02369
02369
犬 94.8
11 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00543
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+3085C
unify to 𰡜 (U+3085C)
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree.
02444
02444
犬 94.14
17 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00545
UK-20893
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02390
02390
犬 94.9
12 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00555
TB-5027
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02405
02405
犬 94.10
13 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00556
VN-F1A19
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02356
02356
犬 94.7
10 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00569
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+247A2
unify to 𤞢 (U+247A2)
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+247A2
02356 and 𤞢 (U+247A2) are the same character.
https://www.kangxizidian.com/v2/index.php?page=3405&dpy=2
02349
02349
犬 94.6
9 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00597
UK-20025
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02339
02339
犬 94.5
8 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00600
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
[ WS2017-02513 ]
unify to WS2017-02513 UK-10799
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
[ WS2017-02513 ]
Agree. Add a extension to WS2017-02513.
02340
02340
犬 94.5
8 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00604
UK-20151
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00730
00730
口 30.17
20 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00606
UK-20392
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02396
02396
犬 94.9
12 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00611
UK-20505
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02337
02337
犬 94.5
8 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00613
UK-20608
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02453
02453
犬 94.15
18 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00614
UK-20336
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02417
02417
犬 94.11
15 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00628
Unification
Eddie LI
Individual
U+2483C
misprint of 𤠼?
Oppose Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
It's not better to unify to 𤠼 (U+2483C), because the components are too different.
04919
04919
鼠 208.6
19 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00640
Unification
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
U+9F35
U+9D4C
similar to 鼵, which 鵌鼵 are always mentioned together.
04922
04922
鼠 208.7
20 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00643
Unification
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
U+300A
U+9D4C
The complete sentence of evidence 1 is “鼵~同處穴”. According to 《康熙字典‧亥集下‧鼠部‧鼵》:“【爾雅‧釋獸】鳥鼠同穴,其鳥為鵌,其鼠為鼵。”It seems that ⿰鼠余 is the misprint of 鵌.

《舒蓺室詩存》
https://ctext.org/library.pl?if=gb&file=41995&page=28

《康熙字典‧亥集下‧鼠部》
https://ctext.org/library.pl?if=en&file=77415&page=1529
04911
04911
鼠 208.5
18 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00644
Unification
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
U+9F2A
Is it a misprint of 鼪?

《康熙字典‧亥集下‧鼠部‧鼪》:「【爾雅·釋獸】【註】江東呼鼬鼠爲鼪,能啖鼠。俗呼鼠狼。」
https://ctext.org/library.pl?if=en&file=77415&page=1528
01588
01588
手 64.16
19 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00651
Unification
BAI Yi
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+64F8
Unify to 擸 (U+64F8)
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+64F8
U+5EE3
U+897F
Agree to unify it to 擸 (U+64F8). This word 擸𢶍 exists in 廣韻 and 西南官話.
04920
04920
鼠 208.7
20 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00653
Unification
HUANG Junliang
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+9F30


Unify to 鼰.

鼰 in 康熙字典(同文書局本):「【字彙補】南見切,音睍。【爾雅·釋獸】鼰鼠。」According to the evidence:

鼰 and ⿰鼠見 share

1) same pronunciation
2) same meanings
3) strong shape similarity

so we can consider unify ⿰鼠見 to 鼰.
04905
04905
鼠 208.3
16 · ㇠ (5)
GKJ-00654
Unification
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
U+300A
U+9F24
According to 《爾雅》which the evidence mentioned and 《康熙字典》, it seems that ⿰鼠女 is the misprint of 鼤.

U+9F24




https://ctext.org/library.pl?if=gb&file=72832&page=115
《爾雅注疏》

《康熙字典‧亥集下‧鼠部‧鼤》:「【爾雅‧釋獸】鼤鼠、鼨鼠。」
https://ctext.org/library.pl?if=en&file=77415&page=1527
04908
04908
鼠 208.4
17 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00664
Unification
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
U+9F23


This evidence was quoted from 《山海經》 which is 鼣. It seems that ⿰鼠火 is the misprint of 鼣.



https://ctext.org/library.pl?if=gb&file=77823&page=57#%E7%99%BD%E8%80%B3
《山海經》,《四部叢刊初編》
04915
04915
鼠 208.6
19 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00665
Unification
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
U+300A
U+9F32
There is another version of 《蘇魏公文集》, which shows 鼲 as below.



https://ctext.org/library.pl?if=gb&file=2005&page=138
《蘇魏公文集》,《欽定四庫全書》
02319
02319
牛 93.11
15 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00671
UK-20053
鹿
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04834
04834
鹿 198.3
14 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00675
鹿
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2EB72
unify to 𮭲 (U+2EB72)
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2EB72
Agree. Add a extension to 𮭲 (U+2EB72).
03147
03147
网 122.11
15 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00676
𠔿鹿
Unification
Eddie LI
Individual
U+4361
04882
04882
鹿 198.16
27 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00677
鹿
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
[ WS2017-04947 ]
unify to WS2017-04947 GHC-0047.00 UTC-03158
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree.
04853
04853
鹿 198.7
18 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00685
UK-20484
鹿
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04835
04835
鹿 198.4
15 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00692
鹿
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+9E89
unify to 麉 (U+9E89)?
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+9E89
Unify to 麉 (U+9E89) by UCV #180
04833
04833
鹿 198.3
14 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00699
鹿
Unification
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
U+300A
U+3010
U+2A291
According to 《康熙字典‧亥集下‧鹿部‧𪊑》:“【正韻】經天切,𠀤音堅。【說文】鹿之絕有力者……”and 《康熙字典‧亥集下‧鹿部‧麉》:“ 【字彙】同𪊑。” , which ⿸鹿寸 share the same meaning and pronunciation with 𪊑, the evidence seems to be:“極有力者曰:麉、𪊑。” Therefore, I doubt that ⿸鹿寸 is the misprint of 𪊑.

《康熙字典‧亥集下‧鹿部》
https://ctext.org/library.pl?if=gb&file=77415&page=1509#32
04870
04870
鹿 198.9
20 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00701
鹿
Unification
Eddie LI
Individual
TE-3A4D
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
04862
鹿 198.8
19 · ㇐ (1)
TE-3A4D
鹿
unify to WS2021-04862:TE-3A4D

UCV #424
04883
04883
鹿 198.24
35 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00705
UK-20580
鹿
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00054
00054
乙 5.5
6 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00730
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+7269
unify to 物 (U+7269)

It's the variant of U+7269 物 clearly according to the context of the evidence.
00604
00604
口 30.12
15 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00731
𣓏
Unification
TAO Yang
China
U+5664
U+7384
Unify to 噤 (U+5664), a temporary error in 玄應一切經音義.
慧琳一切經音義
一切經音義
玄應一切經音義
02307
02307
牛 93.4
8 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00741
VN-F1A16
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
01598
01598
手 64.18
21 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00749
Unification
HUANG Junliang
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+270D4
U+270D4


Unify to 𧃔.

The evidence has 蒴⿰扌藋.

康熙字典(同文書局本):「【申集上】【艸字部】 【唐韻】直角切,音濯。【玉篇】蒴𧃔,藥草。」
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
U+270D4
Agree to unify to 𧃔 (U+270D4).

(宋)王懷隱編,《太平聖惠方》(烏絲欄鈔本)卷14
02473
02473
玉 96.6
10 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00751
Unification
HUANG Junliang
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+73EC


Unify to 珬 by UCV #49.

康熙字典(同文書局本):「【廣韻】珂屬。【集韻】珂謂之珬。」
04852
04852
鹿 198.6
17 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00802
鹿𣅀
Unification
Eddie LI
Individual
U+2A2A8
𪊨
Unification
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
Agree with Eddie.

《康熙字典‧亥集下‧鹿部‧麂》:「【本草註】……本作𪊨。」
https://ctext.org/library.pl?if=en&file=77415&page=1509

According to the evidence, this character is related with 麂子. ⿸鹿𣅀 seems to be a misprint of 𪊨.
01956
01956
气 84.3
7 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00803
UK-20235
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04798
04798
鳥' 196'.5
10 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00810
UK-20622
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04823
04823
鳥' 196'.13
18 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00811
Unification
Eddie LI
Individual
U+312A2
𱊢
accounding to the evidence. It should be 𱊢.
Oppose Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
It's not better to unify to 𱊢 (U+312A2), but we request the submitter changing the evidence or withdraw the character.
04802
04802
鳥' 196'.6
11 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00812
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2A248
unify to 𪉈 (U+2A248)
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree.
02694
02694
目 109.7
12 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00813
UK-20832
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04183
04183
金 167.14
22 · ㇠ (5)
GKJ-00829
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2B4DA
unify to 𫓚 (U+2B4DA)
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2B4DA
Agree. Add a extension to 𫓚 (U+2B4DA).
04150
04150
金 167.12
20 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00831
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+30F46
unify to 𰽆 (U+30F46)
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+30F46
Unify to 𰽆 (U+30F46) by UCV #111
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+30F46
Agree. Add a extension to 𰽆 (U+30F46) .
04106
04106
金 167.9
17 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00832
Unification
Eddie LI
Individual
GKJ-00934
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
04108
金 167.9
17 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00934
unify to WS2021-04108:GKJ-00934

They are duplicates now.
04059
04059
金 167.4
12 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00844
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E868
unify to 𮡨 (U+2E868)
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E868
Agree. Add a extension to 𮡨 (U+2E868).
04094
04094
金 167.9
14 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00847
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
Based on discussion concerning WS2021:GKJ-00846, this is identical. One of the 2 should be withdrawn.
04073
04073
金 167.6
14 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00848
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E876
unify to 𮡶 (U+2E876)
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E876
Agree. Add a extension to 𮡶 (U+2E876).
04140
04140
金 167.11
19 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00852
TE-3873
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Eddie LI
Individual
Missing Evidence
03332
03332
艸 140.6
10 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00867
TC-4F5F
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00768
00768
囗 31.4
7 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00874
Unification
Eddie LI
Individual
Missing Evidence
00761
00761
囗 31.2
5 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00875
Unification
Eddie LI
Individual
missing evidence
02739
02739
石 112.4
9 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00878
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
[ WS2017-02947 ]
unify to WS2017-02947 GDM-00112
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree.
02746
02746
石 112.5
10 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00884
Unification
Eddie LI
Individual
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Eddie's unification comment is moot as IRG Working Set 2017 02960 was postponed and therefore no longer in the encoding pipeline. This ideograph effectively replaces it with better evidence.
01955
01955
气 84.2
6 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00889
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
U+23C56
Unify to 𣱖 (U+23C56)?
Based on the text, it's a variant of U+6C23 氣. And U+23C56 𣱖 is also a variant of 氣.

《漢語大字典》,頁2155.
01966
01966
气 84.7
11 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00905
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+306C2
unify to 𰛂 (U+306C2)
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree.
04108
04108
金 167.9
17 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00934
Unification
Eddie LI
Individual
GKJ-00832
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
04106
金 167.9
17 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00832
unify to WS2021-04106:GKJ-00832

They are duplicates now.
02835
02835
示 113.7
11 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00938
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
U+31D53
The current code point for IRG Working Set 2017 #03073 (aka KC-07574) in the Extension H code chart is U+31D53.

04555
04555
鬼 194.6
16 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00998
UK-20785
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04567
04567
鬼 194.12
22 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-01004
UK-20788
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04568
04568
鬼 194.12
21 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-01004
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
03882
03882
足 157.7
14 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-01008
𧾷
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+8E34
Wrong character of 踴, withdraw.
03492
03492
虍 141.4
10 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-01009
Unification
Eddie LI
Individual
U+30C98
𰲘(U+30C98)
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
U+30C98
Unify to 𰲘 (U+30C98) 'female tiger' which is the correct transcription form of the oracle bone script character.
03970
03970
辵 162.8
12 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-01018
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E7A2
unify to 𮞢 (U+2E7A2)
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
AGREE.
00203
00203
人 9.13
15 · ㇐ (1)
GXM-00370
VN-F20A8
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree with unification with VN-F20A8.
03768
03768
言 149.6
13 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-0302202
𠂢
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E60C
unify to 𮘌 (U+2E60C)
Unification
John Knightley
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E60C
Agreed unify with 𮘌 (U+2E60C). Consider horizontal extension.
00186
00186
人 9.10
12 · ㇔ (4)
GZ-0542402
TB-4931
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01429
01429
手 64.3
6 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-0721201
TC-266C
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
John Knightley
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed.
01507
01507
手 64.11
14 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-0721307
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Identical to VN-F0222 / V+60240
Unification
John Knightley
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
No action required as VN-F0222 / V+60240 has not been submitted.
00448
00448
口 30.5
8 · ㇠ (5)
GZ-1181205
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+20C9D
Vietnam uses an identical character, V+60087 / VN-F0080, which is a variant of U+20C9D (⿰口対). If 00448 is not considered to be unifiable with 𠲝 (U+20C9D), then Vietnam will propose a horizontal extension of VN-F0080.
Unification
John Knightley
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+20C9D
Should not be unified to 𠲝 (U+20C9D).
00511
00511
口 30.8
11 · ㇔ (4)
GZ-1582203
UK-20341
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
John Knightley
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed.
03508
03508
虫 142.3
9 · ㇠ (5)
GZ-2091204
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E4F6
unify to 𮓶 (U+2E4F6)
Unification
John Knightley
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E4F6
Agreed unify with 𮓶 (U+2E4F6). Consider horizontal extension.
02799
02799
石 112.12
17 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-2162602
UK-20913
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
John Knightley
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed.
00463
00463
口 30.6
9 · ㇔ (4)
GZ-2251214
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2D1EE
unify to 𭇮 (U+2D1EE)
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2D1EE
Same as U+2D1EE a nôm Tày character read 'dằng', that is probably cognate with 'gyang'
Unification
John Knightley
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed.
02421
02421
犬 94.12
15 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-2381201
UK-20035
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
John Knightley
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed. Different sources so both retained.
03316
03316
色 139.6
12 · ㇔ (4)
GZ-3272501
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
[ WS2017-03646 ]
unify to WS2017-03646 GZ-3272501
Unification
John Knightley
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed, withdraw.
03661
03661
虫 142.16
22 · ㇔ (4)
GZ-3291307
UK-20264
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
John Knightley
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed.
00827
00827
土 32.8
11 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-3531208
UK-20080
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
John Knightley
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed.
01090
01090
尸 44.8
11 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-3571207
Unification
Eddie LI
Individual
GZ-3571207
Oppose Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
There is no unification issue for Comment #3044. There is no need to unify one character to itself.
Oppose Unification
LI Yuan
SAT
Agree to #3899.
01520
01520
手 64.11
15 · ㇠ (5)
GZ-3902201
𨳝
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
U+648B
Unify to 撋 (U+648B)?

UCV #1 (IRGN2514)
00218
00218
人 9.15
15 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-4122102
Unification
John Knightley
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree glyph should be ⿰面來 in line with the evidence.
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
TS=17
03884
03884
足 157.7
14 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-4242101
𧾷
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E6DD
unify to 𮛝 (U+2E6DD)
Unification
John Knightley
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed, consider horizontal extension.
03909
03909
足 157.14
21 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-4321206
𧾷
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=14 if the glyph been normalized as #1783 shows.

SC should be kept if the glyph been kept.
Unification
John Knightley
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Above SC comment mis-classified as unification.
01444
01444
手 64.5
8 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-4551301
VN-F18EB
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree with unification
Unification
John Knightley
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed.
01451
01451
手 64.6
9 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-4781601
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2D824
unify to 𭠤 (U+2D824)
Unification
John Knightley
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed.
00058
00058
乙 5.5
6 · ㇒ (3)
KC-00025
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+3003F
According to KR Norm. 312-1, this character should be unified to 𰀿 (U+3003F).



The submitted evidence for U+3003F 𰀿 KC-00038 is shown as below.



However, I think they are different character, so ROK should provide more information on these two characters (or glyphs).
Unification
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+3003F
U+3003F/KC-00038 is used for a personal name.

In general, characters used for personal or place names (i.e., proper nouns) are not necessarily subject to these KR Normalization Rules.

KC-00025 is used to indicate an object name.
00171
00171
人 9.9
11 · ㇒ (3)
KC-00160
TC-5166
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00173
人 9.9
11 · ㇒ (3)
TC-5166
KR agrees to unify SN 00171/KC-00160 and SN 00173/TC-5166 in WS2021.
00222
00222
人 9.15
17 · ㇔ (4)
KC-00217
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2B8F7
unify to 𫣷 (U+2B8F7)
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2B8F7
Unify to 𫣷 (U+2B8F7) by UCV #175
Unification
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2B8F7
KR agrees to unify SN 00222/KC-00217 with 𫣷 (U+2B8F7) (TD674C)
00441
00441
口 30.5
8 · ㇐ (1)
KC-00402
Oppose Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Not unify to WS2021-00442 KC-00404

土/士 is one unifiable pair as UCV #312
Unification
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00442
口 30.5
8 · ㇐ (1)
KC-00404
KR disagree to unify SN 00441./KC-00402 and SN 00442/KC-00404.
00442
00442
口 30.5
8 · ㇐ (1)
KC-00404
Oppose Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Not unify to WS2021-00441 KC-00402

土/士 is one unifiable pair as UCV #312
Unification
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00441
口 30.5
8 · ㇐ (1)
KC-00402
KR disagree to unify SN 00442/KC-00404 with SN 00441./KC-00402.
00502
00502
口 30.8
11 · ㇒ (3)
KC-00452
Unification
Eddie LI
Individual
U+54FF
Oppose Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
The title of this poem in the evidence is 《古意三首》. When we read this poem carefully, it's not hard to find out there are three parts based on the rhyme characters. The first part is 甕(옹)宋(송)洞(동)夢(몽), the second part is 隙(극)白(백)藥(약)獨(독) and the third part is 先(선)賢(현)全(전)年(년). The submitted character is in the second part. Notice that the real rhymes (vowels and the following consonants in the syllables) are different in Old Chinese, Middle Chinese (that means 平水韻 here) and Korean readings, maybe we should call it as 押鄰韻 (rhyme adjacently?). The previous verse “胡爲勞形役” is an interrogative question, so the verse with the submitted character should be the reply to the previous verse. This verse looks related to “哿矣富人,哀此惸獨。” in 《詩經·小雅·正月》. However, if we treated this character is the same as 哿 totally, the meaning is contrary to Confucian ideas and the spiritual style of this poem.

My suggestion to keep and encode this character as-is.
00843
00843
土 32.9
12 · ㇐ (1)
KC-00674
TD-2351
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00846
土 32.9
12 · ㇐ (1)
TD-2351
KR agrees to uinify SN 00843/KC-00674 with SN 00846/TD-2351.
00159
00159
人 9.8
10 · ㇒ (3)
KC-04805
T9-792C
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00161
人 9.8
10 · ㇒ (3)
T9-792C
KR agrees to unify SN 00159 with SN 00161.
00304
00304
刀 18.6
8 · ㇒ (3)
KC-04852
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2070B
unify to 𠜋 (U+2070B)

This is a character for surname in ancient China, and U+2070B 𠜋 is the variant of U+4FB4 侴.
Unification
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00340
力 19.10
12 · ㇠ (5)
V4-516F
U+2070B
KR agrees to unify SN 00340/KC-04852 wuit U+2070B.
00961
00961
大 37.12
15 · ㇒ (3)
KC-04953
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E7C1
Unify to 𮟁
Modify the glyph to match the evidence and unify to 𮟁.
Unification
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E7C1
KR agrees to modify the glyph of SN 00961/KC-04953 and to unify SN 00961 with 𮟁 (U+2E7C1).
01438
01438
手 64.5
8 · ㇐ (1)
KC-05112
TC-323B
UTC-00638
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
KR agrees to unify SN 01438 with SNs 01442 and 01440.
02004
02004
水 85.5
8 · ㇒ (3)
KC-05231
TC-3E43
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02011
水 85.6
9 · ㇒ (3)
TC-3E43
KR agrees to unify SN 02004 with SN 02011.
02124
02124
水 85.17
20 · ㇐ (1)
KC-05292
𠦝
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2C266
unify to 𬉦 (U+2C266)
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2C266
The evidence actually shows U+2C266, not the form proposed by Korea.
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Based on UCV# 384

unify to 𬉦 (U+2C266).
Unification
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2C266
KR agrees to unify SN 02124 with 𬉦 (U+2C266). The glyph will remains unchanged according to KR Norm. Rule 335-1.
02490
02490
玉 96.9
13 · ㇠ (5)
KC-05391
TD-795B
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02498
玉 96.10
14 · ㇒ (3)
TD-795B
KR agrees to unify SN 02490 with SN 02498.
03979
03979
辵 162.11
15 · ㇑ (2)
KC-05584
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
U+907B
unify to 遻 (U+907B)?

The word shown in the evidence looks like 相遻.
04152
04152
金 167.12
20 · ㇐ (1)
KC-05820
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
04228
04228
門 169.8
8 · ㇑ (2)
KC-06061
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+28CC8
unify to 𨳈 (U+28CC8)
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree with Eiso.
Unification
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+28CC8
KR agrees to unify SN 04228 with 𨳈 (U+28CC8).
01057
01057
宀 40.13
16 · ㇔ (4)
SAT-03893
𡧡丿
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+8CD3
Unify to 賓?
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion as there is no rule to judge unification with 賓 (U+8CD3) now.
The evidence particularly designates the component as the upper part.
01417
01417
戈 62.4
8 · ㇐ (1)
SAT-04258
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+22992
Unify to 𢦒?
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion as there is no rule to judge unification with 𢦒 (U+22992) now.
The evidence particularly designates the component as the upper part.
04270
04270
阜 170.10
13 · ㇠ (5)
SAT-04580
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E955
unify to 𮥕 (U+2E955)
Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E955
Agree. Unify to 𮥕 (U+2E955).
01655
01655
日 72.3
7 · ㇑ (2)
SAT-04583
丿
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+24C1E
Unify to 𤰞 (U+24C1E)?
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion as there is no rule to judge unification now.
00428
00428
又 29.17
19 · ㇑ (2)
SAT-05094
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unify to 00429(SAT-05095)?
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion as there is no rule to judge unification now.
02173
02173
火 86.6
10 · ㇔ (4)
SAT-05626
𢑑
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+3079D
unify to 𰞝 (U+3079D)
Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree. Withdraw.
03246
03246
肉 130.10
14 · ㇒ (3)
SAT-05648
Unification
Henry CHAN
Individual
U+8173
Unify to 腳; change NUCV-343 to UCV-343.

Despite there being a NUCV-343 [卻, 郤], historically ⿰木郤 and ⿰木卻 have been unified at U+3B9D, until Unicode 12.0 where the G glyph was corrected from ⿰木卻 to ⿰木郤.

It is suggested to change NUCV-343 to a UCV rule, as it appears such variation is not rare. The non-cognate rule can be invoked to separately code characters with 郤 and 卻 when actually required.
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
Agree with the unification and new UCV rule suggested by Henry Chan.
02883
02883
禾 115.11
16 · ㇒ (3)
SAT-05697
鹿
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E0E8
unify to 𮃨 (U+2E0E8)
Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree. Withdraw.
00416
00416
又 29.6
8 · ㇑ (2)
SAT-05802
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+20B38
Unify to 𠬸?
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion as there is no rule to judge unification now.
Ucv
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Suggest to add UCV ⿱回又 and 𠬸, and unify to 𠬸.

Based on context the quoted character is identical in semantics to 𠬸 as it refer to an ancient form of the right hand part of 歿.
Ucv
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree to add UCV per #1047 if approved.
02292
02292
爿 90.13
17 · ㇐ (1)
SAT-05853
𤕫
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+30905
unify to 𰤅 (U+30905)
Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree. Withdraw.
01610
01610
攴 66.9
13 · ㇑ (2)
SAT-05880
𰏘
Ucv
HUANG Junliang
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
According to the evidence it is cognate to 敝. Add ucv for 𰏘/㡀 ?
03049
03049
糸 120.3
9 · ㇑ (2)
SAT-05998
VN-F06F7
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01224
01224
巾 50.5
8 · ㇑ (2)
SAT-06003
Unification
TAO Yang
China
U+6013
Unify to 怓.
康熙字典
00561
00561
口 30.10
13 · ㇒ (3)
SAT-06006
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
[ WS2017-00501 ]
unify to WS2017-00501 VN-F16C6
Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree. Withdraw.
00920
00920
土 32.16
19 · ㇔ (4)
SAT-06008
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2D40B
According to the paraphrase content [从谷害声], this character could be unified with 𭐋 (U+2D40B).
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
The character is found in the context "或作⿰害各" immediately before, so the difference in the component must be intended.
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]

一切經音義 (唐)釋慧琳撰 日本明治十三至十八年(1880-1885)日本東京弘教書院鉛印本
Both 𭐋 (U+2D40B) and SAT-06008 are from SAT source, so SAT need to decide which edition of 一切經音義 should be the best source to dig the unencoded characters.
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
As there has been no additional discussion, we still believe the shape should stand independent unless we have UCV.

One of the rationales is U+2D40B appears in a headword of 慧琳音義 (see below), which is a sign that suggests he sees it as a prescriptively acceptable form, as opposed to 非也. We rely on 大正藏 for printed form, and when it is suspicious, look for older versions. The evidence Tao Yang gives is from 縮刷藏 (弘教藏) from the late 19th century, but our evidence shows it consistent with the ultimate source of Tripitaka Koreana in the 13th c.

As a reminder of what we maintained in IRG #52 and #53, 慧琳's notation "非也" is not a reason for rejection alone, because we would likewise have to reject 擾 in favor of 𢺕, or 戯 of 戲 and so on by that standard.

01239
01239
巾 50.16
19 · ㇒ (3)
SAT-06060
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+22933
unify to 𢤳 (U+22933)

UCV #173, and the evidence has showed it's the variant of U+6192 憒
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Still needs discussion whether 忄 and 巾 are unifiable.
Unification
TAO Yang
China
U+22933
The character on the same page is surely 𢤳 (U+22933), so SAT-06060 must be a wrong handwriting glyph.
02704
02704
目 109.9
14 · ㇒ (3)
SAT-06061
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2DFCD
unify to 𭿍 (U+2DFCD)
Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree. Withdraw.
01364
01364
心 61.11
14 · ㇑ (2)
SAT-06077
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+6137
Unify to 愷 (U+6137)?
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion as there is no rule to judge unification now.
Ucv
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
UCV examples

U+26A8D 𦪍 vs U+26A74 𦩴
U+2EA1C 𮨜 vs U+9857 顗
U+3112E 𱄮 vs U+29949 𩥉
03943
03943
車 159.8
15 · ㇑ (2)
SAT-06136
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E759
unify to 𮝙 (U+2E759)
Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree. Withdraw.
02325
02325
牛 93.19
23 · ㇐ (1)
SAT-06149
&SAT-H19A;
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+3E5B
unify to 㹛 (U+3E5B)
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion as there is no rule to judge unification now.
01377
01377
心 61.12
15 · ㇔ (4)
SAT-06250
𭁄
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
U+398D
00534
口 30.9
12 · ㇑ (2)
SAT-06968
𭁄
unify to 㦍 (U+398D) as the new UCV accepted under WS2021-00534:SAT-06968.
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
Agree with Eiso's comment.
The first evidence mentions “說文云直言也 從心㖾聲或作遻……”
I think 01377(SAT-06250) should be the same as 㦍 (U+398D), and suggest unifying to 㦍 (U+398D).
03144
03144
网 122.6
12 · ㇑ (2)
SAT-06265
𠕎
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
[ WS2017-03505 ]
Unify to WS2017-03505 (UK-10504)?
https://hc.jsecs.org/irg/ws2017/app/index.php?id=03505
Oppose Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Not cognate to WS2017-03505, and form of top component is distinct in the two characters: SAT-06265 means a type of net, and must be written with the net radical; whereas UK-10504 means a pimple, and does not use the net radical. The two glyphs are not mutually acceptable, so oppose unification per PnP 2.1.3 Non-cognate Rule.
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion how much the top parts of WS2017-03505 and this are cognate.
03113
03113
糸 120.13
19 · ㇠ (5)
SAT-06345
&S4-02;
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
U+26188
Per the new unification rules with regard to structure, it should be unifiable with 𦆈 (U+26188) if cognate.
00445
00445
口 30.5
8 · ㇑ (2)
SAT-06377
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+5434
Unify to 吴
“吴会” is the ancient name of 绍兴.
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion as there is no rule to judge unification now.

cf. disunified examples
俣 U+4FE3 / 㑨 U+3468
脵 U+8135 / 𫞆 U+2B786
00132
00132
人 9.3
5 · ㇒ (3)
SAT-06598
𠧒
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
U+4EE1
unify to 仡 U+4EE1?
Ucv
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Add a new UCV between 𠧒 and 乞.

U+209D2 𠧒=U+4E5E 乞
U+21D4A 𡵊=U+5C79 屹
U+21D4B 𡵋=U+2AA23 𪨣
U+221D2 𢇒=U+221D3 𢇓
U+23C81 𣲁=U+6C54 汔
U+264EA 𦓪=U+43A2 䎢
U+26638 𦘸=U+8090 肐
U+2925F 𩉟=U+4A50 䩐
U+2968B 𩚋=U+4B23 䬣
U+29FA4 𩾤=U+29FA5 𩾥
U+2A5DA 𪗚=U+9F55 齕
U+2E782 𮞂=U+8FC4 迄

If these two components are not unifiable, we will meet more and more character with the component 𠧒 in future, because it is too common.
Ucv
WANG Yifan
SAT
We don't have strong opinion; would like to consult IRG experts.
04172
04172
金 167.13
21 · ㇔ (4)
SAT-06661
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E8C9
unify to 𮣉 (U+2E8C9)?
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Possibly cognate, but we would like to know the identity of U+2E8C9.
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E8C9
Unify to 𮣉 (U+2E8C9) by UCV #112. Not relevant if linguistically cognate or not.
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
The geometrical composition is rather different even though nearly unifiable (note that UCV #112 does not cover the U+2E8C9 shape). We would like to know if the two have developed via different paths (cognateness in shape).
03741
03741
見 147.10
17 · ㇔ (4)
SAT-06662
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
U+25AB0
U+2785F
No meaning is given, but the evidence shows that the reading of this character is identical to that of 誩, for which the "Guang Yun" gives the fanqie reading 渠敬 (*gjængH), Mandarin "jìng". This suggests that it is related to 𥪰 (U+25AB0), which is also read 渠敬 = Mandarin "jìng" and defined in Kangxi as a variant of U+7AF6, 競 read "jìng". Also, given the graphic relationship between 並 and 竝, this also appears to be the full form to U+2785F, another variant of U+7AF6. Seems like a strong argument for semantic identity U+7AF6 and possible unification with one of the encoded forms.
02476
02476
玉 96.7
11 · ㇐ (1)
SAT-06673
𢌜
Unification
Henry CHAN
Individual
U+73FD
To be unified to 珽 (U+73FD) after applying new UCV rule 廷 and 𢌜 in IRG 57.
00676
00676
口 30.15
18 · ㇐ (1)
SAT-06793
𢀩
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2D2FF
unify to 𭋿 (U+2D2FF)
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Possibly cognate, but we would like to know about the identity of U+2D2FF.
01168
01168
山 46.11
14 · ㇑ (2)
SAT-06890
𭦌
Ucv
HUANG Junliang
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
According to 直音篇, ⿰山𭦌 is a variant of 嶒. See MOE dictionary. The given evidence also support that.

According to 漢語大字典, the following 8 encoded pairs are variants, most of which come from 直音篇

𰂬 / 僧 p252
𰻹 / 鄫 p4044
𰯐 / 𦠇 p2261
𰦢 / 矰 p2769
𰧞 / 磳 p2626
𰷐 / 𧸑 p3898
𱄱 / 驓 p4872
𱋹 / 𪒟 p5070

The only exception is 𨶧, which is a Taiwan person name but ⿵門曾 is not encoded.

According to MOE dictionary, the following 25 unencoded pairs are variants, most of which come from 直音篇.

⿰口𭦌 / 噌 B00425-004
⿰山𭦌 / 嶒 B00881-006
⿰巾𭦌 / 𢅋 C03181-002
⿰忄𭦌 / 憎 A01437-003
⿰扌𭦌 / 𢴣 A00813-009
⿰土𭦌 / 增 A00813-004
⿰氵𭦌 / 潧 C06414-002
⿰𭦌彡/ 㣒 C03489-002
⿱山𭦌 / 𡼳 B00881-007
⿱艹𭦌 / 𦼏 C11864-002
⿰木𭦌 / 橧 B01837-004
⿰火𭦌 / 熷 C06843-004
⿰牛𭦌 / 𤛢 C07114-002
⿰王𭦌 / 璔 A02595-012
⿱𠔿𭦌 / 𦌘 B03527-007
⿱𠕀𭦌 / 罾 B03527-002 (龍龕)
⿱罒𭦌 / 罾 B03527-003 (玉篇)
⿰立𭦌 / 竲 C09457-002
⿰糹𭦌 / 繒 B03458-006
⿰𭦌羽 / 䎖 C10661-002
⿰貝𭦌 / 贈 A03976-006 (廣碑別字)
⿰金𭦌 / 鏳 A04315-006 or 璔 B02639-002 (玉篇)
⿱山⿰糸𭦌 / 𡾽 B00881-008
⿰黒𭦌 / 𪒟 C18127-002
⿳亠⿲刀丫⿸#(丿𠄌>)乀⿴囗𭦌 / 𪗐 C18268-001

The known exceptions are

⿱𭦌灬 (KC12396): a variant of 魯 according to http://www.koreanhistory.or.kr/newchar/list_view.jsp?code=161977
⿰𭦌盖: a variant of 嫌 A00956-005

Note that the component 𭦌 may also be a variant of the component 魯: ⿰口𭦌 / 噌 A00708-002 from 敦煌俗字譜.

Given that most of unencoded 𭦌 component is a variant of component 曾, consider

add a UCV 187b 曾/𭦌 with etymological link.
02485
02485
玉 96.9
13 · ㇐ (1)
SAT-06892
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
[ WS2017-02622 ]
unify to WS2017-02622 GXM-00156
Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree. Withdraw.
03037
03037
米 119.13
19 · ㇔ (4)
SAT-06893
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
U+7CE3
U+6701
Unify with 糣 (U+7CE3), and add a new UCV for 朁~替.
03400
03400
艸 140.12
15 · ㇐ (1)
SAT-06897
𣈆
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
U+26D7B
U+23206
U+6649
Unify to 𦵻 (U+26D7B) and extend UCV #388 to cover 𣈆 = 晉 = 𦵻.
03255
03255
肉 130.11
15 · ㇠ (5)
SAT-06958
Unification
Henry CHAN
Individual
U+81A0
Unify to 膠 (U+81A0); add new UCV ⿱羽尒 and 翏.
02967
02967
竹 118.12
18 · ㇔ (4)
SAT-07036
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+30A8E
unify to 𰪎 (U+30A8E)
Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree. Withdraw.
03816
03816
貝 154.5
12 · ㇐ (1)
SAT-07087
𠆴
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
U+27D69
U+8CAC
U+258BC
SAT-07087 is used to illustrate the reading in the definition of another character. The character being defined, appears to be a variant of U+258BC. SAT-07087 appears to have the same relationship to 𧵩 (U+27D69) as U+27D69 has to U+258BC, strongly suggestion that they are variants. Both appear to be ancient forms of 責 (古文責字)
03136
03136
缶 121.8
15 · ㇒ (3)
SAT-07099
𦈢𰏤
Unification
Henry CHAN
Individual
U+7F3E
Unify to 缾 (U+7F3E); add new UCV 𰏤 = 并
01283
01283
彐 58.5
8 · ㇠ (5)
SAT-07269
Unification
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+38C7
Suggest to unify to 㣇 (U+38C7).
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion as there is no rule to judge unification now.
02098
02098
艸 140.13
17 · ㇔ (4)
SAT-08157
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]

《爾雅注疏.卷八.釋草》

It is suggested that the glyph 02098 should be unified with 薃 (U+8583).
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
We need discussion because swapping of top-level radical is not consistently unifiable in the past practice.
Ucv
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
It looks we need to discuss if we add the following pairs to UCV when we know they mean the same characters. Maybe we need to do more studies on this type of characters later.

03859
03859
走 156.9
16 · ㇐ (1)
SAT-08328
TD-706F
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00272
00272
冖 14.4
6 · ㇑ (2)
SAT-08359
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
U+758B
unify to 疋 U+758B

The evidence shows the book name is 《廣疋》 (aka 廣雅).

BTW, 鄧爾雅 wrote his name as 疋 not 雅 in his Chinese calligraphy works.

Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
Needs discussion whether 冖 and 乛 are unifiable.
04277
04277
阜 170.13
16 · ㇐ (1)
SAT-08377
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+31038
unify to 𱀸 (U+31038)
Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree. Withdraw.
03775
03775
言 149.8
15 · ㇔ (4)
SAT-08440
𠩋
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
U+27A6F
The evidence suggests that this is a variant of U+27A6F, which, according to Kangxi, is in turn a variant of 訴. The reading shown is 素, Mandarin "sù", which is the same as U+27A6F and 訴. The variants given, U+27A9C and 愬 are also similar to 訴 in meaning. The definitions overlap with those of 訴 (吿, 論, 譖, etc.), and the context shown would make sense written as 訴諸鬼神, "appeal to / have recourse to demons and spirits".
01613
01613
攴 66.11
15 · ㇔ (4)
SAT-08475
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
U+2BFD3
U+22FE5
Appears to be a variant of U+2BFD3 and U+22FE5.
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
U+2BFD3
unify to 𫿓 (U+2BFD3)

Support Lee's Comment #3915. The evidence shows the left part is the variant of 番 without any doubt. 𫿓 (U+2BFD3) itself is the variant of 播, but it shares the same rationale (same semantic element and same phonetic element).
Ucv
Eiso CHAN
Individual
It's better to add the followings as UCVs if they share the same rationale (same semantic element and same phonetic element).

(1)
e.g.
U+227F7 𢟷 vs U+61A3 憣
U+240F3 𤃳 vs U+2412B 𤄫
U+2839A 𨎚 vs U+8F53 轓
U+2E0EA 𮃪 vs U+2588C 𥢌

(2)
e.g.
U+2E2D2 𮋒 vs U+7FFB 翻

(3)
e.g.
U+2242E 𢐮 vs U+22432 𢐲
01465
01465
手 64.7
10 · ㇒ (3)
SAT-08486
𢌜
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00150
00150
人 9.7
9 · ㇒ (3)
SAT-08559
𢌜
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+4FB9
Unify to 侹
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion as there is no rule to judge unification now.
Unification
TAO Yang
China
U+8AAA
Wrong citation from 說文.

陳刻本

汲古閣本

日藏本
Unification
TAO Yang
China
But a commonly used glyph in the other literature.

攷正玉堂字彙

谭從周墓誌

(同治)重修寧海州志
03067
03067
糸 120.7
13 · ㇑ (2)
SAT-08568
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+7D57
Unify to 絗 (U+7D57)?
Ucv
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Surely there should be a UCV for 回~囬~囘 but I cannot see it.
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification is in fact prohibited by NUCV #317.
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+300A
U+7D57
U+7DEC
U+2C5DF
In 《佛教難字字典》, 絗 (U+7D57) is used as the variant of 緬 (U+7DEC), and 緬 (U+7DEC) has the other variant form 𬗟 (U+2C5DF, ⿰糹靣).

03225
03225
肉 130.5
9 · ㇒ (3)
SAT-08616
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
U+43E3
It seems to be an error for 䏣 in the head character only, and the entry actually uses 䏣 (肉中蟲謂之䏣蝇). Therefore this evidence is insufficient for encoding. Suggest unifying to 䏣.
04234
04234
門 169.11
19 · ㇐ (1)
SAT-08671
Ucv
HUANG Junliang
Individual
啟/啓

Unify to 闙.
03293
03293
舌 135.9
15 · ㇒ (3)
SAT-08725
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
U+8213
U+8499
U+6613
U+661C
This character appears to be an error for 舓 (this error form is also found in 蒙古字韻). As it is a common mistake to miswrite 易 as 昜 and vice versa, perhaps we should have a UCV rule for 易 and 昜 when cognate.
01207
01207
巛 47.10
13 · ㇐ (1)
SAT-08726
𠙻
Unification
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+24C91
Unify to 𤲑 (U+24C91).
Suggest to add a new UCV rule ⿱巛𠙻 to 甾.
(To copy some examples from MOE Dictionary)
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion for the suggested UCV.
Ucv
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
A similar form can be found in the MOE Dictionary:


Suggest to unify these shapes:
02177
02177
火 86.7
11 · ㇐ (1)
SAT-08823
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2DD29
unify to 𭴩 (U+2DD29)
Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree. Withdraw.
03783
03783
言 149.11
18 · ㇠ (5)
SAT-08887
Ucv
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add a new UCV 㕘~參 and new UCV 㕘~喿
01293
01293
彳 60.6
9 · ㇒ (3)
SAT-08911
𠂛
Unification
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+5EF6
U+5EF4
Unify to 延 (U+5EF6) and add a new UCV for the other shape to 廴.
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion for suggested UCV.
01754
01754
月 74.12
16 · ㇒ (3)
SAT-08914
𭁄
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
U+2680D
00534
口 30.9
12 · ㇑ (2)
SAT-06968
𭁄
unify to 𦠍 (U+2680D) as the new UCV accepted under WS2021-00534:SAT-06968.
00795
00795
土 32.5
8 · ㇐ (1)
SAT-08938
𭤟
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2D38B
unify to 𭎋 (U+2D38B)
Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2D38B
Agree. Withdraw. The glyph of U+2D38B should be updated.
03822
03822
貝 154.7
14 · ㇐ (1)
SAT-08945
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
U+8CAC
U+27D69
U+27D8C
SAT-08945 and the similar characters U+27D69 and U+27D8C are all variants of what's now written 責.
00685
00685
口 30.15
18 · ㇑ (2)
SAT-08974
𩒛
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
This is a peculiar shape at this place. While it is possible to unify, we currently don't have a rule.
01412
01412
心 61.18
21 · ㇒ (3)
SAT-08975
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2D7E3
unify to 𭟣 (U+2D7E3)
Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree. Withdraw.
03524
03524
虫 142.6
12 · ㇐ (1)
SAT-09003
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+45A4
Suggest unification to 䖤 and encoded via IVS.

夗 at the top is often 類化 to ⿱一夗 or 死, thereby losing its phonetic indication. Some examples of such variations:

怨 ~ ⿱死心:
Source from MOE Dictionary:


Source from 京都大学《拓本文字データベース》:


苑 ~ ⿱艹⿱一夗
Source from MOE Dictionary:


Source from 京都大学《拓本文字データベース》:


See also:
04702
鳥 196.6
17 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00382
01208
01208
巛 47.14
17 · ㇒ (3)
SAT-09025
𠙻
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+7580
Unify to 疀.
Unify to 疀 and add a new UCV.
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion for the suggested UCV. Also see WS2021-01207.
03763
03763
言 149.3
10 · ㇔ (4)
SAT-09285
𠧒
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
U+8A16
unify to 訖 U+8A16?

It's used as a 反切下字 in the evidence, but it's very easy to know it's really the variant of 訖.
Ucv
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Add a new UCV between 𠧒 and 乞.

U+209D2 𠧒=U+4E5E 乞
U+21D4A 𡵊=U+5C79 屹
U+21D4B 𡵋=U+2AA23 𪨣
U+221D2 𢇒=U+221D3 𢇓
U+23C81 𣲁=U+6C54 汔
U+264EA 𦓪=U+43A2 䎢
U+26638 𦘸=U+8090 肐
U+2925F 𩉟=U+4A50 䩐
U+2968B 𩚋=U+4B23 䬣
U+29FA4 𩾤=U+29FA5 𩾥
U+2A5DA 𪗚=U+9F55 齕
U+2E782 𮞂=U+8FC4 迄

If these two components are not unifiable, we will meet more and more character with the component 𠧒 in future, because it is too common.
00183
00183
人 9.10
12 · ㇐ (1)
SAT-09305
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+5044
Unify to 偄
偄 is a variant of 懦.
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion as there is no rule to judge unification now.
Ucv
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
We may reference this UCV added in WS2017:
02392
02392
犬 94.9
12 · ㇒ (3)
SAT-10101
VN-F1A20
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00373
00373
十 24.6
8 · ㇐ (1)
SAT-10114
𪢴
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+534B
Unify to 卋
According to the second evidence, the meaning of 遯⿱十𪢴 is "避世", so ⿱十𪢴 is congnate with 卋.
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion as there is no rule to judge unification now.
01907
01907
止 77.3
7 · ㇑ (2)
SAT-10320
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+27FB7
unify to 𧾷 (U+27FB7)
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion whether it is appropriate to unify with 𧾷 (U+27FB7) which apparently encoded for a component.
03452
03452
艸 140.15
19 · ㇐ (1)
T9-756E
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Similar with TE-782A (WS2021-01575), so withdrawn.
04132
04132
金 167.11
19 · ㇑ (2)
T9-7665
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04158
金 167.12
20 · ㇑ (2)
TE-387B
unify to WS2021-04158 TE-387B
T9-7665 and TE-387B are not duplicate, but they are unifiable. TE-387B matches the TCA conventions, so it’s better to keep TE-387B when IRG confirms this unification.
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree. Keep TE-387B (WS2021-04158).
03855
03855
走 156.6
13 · ㇒ (3)
T9-7768
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+8D9C
Variant of 趜 U+8D9C?
Oppose Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Disagree. The two glyphs 匊 and ⿹勹水 are not non-cognate.
00161
00161
人 9.8
10 · ㇒ (3)
T9-792C
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00506
00506
口 30.8
11 · ㇒ (3)
T9-7A3D
Unification
TAO Yang
China
U+269D9
𦧙?
Please provide the evidence include the glyph how it is used or what it means.
01265
01265
广 53.11
14 · ㇔ (4)
T9-7B39
广
Unification
LI Yuan
SAT
U+222D0
Unify to 𢋐 (U+222D0). U+222D0 has the pronunciation jí according to CNS 11643, therefore might be miswriting of U+222D0.
04561
04561
鬼 194.8
18 · ㇐ (1)
T9-7B7C
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+29CEC
U+4C2A
Both of 𩳬 U+29CEC and T9-7B7C should be the variants of 䰪 U+4C2A.
Disunification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Disagree to be unified, there is no rule to judge unification.
Unification
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
U+4C2A
U+300A
The glyph of 䰪 (U+4C2A) which shows in 《康熙字典》(同文書局) is similar to ⿰⿱夫月鬼.

https://ctext.org/library.pl?if=en&file=77415&page=1462
03453
03453
艸 140.15
19 · ㇐ (1)
T9-7C4F
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unify to T9-756E.
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
T9-756E will be withdrawn.
00194
00194
人 9.11
13 · ㇒ (3)
TB-4931
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00283
00283
冫 15.8
10 · ㇔ (4)
TB-494F
Unification
TAO Yang
China

Actually, the radical is the cursive form of 氵.
03974
03974
辵 162.9
13 · ㇐ (1)
TB-4C60
Unification
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
U+48A5
U+28552
similar to 䢥(U+48A5) or 𨕒(U+28552).
02393
02393
犬 94.9
12 · ㇒ (3)
TB-5027
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02974
02974
竹 118.13
19 · ㇔ (4)
TB-6262
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E19D
unify to 𮆝 (U+2E19D)
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E19D
Unify to 𮆝 (U+2E19D) by UCV #55
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2E19D
Agree. Add a extension to 𮆝 (U+2E19D).
00154
00154
人 9.8
10 · ㇐ (1)
TB-703A
𠈌
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+200B9
Unify to 𠂹
01430
01430
手 64.3
6 · ㇒ (3)
TC-266C
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00137
00137
人 9.5
7 · ㇑ (2)
TC-282C
Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
U+3438
Given the information is correct, can consider IVS to 㐸 (U+3438). cf. Annex S.1.5.i
00374
00374
十 24.6
8 · ㇔ (4)
TC-2F48
Unification
TAO Yang
China
康熙字典
Unification
TAO Yang
China
Please provide the evidence include the glyph how it is used or what it means.
00769
00769
囗 31.5
8 · ㇒ (3)
TC-3024
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+56EB
Unify to 囫 (U+56EB)
Oppose Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
勿 and 匆 are different characters and have different meanings.
01440
01440
手 64.5
8 · ㇐ (1)
TC-323B
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00273
00273
冖 14.7
9 · ㇒ (3)
TC-375C
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+262A8
unify to 𦊨
The same character have been proposed by UK in WS2017.
https://hc.jsecs.org/irg/ws2017/app/index.php?ids=%E2%BF%B1%E3%93%81%E4%B8%94
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+262A8
>unify to 𦊨(U+262A8)
Agree.
00280
00280
冫 15.7
9 · ㇑ (2)
TC-3761
Unification
TAO Yang
China
漢書
詩氏族考
字彙補
All above are the wrong glyph of 浞.
Please provide the evidence include the glyph how it is used or what it means.
00462
00462
口 30.6
9 · ㇒ (3)
TC-3873
𠆢
Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
U+54DA
Possibly unifiable with 哚 (U+54DA).
02011
02011
水 85.6
9 · ㇒ (3)
TC-3E43
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00336
00336
力 19.8
10 · ㇑ (2)
TC-4466
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+52D6
Unify to 勖?
Oppose Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Disagree to be unified, there is no rule to judge unification.
Unification
TAO Yang
China
Please provide the evidence include the glyph how it is used or what it means.
00385
00385
卜 25.8
10 · ㇐ (1)
TC-447C
Unification
TAO Yang
China
U+2A2FF
Although we believe that TC-447C should related to 𪋿, but no evidence can prove it.
Please provide the evidence include the glyph how it is used or what it means.
01466
01466
手 64.7
10 · ㇒ (3)
TC-487C
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01737
01737
月 74.6
10 · ㇒ (3)
TC-4A25
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
VN-F195D should be unifiable with this character, and Vietnam will propose a horizontal extension later.
03333
03333
艸 140.6
10 · ㇒ (3)
TC-4F5F
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00175
00175
人 9.9
11 · ㇔ (4)
TC-5164
VN-F002E
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00173
00173
人 9.9
11 · ㇒ (3)
TC-5166
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00841
00841
土 32.8
11 · ㇔ (4)
TC-5371
Unification
TAO Yang
China
U+55CC
According to the pronunciation, it should be a wrong glyph of 嗌.
02478
02478
玉 96.7
11 · ㇒ (3)
TC-5B6D
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+24962
unify to 𤥢 (U+24962)
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+24962
Unify to 𤥢 (U+24962) by UCV #70
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree.
00379
00379
十 24.11
13 · ㇒ (3)
TC-655A
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2A719
U+2B870
unify to 𪜙 (U+2A719) or U+2B870?
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2B870
Unify to 𫡰 (U+2B870)
Oppose Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion as there is no rule to judge unification now.
Unification
TAO Yang
China
Minor structural differences, could be unified.
00402
00402
厂 27.9
11 · ㇔ (4)
TC-7D4A
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+20A82
Unify to 𠪂?
Disunification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+6241
Disagree. ⿸户皿 and 扁 are totally different characters.
00188
00188
人 9.10
12 · ㇔ (4)
TD-2261
𠈌
Unification
TAO Yang
China
U+209AC
Unify to 𠦬 (U+209AC)
00545
00545
口 30.9
12 · ㇒ (3)
TD-2337
Unification
TAO Yang
China
Please provide the evidence include the glyph how it is used or what it means.
00846
00846
土 32.9
12 · ㇐ (1)
TD-2351
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02046
02046
水 85.9
12 · ㇒ (3)
TD-2A7B
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+3D1E
unify to 㴞 (U+3D1E)?
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Suggest adding rhs shape to UCV #90
Disunification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion as there is no rule to judge unification now.
00558
00558
口 30.10
13 · ㇑ (2)
TD-366F
Unification
TAO Yang
China
Please provide the evidence include the glyph how it is used or what it means.
03818
03818
貝 154.6
13 · ㇐ (1)
TD-457B
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
Similar shape and same reading as U+8CDA.
00122
00122
亠 8.12
14 · ㇑ (2)
TD-4828
UTC-03195
Unification
Eddie LI
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
unified with UTC-03195
04070
04070
金 167.6
14 · ㇐ (1)
TD-572C
Ucv
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
There is no evidence for the meaning, but the reading "zā" is identical with that of U+9254, suggesting that they might be variants. There is one other pair similar to this already encoded, U+2341D and U+23459. U+2341D is used in Nôm with the meaning "soft" but it's not clear what the semantic relation, if any, is in Chinese. Should we consider UCV for ⿷匚帀 and 木匝?
02507
02507
玉 96.12
16 · ㇐ (1)
TD-6D41
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
U+3EF8
U+6701
Unify with 㻸 (U+3EF8), and add a new UCV for 朁~替. See also SAT-06893 and TE-2F54.
03860
03860
走 156.9
16 · ㇐ (1)
TD-706F
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02969
02969
竹 118.13
19 · ㇐ (1)
TD-743C
V4-5037
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
03339
03339
艸 140.6
12 · ㇠ (5)
TD-7537
Ucv
Andrew WEST
UK
Given that any character with a grass radical could be written with 艸 instead, I think it would be a good idea to define a UCV for 艸 = 艹 where cognate.
02498
02498
玉 96.10
14 · ㇒ (3)
TD-795B
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04018
04018
邑 163.12
15 · ㇐ (1)
TD-7E3F
Ucv
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
Possible variant of U+90FE. We should consider extension of UCV to cover 匽, ⿷匚晏, and ⿷匸晏 as components. There are already several possible pairs encoded, such as U+5043 and U+2037E. The proposed characters TB-5C5C and TD-7E57 are other examples
03094
03094
糸 120.11
17 · ㇒ (3)
TE-2736
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
U+260AF
Unify to 𦂯 (U+260AF)
Ucv
Andrew WEST
UK
UCV #401
04023
04023
邑 163.15
18 · ㇐ (1)
TE-2931
𬥁
Unification
Henry CHAN
Individual
U+9139
Unify to 鄹 (U+9139).

Excerpt from Hanyu Dazidian shows that 鄹 (U+9139) can also be read as jù when used as a place name:


There is also a similar case in the UCV, with a single stroke difference:
04387
04387
面 176.8
17 · ㇐ (1)
TE-2A23
Ucv
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
This appears to be a variant of U+9EB5 麵. There are other pairs already encoded, such as U+ 4D2C 䴬 and U+2D6A2 that show ⿺夌 as a simplification of 麥. Might be worth consideration of this component shape as UCV of the simplified form, U+9EA6 麦
01571
01571
手 64.15
18 · ㇐ (1)
TE-2C3F
UTC-00659
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
03100
03100
糸 120.12
18 · ㇐ (1)
TE-2F54
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
U+26166
U+6701
Unify with 𦅦 (U+26166), and add a new UCV for 朁~替. See also SAT-06893 and TD-6D41.
03440
03440
艸 140.14
18 · ㇒ (3)
TE-302C
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Normalize to ⿱艹毓
Oppose Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
This glyph is used for personal name, so it is not normalized.
03445
03445
艸 140.14
18 · ㇔ (4)
TE-3048
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+26EEC
Other than the minor difference in shape of radical 140, how is this different from U+26EEC? Is the given radical correct?
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+26EEC
unify to 𦻬 (U+26EEC) possibly?

Agree with Lee's comment at #2014.
Oppose Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
I do not think it is unifiable with 𦻬 (U+26EEC). ⿰方⿱𠂉其 and ⿰方其 are not the same.
Oppose Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Disagree to be unified, there is no rule to judge unification.
04123
04123
金 167.10
18 · ㇔ (4)
TE-3166
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
[ WS2017-04447 ]
unify to WS2017-04447 KC-07700
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
[ WS2017-04447 ]
Agree. Add a extension to WS2017-04447 KC-07700.
00705
00705
口 30.16
19 · ㇑ (2)
TE-3371
UTC-00427
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
03642
03642
虫 142.13
19 · ㇒ (3)
TE-3773
Ucv
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Suggest adding UCV for 解~觧 as this is such a common variant.
Ucv
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion as there is no rule to judge unification now.
But 觧 could be a variant of 解 or 鮮.
04141
04141
金 167.11
19 · ㇒ (3)
TE-3873
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04158
04158
金 167.12
20 · ㇑ (2)
TE-387B
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04132
金 167.11
19 · ㇑ (2)
T9-7665
unify to WS2021-04132 T9-7665
T9-7665 and TE-387B are not duplicate, but they are unifiable. TE-387B matches the TCA conventions, so it’s better to keep TE-387B when IRG confirms this unification.
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree. Keep TE-387B (WS2021-04158).
04604
04604
魚 195.8
19 · ㇔ (4)
TE-3A27
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04862
04862
鹿 198.8
19 · ㇐ (1)
TE-3A4D
鹿
Unification
Eddie LI
Individual
GKJ-00701
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
04870
鹿 198.9
20 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00701
鹿
unify to WS2021-04870:GKJ-00701

UCV #424
04750
04750
鳥 196.10
21 · ㇔ (4)
TE-4361
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04191
04191
金 167.16
24 · ㇑ (2)
TE-4A5A
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00325
00325
刀 18.14
16 · ㇑ (2)
TE-7177
𦶝
Unification
TAO Yang
China
Please provide the evidence include the glyph how it is used or what it means.
03891
03891
足 157.10
17 · ㇑ (2)
TE-7262
𧾷𧆠
Ucv
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
We might want to consider unification of 𧆠 and 虖 as components
00361
00361
勹 20.15
17 · ㇔ (4)
TE-7276
𰍇
Unification
TAO Yang
China
Please provide the evidence include the glyph how it is used or what it means.
03431
03431
艸 140.13
17 · ㇠ (5)
TE-743B
𦵢
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+8585
Unify to 薅 (U+8585).
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Needs discussion as there is no rule to judge unification now.
04241
04241
門 169.12
20 · ㇑ (2)
TE-7A52
Unification
TAO Yang
China
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+95D2
Unify to 闒 U+95D2? We need the pronunciation to make sure whether it is a wrong character of 闒 U+95D2.
Disunification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
This glyph is used for personal name and is pronounced "jin".
04001
04001
辵 162.17
21 · ㇔ (4)
TE-7B2D
𣁎
Unification
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
U+908E
similar to 邎(U+908E).
03479
03479
艸 140.17
20 · ㇠ (5)
TF-7E5A
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
U+2BC9B
Unify to 𫲛 (U+2BC9B)
04623
04623
魚 195.10
21 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20003
Ucv
HUANG Junliang
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
The evidence gives ⿲魚彳⿻𠆤⿱二八.
According to MOE dictionary, ⿻𠆤⿱二八 is a variant of 余.

Add a ucv for ⿻𠆤⿱二八/余 ?
03455
03455
艸 140.15
19 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20011
Unification
BAI Yi
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+23A77
Unify to 𣩷 (U+23A77).
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
We don't object to unification if that is considered appropriate.
02352
02352
犬 94.6
9 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20025
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02425
02425
犬 94.12
15 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20035
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02320
02320
牛 93.11
15 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20053
鹿
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
03770
03770
言 149.8
15 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20054
Unification
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
U+8A86
Is it a misprint of 誆?
04586
04586
魚 195.6
17 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20070
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00829
00829
土 32.8
11 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20080
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02578
02578
田 102.2
7 · ㇠ (5)
UK-20108
SAT-08976
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02579
02579
田 102.2
7 · ㇠ (5)
UK-20108
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02776
02776
石 112.9
14 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20139
UTC-03169
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02341
02341
犬 94.5
8 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20151
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04102
04102
金 167.9
17 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20156
𬙙
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04885
04885
麥 199.5
16 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20183
SAT-09217
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04886
04886
麥 199.5
16 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20183
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01957
01957
气 84.3
7 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20235
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00039
00039
乙 5.1
2 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20253
丿
Disunification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+20832
not unify to 𠠲 (U+20832)

U+20832 is the ancient variant form of U+529B according to the real sources.


▲ Kangxi Dictionary


▲ 《字彙補》
03662
03662
虫 142.16
22 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20264
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01449
01449
手 64.5
9 · ㇠ (5)
UK-20273
UTC-00637
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
03494
03494
虍 141.5
11 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20278
UTC-00742
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01834
01834
木 75.11
15 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20280
UTC-00671
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00527
00527
口 30.9
12 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20281
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
The evidence should be considered unbelievable because the character is of great possibility created by the author in modern times and never actually accepted or used by other people.
01704
01704
日 72.12
16 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20283
UTC-00667
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01945
01945
毛 82.7
11 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20287
UTC-00682
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02251
02251
火 86.14
18 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20288
UTC-00697
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02228
02228
火 86.12
16 · ㇠ (5)
UK-20296
UTC-00766
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00201
00201
人 9.12
14 · ㇠ (5)
UK-20297
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00196
00196
人 9.11
13 · ㇠ (5)
UK-20297
UTC-00498
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
01385
01385
心 61.13
16 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20300
UTC-00631
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01540
01540
手 64.12
15 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20303
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01528
01528
手 64.12
15 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20303
UTC-00652
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
01908
01908
止 77.5
9 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20304
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00353
00353
勹 20.7
9 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20304
UTC-00778
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
02685
02685
目 109.2
7 · ㇠ (5)
UK-20306
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02684
02684
目 109.2
7 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20306
UTC-00712
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
03088
03088
糸 120.10
16 · ㇠ (5)
UK-20308
UTC-00723
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01513
01513
手 64.11
14 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20310
UTC-00647
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
The evidence should be considered unbelievable because the character is of great possibility created by the author in modern times and never actually accepted or used by other people.
01549
01549
手 64.13
16 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20313
UTC-00653
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00507
00507
口 30.8
11 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20314
VN-F173E
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01473
01473
手 64.8
12 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20315
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
The evidence should be considered unbelievable because the character is of great possibility created by the author in modern times and never actually accepted or used by other people.
02665
02665
皮 107.11
16 · ㇠ (5)
UK-20316
UTC-00711
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01432
01432
手 64.4
8 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20317
UTC-00636
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02276
02276
爪 87.6
10 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20320
UTC-00699
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02289
02289
爿 90.5
9 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20324
UTC-00701
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01555
01555
手 64.13
16 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20327
UTC-00787
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01544
01544
手 64.13
17 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20328
UTC-00768
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02044
02044
水 85.9
13 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20329
UTC-00689
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02661
02661
皮 107.8
13 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20333
UTC-00709
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02454
02454
犬 94.15
18 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20336
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00514
00514
口 30.8
11 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20341
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00720
00720
口 30.16
19 · ㇠ (5)
UK-20342
UTC-03218
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00536
00536
口 30.9
12 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20358
VN-F1751
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00617
00617
口 30.12
15 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20366
SAT-08745
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00619
00619
口 30.12
15 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20366
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00515
00515
口 30.8
11 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20367
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00513
00513
口 30.8
11 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20367
TC-5340
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04901
04901
黹 204.5
17 · ㇠ (5)
UK-20372
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04900
04900
黹 204.5
17 · ㇠ (5)
UK-20372
SAT-10122
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00731
00731
口 30.17
20 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20392
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00106
00106
二 7.9
11 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20399
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+63A3
It is a wrong glyph of 掣, we should reject it on this evidence. This shows the importance of checking the context and other vertions, and not just relying on the glyph.
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree to withdraw if no additional evidence is produced.
00573
00573
口 30.11
14 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20407
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
02710
02710
目 109.12
17 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20425
𭦟
Unification
Henry CHAN
Individual
U+25291
Unify to 𥊑 (U+25291); consider new UCV 𭦟 = 曼.
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
U+25291
U+66FC
U+2D99F
U+2D997
Agree to unification with 𥊑 (U+25291) if new UCV is defined for 曼 = 𭦟 = 𭦗.
03467
03467
艸 140.16
20 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20437
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
U+2C7CF
The bottom component of U+2C7CF 𬟏 is obviously a turtle, so unification seems justified. Perhaps UCV #160 can be extended to include the bottom component of U+2C7CF 𬟏.
Oppose Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
U+2C7CF 𬟏 is the modern transcription form of an oracle bone script character that means "autumn", and the original oracle bone script character it represents is thought to be a drawing of a grasshopper (which is active in autumn). The grass radical shown in the G-source glyph for U+2C7CF should correctly be 卝 as it actually represents the grasshopper's antennae.

On the other hand, UK-20437 is used in the evidence provided as an alternate way of writing the character 鱉 'softshell turtle' in the specific word 紫鱉, an ancient name for a type of plant. In this case it is obvious that the character is composed of a grass radical above a turtle.

Thus UK-20437 and U+2C7CF are non-cognate, and have significantly different glyph forms, and so cannot be unified.
04266
04266
阜 170.9
12 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20475
𠚏
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+28EAD
U+5009
Looks identical to 𨺭 (U+28EAD). Also, the reading given above, 倉夾, is the same as that shown in Kangxi for U+28EAD. Any reason not to unify?
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree to unify and withdraw.
Ucv
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add new UCV for the different wrapping structural forms of 𠚏.
04855
04855
鹿 198.7
18 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20484
鹿
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
03265
03265
肉 130.14
18 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20488
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01760
01760
月 74.14
18 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20488
UTC-03203
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
02703
02703
目 109.8
13 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20498
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02700
02700
目 109.8
13 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20498
VN-F03A5
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree with Unification
00231
00231
人 9.17
19 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20503
UTC-00536
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00270
00270
冖 14.3
5 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20504
丿
Unification
TAO Yang
China

Normalized form from cursive script.
02399
02399
犬 94.9
12 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20505
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01874
01874
木 75.15
19 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20528
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+237C0
unify to 𣟀 (U+237C0)
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree and withdraw.
00358
00358
勹 20.15
17 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20529
UTC-03200
Unification
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01345
01345
心 61.8
12 · ㇠ (5)
UK-20536
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01344
01344
心 61.8
12 · ㇠ (5)
UK-20536
TD-2731
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00766
00766
囗 31.4
7 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20544
Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
U+211B6
Possibly unifiable with 𡆶 (U+211B6).
Is there explanation for the character why the inside should be exactly 旡 instead of 无?
02055
02055
水 85.9
12 · ㇠ (5)
UK-20558
Unification
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]

https://baiyunju.cc/754
https://kknews.cc/culture/pega9j.html
This character comes from 老君碑, and in related inscriptions, it is written as 𢛣 or "⿰氵⿱民心". Therefore, should the glyph 02055 be unified with 𢛣 (U+226E3)?
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
We don't object to unification if that is considered appropriate.
00030
00030
丿 4.5
6 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20575
UTC-03219
𠂝
Unification
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00034
00034
丿 4.10
11 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20576
𠈌
Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
[ WS2017-00744 ]
U+209AC
Per precedent of WS2017-00744, this could be unified to 𠦬 (U+209AC).
00138
00138
人 9.5
7 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20577
𫵲
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+4F47
Unify to 佇
According to the evidece, 佇 means "to hope and wait for" and ⿰亻𫵲 means "to wait". Their meanings are very close. Meanwhile, it's normal that "宀" become "山":

So the new UCVs above can be added with meaning control.
Oppose Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
The evidence shows the proposed character in contrast with 佇. I agree that it is probably a variant of 佇, but the evidence gives them slightly different meanings so it may be best not to unify.
04884
04884
鹿 198.24
35 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20580
鹿
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04528
04528
高 189.5
15 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20581
Unification
BAI Yi
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+29ACA
𩫊 (U+29ACA)
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree to unification as both characters have the same meaning and reading. Therefore we withdraw this character.
02338
02338
犬 94.5
8 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20608
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04799
04799
鳥' 196'.5
10 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20622
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01127
01127
山 46.6
9 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20629
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01144
01144
山 46.8
11 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20631
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00667
00667
口 30.14
17 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20659
𪏭
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+569F
unify to 嚟 (U+569F)?
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
UCV #413. Personally I do not like this unification.
00861
00861
土 32.10
13 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20662
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00860
00860
土 32.10
13 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20662
TD-3825
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00671
00671
口 30.14
17 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20675
Unification
HUANG Junliang
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2105F
U+2105F


Consider add 賔/賓 as UCV so it can be unified to 𡁟.
Ucv
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
A new UCV for 賔~賓 would need to be discussed by IRG.
00679
00679
口 30.15
18 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20677
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
03765
03765
言 149.4
11 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20679
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
No reading is given, but shape and context suggests that this is identical to UK-20682 / SN03761 and could be unified
01153
01153
山 46.9
12 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20727
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+30114
Unify to 𰄔?
Since 出 can be written as 岀, so this can be unified to 𰄔.
Oppose Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
UK-20727 is composed of four separate 'mountain' characters, and so cannot be written as ⿰出出. It is not cognate with 𰄔 (U+30114), and the two characters have different glyph shapes, therefore we strongly oppose unification with U+30114.
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+5C80
U+51FA
岀(U+5C80) is written as two mountain and it's a variant of 出.
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+4E2D
中文大辞典P4349
Oppose Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
They are clearly distinguished in a book named 《同字符合体字汇》:
Page11:

Page35:

So they should be disunified.
00498
00498
口 30.8
11 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20767
VN-F1742
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00491
00491
口 30.8
11 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20770
𫆀
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
U+35BF
U+2B180
U+8036
In other texts, ⿰口𫆀 is written as 㖿 in the same sequences of syllables (example shown below). Therefore, unify to 㖿 (U+35BF) and create a new UCV for 𫆀 = 耶.
04556
04556
鬼 194.6
16 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20785
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02696
02696
目 109.7
12 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20832
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02170
02170
火 86.5
9 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20863
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02169
02169
火 86.5
9 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20863
TC-3E52
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01138
01138
山 46.8
11 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20874
Unification
HUANG Junliang
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unify to [ {{WS2017-01096}} ]


Exact match.
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
[ WS2017-01096 ]
Withdraw as it is a duplicate of WS2017-01096 (UTC-03041)
02110
02110
水 85.15
18 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20882
𠏉
Ucv
HUANG Junliang
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+6FA3


Consider adding 幹/榦/𠏉 to UCV so it can be unified to 澣.

Including 幹:
U+64C0 擀 ^⿰扌幹$(GHTV)
U+6A8A 檊 ^⿰木幹$(GHTV)
U+6FA3 澣 ^⿰氵幹$(GHJKT)
U+7C33 簳 ^⿱𥫗幹$(GHJKT)
U+20FE8 𠿨 ^⿰口幹$(G)
U+26F2E 𦼮 ^⿱艹幹$(GT)
U+29F1B 𩼛 ^⿰魚幹$(G)
U+2D5E0 𭗠 ^⿱山幹$(S)

Including 榦:
U+26FAE 𦾮 ^⿱艹榦$(GT)
U+2DB15 𭬕 ^⿰木榦$(K)

Including 𠏉:
U+25DAD 𥶭 ^⿱𥫗𠏉$(G)
U+27040 𧁀 ^⿱艹𠏉$(GT)
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
We don't object to unification with a new ucv if that is considered appropriate.
Ucv
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
I suggest a new UCV of 榦 & 𠏉 only, with 幹 excluded. In that case it won't be unified with 澣 (U+6FA3), but it can be unified with ⿰氵榦 if we see it in the future.
02529
02529
玉 96.14
18 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20883
Unification
HUANG Junliang
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+74B8


Consider add 賔/賓 as UCV so it can be unified to 璸.
Ucv
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
A new UCV for 賔~賓 would need to be discussed by IRG.
02447
02447
犬 94.14
17 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20893
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01397
01397
心 61.14
17 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20896
Unification
HUANG Junliang
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+228D0
U+228D0


Consider add 賔/賓 as UCV so it can be unified to 𢣐.
Ucv
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
A new UCV for 賔~賓 would need to be discussed by IRG.
00007
00007
一 1.8
9 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20897
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+4E3D
Unify to 丽
《中华字海》P832
Disunification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+4E3D
It's not acceptable to unify this character to 丽 (U+4E3D), and I show the reasons as below.

1) The variant of 丽/麗 in 《篇海》 is ⿰𣄼𣄼 not ⿱一昍.



And ⿰𣄼𣄼 was included in 《字學三正》.



We can unify ⿰𣄼𣄼 to 丽 (U+4E3D).

2) The person mentioned in the evidence for UK-20897 was also written as 劉雨 in 《瓊州府志》 as below. This is why UK provides the variant relation between U+96E8 and it, and there is no any UCV to unify UK-20897 with 雨 (U+96E8).



Notice that 瓊州 or 琼州 here means 海南 (Hainan). Hainan had become province since 1988, which was a part of Guangdong Province before 1988.
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
In 康熙《琼山县志》is the same with 《广东通志》

However, in 咸丰《琼山县志》,It's 丽.

What's more, as I know, there is no glyph of “雨” in ancient books is written as two parts. "丽", however, is much more likely to have one stroke on it's top.

(From zi.tools)
Two 点校本 also take this as “丽”:
(清)王贽修,关必登纂. 康熙琼山县志 康熙四十七年本 下[M]. 海口:海南出版社, 2006.P176

(清)杨宗秉纂修;王秀臣点校. 乾隆琼山县志[M]. 海口:海南出版社, 2006.P223

At last, 《琼州府志》 seems like 光绪本 or 民国本 which is later than 咸丰.
Unification
HUANG Junliang
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+4E3D
Agree to unify with 丽. I suggest we add two UCV rules:

1) ⿰𣄼𣄼 / 丽 + VS17 are unifiable under UCV b-2 (like b-2 #123?)
2) ⿰𣄼𣄼 / ⿱一昍 are unifiable under UCV c-1 (like c-1#178)

So ⿱一昍 ~(c1) ⿰𣄼𣄼 ~(b-2) 丽 + VS17 ~ 丽.
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree to unification.
01785
01785
木 75.7
11 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20901
𮕜
Oppose Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Not unify to 𫭱 (U+2BB71) as this is not a unifiable variant (木 radical as opposed to 土 radical). Even if U+2BB71 should be the preferred form of this character, UK-20901 still needs to be encoded as this form is given in at least two major modern printed scholarly works. See also L2/21-101 for discussion of this character by Alexander Zapryagaev.
Oppose Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree not to unify.
02057
02057
水 85.9
12 · ㇠ (5)
UK-20902
Ucv
HUANG Junliang
Individual
Consider add UCV 迴/廻/廽 so it can be unified to 𭱫.
01165
01165
山 46.10
13 · ㇠ (5)
UK-20903
𥙊
Ucv
HUANG Junliang
Individual
Add UCV 祭/𥙊.
04119
04119
金 167.10
18 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20904
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04118
04118
金 167.10
18 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20904
TE-3177
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02802
02802
石 112.12
17 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20913
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04131
04131
金 167.11
19 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20922
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
04130
04130
金 167.11
19 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20922
TE-3924
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
01256
01256
广 53.7
10 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20925
广
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01255
01255
广 53.7
10 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20925
TC-4773
广
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
LI Yuan
SAT
U+2AA98
Unify to 𪪘 (U+2AA98). U+2AA98 has the pronunciation yi4 according to CNS 11643, therefore might be cognate with this character.
01897
01897
木 75.27
31 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20926
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01896
01896
木 75.27
31 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20926
SAT-07235
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01897
01897
木 75.27
31 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20926
Unification
HUANG Junliang
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2387F
U+2387F


Consider add 㸑/爨 as UCV so it can be unified to 𣡿.
00350
00350
力 19.19
21 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20943
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00349
00349
力 19.19
21 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20943
TE-3F65
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01172
01172
山 46.11
14 · ㇑ (2)
UK-20945
Ucv
HUANG Junliang
Individual
Extend UCV #157 to include ⿳⿱甲卝一八?
03409
03409
艸 140.12
16 · ㇒ (3)
UK-20947
𣸧
Unification
HUANG Junliang
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+26E02
U+26E02


Consider add 𣸧/深 as UCV so it can be unified to 𦸂.
Ucv
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Based on the discussion, it is suggested to add a new UCV as follows:
00847
00847
土 32.9
12 · ㇐ (1)
UK-20964
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00602
00602
口 30.11
14 · ㇠ (5)
UK-20983
VN-F16CA
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00736
00736
口 30.17
20 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20992
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00734
00734
口 30.17
20 · ㇔ (4)
UK-20992
TE-3A66
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00571
00571
口 30.10
13 · ㇠ (5)
UK-20997
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+20D32
Unify to 𠴲?
The pronounciation of 沓 in 粤语 is tʰap22、tap22, which reads like "the noise of rain falling on hard substances", so the right part of this character should be a variant of “沓” and ⿰口㳫 and
𠴲 are congnate.
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+6C93
We do not oppose unification if a new UCV for 沓~㳫 is defined.
Ucv
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add a new UCV rule 沓~㳫.
㳫 is a corrupted form of 沓 according to the Kangxi Dictionary.
00701
00701
口 30.16
19 · ㇐ (1)
UTC-00372
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+210E4
unify to 𡃤 (U+210E4)?
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+210E4
Unify to 𡃤 (U+210E4) by UCV #324
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+210E4
Agree to unify with 𡃤 (U+210E4) per UCV #324
00709
00709
口 30.16
19 · ㇑ (2)
UTC-00427
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
00569
00569
口 30.10
13 · ㇔ (4)
UTC-00441
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+9FFD
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree with Eiso. UTC-00441 was included in the UTC's submission for IRG Working Set 2021, because U+9FFD (MC-00134) is not yet encoded, but is expected to be included in Unicode Version 14.0, which will be released in September. Shown is U+9FFD from the Unicode Version 14.0 Beta code charts.

00214
00214
人 9.14
16 · ㇒ (3)
UTC-00445
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+50ED
unify to 僭 (U+50ED)?
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+50ED
Agree to unify with 僭 (U+50ED) by extending UCV #213
00232
00232
人 9.17
19 · ㇐ (1)
UTC-00536
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
01028
01028
子 39.14
17 · ㇒ (3)
UTC-00623
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
01386
01386
心 61.13
16 · ㇑ (2)
UTC-00631
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
01434
01434
手 64.4
8 · ㇐ (1)
UTC-00636
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
01450
01450
手 64.5
9 · ㇠ (5)
UTC-00637
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
01442
01442
手 64.5
8 · ㇐ (1)
UTC-00638
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
01515
01515
手 64.11
14 · ㇔ (4)
UTC-00647
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
01550
01550
手 64.13
16 · ㇑ (2)
UTC-00653
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
01545
01545
手 64.13
17 · ㇐ (1)
UTC-00656
𤞣
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+64EA
unify to 擪 (U+64EA)?
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+64EA
Agree to unify with 擪 (U+64EA)
01572
01572
手 64.15
18 · ㇐ (1)
UTC-00659
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
01591
01591
手 64.17
20 · ㇐ (1)
UTC-00661
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+650B
unify to 攋 (U+650B)?
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+650B
Unify to 攋 (U+650B) as second evidence image clearly shows T-form of 攋. First evidence is probably a mistake.
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+650B
Agree to unify with 攋 (U+650B)
01705
01705
日 72.12
16 · ㇒ (3)
UTC-00667
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
01835
01835
木 75.11
15 · ㇔ (4)
UTC-00671
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
The evidence should be considered unbelievable because the character is of great possibility created by the author of reference in modern times and never actually accepted or used by other people.
01946
01946
毛 82.7
11 · ㇔ (4)
UTC-00682
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
02045
02045
水 85.9
13 · ㇑ (2)
UTC-00689
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
02252
02252
火 86.14
18 · ㇔ (4)
UTC-00697
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
02277
02277
爪 87.6
10 · ㇐ (1)
UTC-00699
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
02541
02541
瓜 97.4
9 · ㇒ (3)
UTC-00701
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
02662
02662
皮 107.8
13 · ㇐ (1)
UTC-00709
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
02666
02666
皮 107.11
16 · ㇠ (5)
UTC-00711
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
03089
03089
糸 120.10
16 · ㇠ (5)
UTC-00723
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
03495
03495
虍 141.5
11 · ㇒ (3)
UTC-00742
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
02246
02246
火 86.13
17 · ㇠ (5)
UTC-00766
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
01546
01546
手 64.13
17 · ㇐ (1)
UTC-00768
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
01556
01556
手 64.13
16 · ㇒ (3)
UTC-00787
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
02747
02747
石 112.5
10 · ㇐ (1)
UTC-03168
Disunification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+254DD
U+2C483
According to the document that requested that this ideograph be added to UAX #45 for a future submission to the IRG, https://www.unicode.org/L2/L2018/18064-add-uax45-chars.pdf, this ideograph is the simplified form of U+254DD 𥓝, and that U+2C483 𬒃 is the simplified form of 02778 of IRG Working Set 2021 (aka UTC-03169).
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree with Eiso
02778
02778
石 112.9
14 · ㇐ (1)
UTC-03169
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
04238
04238
門 169.11
19 · ㇒ (3)
UTC-03180
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+95D1
unify to 闑 (U+95D1)?
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree to proposed unification. It is not clear from the evidence image (too low resolution) what the actual shape of the internal component is.
Oppose Unification
Jaemin CHUNG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Evidence enlarged:


The internal component is indeed ⿱自夲 and thus not unifiable with 闑 (U+95D1).
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+95D1
Further discussion is necessary before unification with 闑 (U+95D1) can be considered
01363
01363
心 61.11
15 · ㇐ (1)
UTC-03181
𡗗丿
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+6183
unify to 憃 (U+6183)?
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+6183
U+8202
Unify to 憃 (U+6183) and add a new UCV for 舂
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+6183
Further discussion is necessary before unification with 憃 (U+6183) can be considered
Ucv
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Based on the discussion, it is suggested to add new UCV:
03505
03505
虫 142.3
9 · ㇒ (3)
UTC-03182
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+8677
unify to 虷 (U+8677)?
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+8677
Unify to 虷 (U+8677). As telegraph code books should only list relatively common characters that are well-attested elsewhere, any unencoded characters must be variants or mistakes of already-encoded characters. But as the code books do not provide readings or meanings for the characters listed we have to guess what the true identification of the character is. In this case it is almost certainly a mistake or variant for U+8677. Unify according to UCV principle a-1 (differences in stroke initiation direction).
Oppose Unification
Jaemin CHUNG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Evidence enlarged:


The first stroke of the right-hand component goes top-right to bottom-left. 千 and 干 are different components and thus not unifiable.
Oppose Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
“千” and “干” are apparently different characters and they can't be unified. If we encode these two shape to one code point, the disunification is just a matter of time.
If we have to confirm that this is not a wrongly printed glpyh, we can reject it according to IRG PnP 2.2.1.d.(2), the evidence satisfy none of the items under IRG PnP 2.2.1.d.(2).
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+8677
It is ridiculous to say "“千” and “干” are apparently different characters and they can't be unified" without providing any evidence for the meaning of the ⿰虫千. The telegraph code book is not a dictionary but only lists characters in current use, so ⿰虫千 must be presumed to be a mistake/variant of 虷 unless reliable evidence that it is a separate character can be produced.
Disunification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
To my point of view, unifying “千” to “干” is ridiculous. Though their shape is similar to each other, they are definately different characters. If the componet "千" is written as “干”, we call it a wrong glyph but a variant. If “千” can be unified to “干” without any solid evidence, considering every character that contains a component of “千” can be written as “干”, should we unify them all? The answer is absolutely NO. That's why I oppose to unify the two characters but reject the evidence. Hence the new evidence is provided, I think there is no need to withdraw the character.

What's more, I believe UK said "As telegraph code books should only list relatively common characters that are well-attested elsewhere, any unencoded characters must be variants or mistakes of already-encoded characters" and suggest to unify ⿰虫千 to 虷 (U+8677) based on this, I'd like to know which character should UTC-03171 be unified to.

https://hc.jsecs.org/irg/ws2021/app/?find=UTC-03171

So if the evidece is not clear enough, we'd better reject the evidence but unify the proposed glyph by inference.
Oppose Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Disagree to unify with 虷 (U+8677) per new evidence
03804
03804
豸 153.3
10 · ㇒ (3)
UTC-03183
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+8C7B
unify to 豻 (U+8C7B)?
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+8C7B
Unify to 豻 (U+8C7B). As telegraph code books should only list relatively common characters that are well-attested elsewhere, any unencoded characters must be variants or mistakes of already-encoded characters. But as the code books do not provide readings or meanings for the characters listed we have to guess what the true identification of the character is. In this case it is almost certainly a mistake or variant for U+8C7B. Unify according to UCV principle a-1 (differences in stroke initiation direction).
Oppose Unification
Jaemin CHUNG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Evidence enlarged:


The first stroke of the right-hand component goes top-right to bottom-left. 千 and 干 are different components and thus not unifiable.
Oppose Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
千” and “干” are apparently different characters and they can't be unified. If we encode these two shape to one code point, the disunification is just a matter of time.
If we have to confirm that this is not a wrongly printed glpyh, we can reject it according to IRG PnP 2.2.1.d.(2), the evidence satisfy none of the items under IRG PnP 2.2.1.d.(2).
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+8C7B
It is ridiculous to say "“千” and “干” are apparently different characters and they can't be unified" without providing any evidence for the meaning of the ⿰豸千. The telegraph code book is not a dictionary but only lists characters in current use, so ⿰豸千 must be presumed to be a mistake/variant of 豻 unless reliable evidence that it is a separate character can be produced.
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+8C7B
Further discussion is necessary before unification with 豻 (U+8C7B) can be considered
04553
04553
鬼 194.5
15 · ㇐ (1)
UTC-03184
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+9B46
unify to 魆 (U+9B46)?
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+9B46
Unify to 魆 (U+9B46). As telegraph code books should only list relatively common characters that are well-attested elsewhere, any unencoded characters must be variants or mistakes of already-encoded characters. But as the code books do not provide readings or meanings for the characters listed we have to guess what the true identification of the character is. In this case it is almost certainly a mistake or variant for U+9B46.
Oppose Unification
Jaemin CHUNG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Disagree. 戉 and 戊 are different components.
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+620A
U+6209
U+9B46
In this case 戊 is an obvious and minor mistake for 戉. We should not enode error forms of characters just because a component is miswritten. Strongly support unification with 魆 (U+9B46).
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+9B46
Further discussion is necessary before unification with 魆 (U+9B46) can be considered
02380
02380
犬 94.8
11 · ㇒ (3)
UTC-03186
𫤘
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+730A
unify to 猊 (U+730A)?
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
This is the same simplification of the 臼 component as seen in UTC-03181. Consider adding a UCV. for 兒 and 𫤘.
Ucv
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Suggest to add new UCV 兒/𠒇/𫤘.
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+730A
Further discussion is necessary before unification with 猊 (U+730A) can be considered
03787
03787
言 149.13
20 · ㇒ (3)
UTC-03187
丿
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+8B6D
unify to 譭 (U+8B6D)?
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+8B6D
Further discussion is necessary before unification with 譭 (U+8B6D) can be considered
00155
00155
人 9.8
10 · ㇐ (1)
UTC-03188
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+506D
unify to 偭 (U+506D)?
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+506D
U+9763
U+9762
Unify to 偭 (U+506D). As telegraph code books should only list relatively common characters that are well-attested elsewhere, any unencoded characters must be variants or mistakes of already-encoded characters. But as the code books do not provide readings or meanings for the characters listed we have to guess what the true identification of the characters are. In this case, 靣 is well-known variant of 面, so it is best to unify UTC-03188 with 偭 and register an IVS for this glyph form.
Oppose Unification
Jaemin CHUNG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Not unifiable by NUCV #317.
Ucv
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
I think we should remove NUCV #317. That rule was put there at a time when we did not have the Ideographic Variation Database. The form 靣 is sufficiently rare nowadays but was a common variant form of 面, which makes it a good candidate to be encoded as an ideographic variation instead of as a separate character.
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+506D
Agree to unify with 偭 (U+506D); agree to remove NUCV #317
02280
02280
爪 87.10
14 · ㇠ (5)
UTC-03193
𰆊
Oppose Unification
Jaemin CHUNG
Individual
⿱爲𰆊 and 噕 are non-cognates.

According to page 2 of WG2 N4008 (the first URL in my comment above) which in turn cites the source reference document for K2, 噕 is read 고 (go) or 하고 (hago).
But according to the evidence provided by Eiso, ⿱爲𰆊 is read 한 (han).

So it is not clear why the virtual row 93 of GB 12345 changed ⿱爲𰆊 to 噕.
03886
03886
足 157.7
14 · ㇔ (4)
UTC-03195
Unification
Eddie LI
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
unified with TD-4828
00450
00450
口 30.5
8 · ㇠ (5)
UTC-03197
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+5463
Unify to 呣?
Oppose Unification
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Do not unify to 呣 (U+5463).
They are non-cognate. 呣 is used as a modal particle while UTC-03197 is used for negation.
Oppose Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Disagree to unify with 呣 (U+5463) per Henry's comments
Unification
TAO Yang
China
U+5463
UTC-03197 and 呣 (U+5463) share the same pronunciation.
According to the evidence, I doubt it means 不是(no), which is generally written as 唔是 or 唔系 in Cantonese, UTC-03197 and 唔 share the same pronunciation and meaning.
In addition, 呣 have a variant shape which is much more similar to UTC-03197.

On the whole, the characters are created for language, people could give a pronunciation multiple ways of writing. Considering the randomness of ordinary people's writing, it is not unreasonable to link UTC-03197 and 呣 (U+5463) as synonym in this case.
Oppose Unification
WANG Yifan
SAT
In Min, 母 does not have initial M and theoretically cannot be used as phonetic of this word.

Note that the Taiwanese Minnan Dictionary does list 呣 as a variant of 毋. https://twblg.dict.edu.tw/holodict_new/
00359
00359
勹 20.15
17 · ㇒ (3)
UTC-03200
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
00722
00722
口 30.16
19 · ㇠ (5)
UTC-03218
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
00031
00031
丿 4.5
6 · ㇑ (2)
UTC-03219
𠂝
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
00913
00913
土 32.15
18 · ㇐ (1)
UTC-03228
𮧌
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2BBB0
Unify to 𫮰?
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+58BB
U+2BBB0
Further discussion is necessary before unification with 墻 (U+58BB) or U+2BBB0 𫮰 can be considered
01259
01259
广 53.9
12 · ㇒ (3)
UTC-03230
𠂊广
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2B756
Unify to 𫝖?
𫝖 has J-Source only now. And this character is also used in Japan.
Unification
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2B756
Unify to 𫝖

JH-JTC064 is a variant of 麁.

Also refer to the following Google search result, which shows the place name in the evidence to be 麁利町:
Unification
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
The pronunciation そ is also consistent with the on-reading of 麁.
Unification
Ken LUNDE
UTC
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2B756
Agree to unify with 𫝖 (U+2B756)
02971
02971
竹 118.13
19 · ㇐ (1)
V4-5037
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree with unification
04179
04179
金 167.14
22 · ㇒ (3)
V4-5642
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree with unification
00033
00033
丿 4.6
7 · ㇐ (1)
VN-F000F
Unification
Xieyang WANG
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2B826
unify to 𫠦
Unification
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+6240
U+3ABD
U+20A44
U+2B742
U+2B826
U+2CED0
Existing coded variant forms of 所 include 㪽 (U+3ABD), 𠩄 (U+20A44), 𫝂 (U+2B742), 𫠦 (U+2B826), 𬻐 (U+2CED0).
Oppose Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
While the semantic relationship is clear, structurally, the overall effect is different from the other variants and we see no need to unify.
Unification
TAO Yang
China
U+6240
U+3ABD
U+20A44
U+2B742
U+2B826
U+2CED0
As Henry mentioned, there are 5 existing coded variant forms of 所 include 㪽 (U+3ABD), 𠩄 (U+20A44), 𫝂 (U+2B742), 𫠦 (U+2B826), 𬻐 (U+2CED0).
1. The quality of this character is questionable.
2. A similar glyph has already been encoded in 𫠦 (U+2B826).
3. There would be no end for this issue, for the discovery of variants would be a endless trip.
Oppose Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
Most of the CJK characters in Unicode are variants of another character as a large number of the characters proposed in WS2021. So, this is not an argument for unification. Neither is there new information added since the previous IRG #57 decision to not unify.
00178
00178
人 9.9
11 · ㇔ (4)
VN-F002E
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree with unification
03973
03973
辵 162.8
12 · ㇠ (5)
VN-F05A2
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2CA32
unify to 𬨲 (U+2CA32)
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2CA32
Agree, this should be unified to 𬨲 (U+2CA32)
03050
03050
糸 120.3
9 · ㇑ (2)
VN-F06F7
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree with Unification
00610
00610
口 30.12
15 · ㇐ (1)
VN-F0B14
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2D25B
unify to 𭉛 (U+2D25B)?
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2C6F8
Yes, this can be unfied, since ⿱日工 is a common variant of 𬛸 as a component
03620
03620
虫 142.11
17 · ㇠ (5)
VN-F0B36
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01997
01997
水 85.4
7 · ㇐ (1)
VN-F0B6A
Oppose Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Do not unify to 沔 (U+6C94) by UCV #326 as not cognate (reading of cái indicates rhs must be 丐 not 丏)
Oppose Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Andrew is correct. This character, read "cái", is the name of a river in Vietnam. 沔 (U+6C94) read "miền" means "area" or "region". They need to be kept separate.
00603
00603
口 30.11
14 · ㇠ (5)
VN-F16CA
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree with unification
00611
00611
口 30.12
15 · ㇐ (1)
VN-F16D1
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Unification
TAO Yang
China
雪鴻堂文集
古文苑
古音複字
00653
00653
口 30.13
16 · ㇠ (5)
VN-F16EC
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+21078
unify to 𡁸 (U+21078)?
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+21078
Unify to 𡁸 (U+21078) by UCV #284
00510
00510
口 30.8
11 · ㇒ (3)
VN-F173E
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree with unification
00500
00500
口 30.8
11 · ㇑ (2)
VN-F1742
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree with unification
00792
00792
土 32.4
7 · ㇒ (3)
VN-F178C
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
[ WS2017-00665 ]
unify to WS2017-00665 KC-07393
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
agree to unification
01447
01447
手 64.5
8 · ㇒ (3)
VN-F18EB
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
01740
01740
月 74.7
11 · ㇒ (3)
VN-F195F
Oppose Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
The radical for this character is 74, while U+8115 is 130
02261
02261
火 86.15
19 · ㇔ (4)
VN-F19F8
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+244B2
unify to 𤒲 (U+244B2)?
Unification
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+244B2
Unify to 𤒲 (U+244B2) by UCV #184a
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree to unification
02202
02202
火 86.9
13 · ㇔ (4)
VN-F1A05
𢒎
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2AE4E
unify to 𪹎 (U+2AE4E)
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+2AE4E
Unify to 𪹎 (U+2AE4E). Shape is slightly different, so will propose as IVS
02310
02310
牛 93.4
8 · ㇒ (3)
VN-F1A16
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02409
02409
犬 94.10
13 · ㇒ (3)
VN-F1A19
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
02394
02394
犬 94.9
12 · ㇒ (3)
VN-F1A20
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
agree with unification
03465
03465
艸 140.16
20 · ㇑ (2)
VN-F1B39
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+8603
unify to 蘃 (U+8603)
Unification
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+8603
Agree with unification to 蘃
03515
03515
虫 142.5
11 · ㇐ (1)
VN-F1B4B
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
00589
00589
口 30.11
14 · ㇒ (3)
VN-F1D5E
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
[ WS2017-00525 ]
unify to WS2017-00525 VN-F1D5E
VN-F1D5E has still been kept in WS2017 after the discussion at online IRG #56. Vietnam has provided new explanation on this character.
00205
00205
人 9.13
15 · ㇐ (1)
VN-F20A8
Unification
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]


Attributes

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
04524
04524
骨 188.8
17 · ㇐ (1)
GDM-00227
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
TS=18
02823
02823
石 112.19
24 · ㇒ (3)
GDM-00268
𬙔
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿰石𬙙
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=9
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=2
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
TS=14
04687
04687
鳥 196.3
8 · ㇐ (1)
GDM-00286
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
The radical should be 196.1 not 196.0.
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add the second radical as 32.0 because of the semantics
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=5 with the second radical as 32.0.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=3 with the second radical as 32.0.
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Change Radical to 196' 鸟
04673
04673
魚' 195'.8
16 · ㇐ (1)
GDM-00302
Total Stroke Count
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
TS=17
04254
04254
阜 170.3
5 · ㇐ (1)
GDM-00305
Total Stroke Count
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
TS=6
03363
03363
艸 140.9
13 · ㇐ (1)
GDM-00320
Residual Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change SC to 10.
Total Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change TC to 14.
00099
00099
二 7.3
5 · ㇑ (2)
GDM-00330
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Add 46 山 as the second radical.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Add SC=2 as the second SC.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Add FS=1 as the second FS.
IDS
HUANG Junliang
Individual
Change IDS to ⿱亠山 and update glyph accordingly.

⿱二山 is unifiable to ⿱亠山 per UCV #62.

Here is the evidence of ⿱亠山:



▲ 漢字海 pp. 190
IDS
Andrew WEST
UK
Keep IDS and glyph as ⿱二山 as in my experience this is the most common form of this character.
02576
02576
田 102.1
6 · ㇐ (1)
GDM-00349
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 1 一

The component 一 comes from 心 according to the evidence.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=5 if the radical been changed to 1.0.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=2 if the radical been changed to 1.0.
Radical
Ken LUNDE
UTC
The current radical, 102 田, is more intuitive than 1 一.
02941
02941
竹 118.10
16 · ㇐ (1)
GDM-00360
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=3
04626
04626
魚 195.11
22 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00216
IDS
HUANG Junliang
Individual
change ids to ⿰魚𢛢
04952
04952
龍 212.11
27 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00229
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 195 魚

The evidence shows it's the name of a kind of fish.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=16 if the radical been changed to 195.0.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=4 if the radical been changed to 195.0.
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Change Radical to 195 魚

The evidence shows it's the name of a kind of fish.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
SC=16 if the radical been changed to 195.0.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
FS=4 if the radical been changed to 195.0.
Radical
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
Follow comment #2161, 《莊子注》 annotated that 阿鮭蠪 doesn't relate with fish, which is much more like a legendary creature. Therefore, ⿱龍魚 should maintain its radical in 212 龍.



《莊子注》,《欽定四庫全書》
https://ctext.org/library.pl?if=gb&file=53877&page=15#box(176,57.666664123535156,1,0)
04575
04575
魚 195.4
15 · ㇠ (5)
GKJ-00235
Residual Stroke Count
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
SC=5, TS=16
03439
03439
艸 140.14
17 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00249
Total Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change TC to 18.
01934
01934
殳 79.17
21 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00254
𣪊
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 195 魚

The evidence shows it's the name of a kind of fish.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=10
IDS
Conifer TSENG
TCA
⿰⿳士冖⿱一魚殳
04579
04579
魚 195.5
16 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00262
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
IDS=⿰魚卯 if Comment #4214 been accepted.

I support Henry's comment.
04655
04655
魚 195.16
27 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00276
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
SC=17
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
TS=28
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
FS=2
00127
00127
亠 8.16
18 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00279
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add the second radical as 195.0 because of the semantics
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=7 with the second radical as 195.0.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=4 with the second radical as 195.0.
04606
04606
魚 195.8
19 · ㇠ (5)
GKJ-00280
Residual Stroke Count
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
SC=9
01586
01586
手 64.16
19 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00293
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 196 鳥

The evidence shows this character is related to a kind of bird.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=8 if the radical been changed to 196.0.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=1 if the radical been changed to 196.0.
04510
04510
馬 187.11
21 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00299
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 196 鳥

The evidence shows this character is related to a kind of bird.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=10 if the radical been changed to 196.0
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=1 if the radical been changed to 196.0
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Change Radical to 196 鳥

The evidence shows this character is related to a kind of bird.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
SC=10 if the radical been changed to 196.0
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
FS=1 if the radical been changed to 196.0
00410
00410
鳥 196.14
25 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00301
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 196 鳥
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=14 if the radical been changed to 196.0 鳥.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=1 if the radical been changed to 196.0 鳥.
04937
04937
鼠 208.11
24 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00302
Radical
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
As the evidence of WS2017-04940 , which probably simplify to ⿰鼠鳥, shows that it is a kind of bird. It seems that the radical should be changed to 196 鳥.
03487
03487
艸 140.21
24 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00306
𠂤
Total Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change TC to 25.
00229
00229
鳥 196.8
18 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00313
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 196 鳥
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=8 if the radical been changed to 196.0
00408
00408
厂 27.17
19 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00315
Radical
WANG Yifan
SAT
May be better changing Radical to 196 鳥. What is the rationale below this text?
01408
01408
心 61.17
20 · ㇠ (5)
GKJ-00318
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 196 鳥

⿰恨鳥鶻 is a word meant a kind of bird on the evidence
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=9 if the radical been changed to 196.0
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=4 if the radical been changed to 196.0
04745
04745
鳥 196.10
21 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00319
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
SC=9
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
TS=20
00217
00217
鳥 196.6
17 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00326
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 196 鳥
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=6 if the radical been changed to 196.0
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=3 if the radical been changed to 196.0
02824
02824
石 112.19
24 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00336
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 196 鳥

The evidence shows it's the variant of 鸊.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=13
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=1
04700
04700
鳥 196.6
17 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00341
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿰夹鳥
04743
04743
鳥 196.11
22 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00345
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=11
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=2
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
TS=22
04783
04783
鳥 196.14
25 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00349
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿰截鳥
02153
02153
水 85.22
25 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00353
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 196 鳥

The evidence shows it's related to a kind of bird.
04184
04184
金 167.15
23 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00363
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿰欽鳥
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 196 鳥

The evidence shows this character is related to a kind of bird.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=12 if the radical been changed to 196.0.
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Change Radical to 196 鳥

The evidence shows this character is related to a kind of bird.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
SC=12 if the radical been changed to 196.0.
04709
04709
鳥 196.7
18 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00365
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=1 or 3?
00409
00409
厂 27.19
21 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00366
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 196 鳥
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=10 if the radical been changed to 196.0 鳥.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=1 if the radical been changed to 196.0 鳥.
04760
04760
鳥 196.12
23 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00367
TE-493F
Residual Stroke Count
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
SC=13, FS=2, TS=24
04283
04283
阜 170.16
19 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00368
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 196 鳥

The evidence shows this character is related to a kind of bird.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=8 if the radical been changed to 196.0.
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
TS=19
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=5 if the radical been changed to 196.0.
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Change Radical to 196 鳥

The evidence shows this character is related to a kind of bird.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
SC=8 if the radical been changed to 196.0.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
FS=5 if the radical been changed to 196.0.
01587
01587
手 64.16
19 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00370
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 196 鳥

The evidence shows the phonetic element is 押, and the semantic element is 鳥.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=8 if the radical been changed to 196.0.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=1 if the radical been changed to 196.0.
04714
04714
鳥 196.7
18 · ㇠ (5)
GKJ-00379
IDS
HUANG Junliang
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
The glyph does not match the IDS.

Consider change IDS to ⿱壯鳥 and accept the new evidence here which gives ⿱壯鳥:



浙江通志(清乾隆刊本) 卷101 folio 2

⿱𡉟鳥 can be unified to ⿱壯鳥 by UCV #312.
IDS
Eddie LI
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS should be "壯鳥"
04772
04772
鳥 196.12
23 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00388
IDS
Eddie LI
Individual
⿰渺鳥
04814
04814
鳥' 196'.9
14 · ㇠ (5)
GKJ-00393
Residual Stroke Count
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
SC=10, TS=15
04816
04816
鳥' 196'.11
16 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00395
Residual Stroke Count
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
SC=12, TS=17
03617
03617
虫 142.11
17 · ㇠ (5)
GKJ-00399
Residual Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change SC to 12.
Total Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change TC to 18.
01050
01050
宀 40.11
14 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00408
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 142 虫

According to the evidence, it's a kind of insect.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=8 if the radical been changed to 142.0
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=4 if the radical been changed to 142.0
03594
03594
虫 142.10
16 · ㇠ (5)
GKJ-00421
VN-F0B36
Residual Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change SC to 11.
Total Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change TC to 17.
03618
03618
虫 142.11
17 · ㇠ (5)
GKJ-00438
Residual Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change SC to 12.
Total Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change TC to 18.
03551
03551
虫 142.8
14 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00469
Residual Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change SC to 9.
Total Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change TC to 15.
03665
03665
虫 142.18
24 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00475
IDS
Eddie LI
Individual
⿱蟲虫
03959
03959
辵 162.4
7 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00483
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
TS=8
04180
04180
金 167.14
22 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00485
Residual Stroke Count
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
SC=15, TS=23
04188
04188
金 167.16
24 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00501
TE-4A5A
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
FS=2
04146
04146
金 167.11
19 · ㇠ (5)
GKJ-00506
IDS
Eddie LI
Individual
⿰鍏刂
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
It's not better to update the IDS to ⿰鍏刂 because of the semantics based on the evidences. Please keep ⿲金韋刂.
04093
04093
金 167.9
17 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00508
Residual Stroke Count
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
SC=10, FS=2, TS=18 according to IRGN954AR.
04135
04135
金 167.12
20 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00510
𢔪
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=12
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
TS=20
04187
04187
金 167.15
23 · ㇠ (5)
GKJ-00526
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿰鏁斤
04200
04200
金 167.18
26 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00527
Residual Stroke Count
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
SC=19, TS=27
04087
04087
金 167.8
13 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00531
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Change Radical to 167' 钅
04167
04167
金 167.13
18 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00532
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Change Radical to 167' 钅
01844
01844
木 75.12
16 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00575
IDS
Conifer TSENG
TCA
Change IDS to ⿰木𭸟. (𭸟=U+2DE1F)
00730
00730
口 30.17
20 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00606
UK-20392
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿰口獲
01793
01793
木 75.8
12 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00635
IDS
Eddie LI
Individual
⿰枤木
04923
04923
鼠 208.7
16 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00652
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 140 艸
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=12
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=1
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
TS=16
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Change Radical to 140 艸
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
SC=12
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
FS=1
04850
04850
鹿 198.6
17 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00670
鹿
IDS
BAI Yi
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿸鹿合
04836
04836
鹿 198.4
15 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00674
鹿
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Change Radical to 72 日

The evidence shows this character is the variant of 暴, and the radical of 暴 is 72.0 日.

U+66B4
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
SC=11 if the radical been changed to 72.0.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
FS=4 if the radical been changed to 72.0.
04851
04851
鹿 198.6
17 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00678
鹿𠑼
IDS
Lee COLLINS
Vietnam
The IDS ⿸鹿⿰𠂎巳 would be clearer and eliminate the need for the variation indicator 〾
03789
03789
言 149.19
26 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00680
鹿
IDS
BAI Yi
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿰言⿱鹿兔
04875
04875
鹿 198.10
21 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00694
鹿
IDS
BAI Yi
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱鹿留
04872
04872
鹿 198.9
20 · ㇠ (5)
GKJ-00712
鹿
Residual Stroke Count
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
SC=10, TS=21
03569
03569
虫 142.9
15 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00722
Residual Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change SC to 8.
Total Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change TC to 14.
04810
04810
鳥' 196'.8
13 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00756
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
SC=9
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
TS=14
01935
01935
比 81.5
9 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00775
Radical
Conifer TSENG
TCA
Change Radical to 109 目.
The radical should be the same as 眥 (U+7725).
00400
00400
厂 27.7
9 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00801
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 196' 鸟
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=4
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=1
03367
03367
魚' 195'.8
16 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00815
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 195' 鱼
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=8
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=4
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
TS=16
00743
00743
口 30.18
21 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00817
𪖙
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿰口𪖙
04197
04197
金 167.18
26 · ㇠ (5)
GKJ-00834
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=18
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
TS=26
04210
04210
金' 167'.9
14 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00846
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
The radical should be 167.0 not 167.1.
04094
04094
金 167.9
14 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00847
Radical
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
Change Radical to 167' 钅
04171
04171
金' 167'.13
21 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00849
Total Stroke Count
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
TS=18
04213
04213
金' 167'.12
20 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00850
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
The radical should be 167.0 not 167.1.
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Change Radical to 167 金
04139
04139
金 167.11
16 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00851
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 167' 钅
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Change Radical to 167' 钅
00768
00768
囗 31.4
7 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00874
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿴囗六
00761
00761
囗 31.2
5 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00875
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿴囗七
00762
00762
囗 31.2
5 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00876
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿴囗九
00777
00777
囗 31.10
13 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00877
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿴囗⿳一巛⿸厂六
00447
00447
口 30.5
8 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00910
IDS
Eddie LI
Individual
⿰口⿱𠘧口
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
The current IDS is OK, there is no need to change.
03696
03696
行 144.19
25 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00916
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=19
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=2
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
TS=25
03694
03694
行 144.14
20 · ㇠ (5)
GKJ-00920
IDS
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change IDS to ⿲彳绿亍.
03684
03684
行 144.9
15 · ㇠ (5)
GKJ-00921
IDS
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change IDS to ⿲彳红亍.
Residual Stroke Count
Andrew WEST
UK
SC = 6
Total Stroke Count
Andrew WEST
UK
TC = 12
03695
03695
行 144.18
24 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00924
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=18
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
TS=24
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=2
04108
04108
金 167.9
17 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00934
IDS
Andrew WEST
UK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change the IDS and glyph to ⿱信金 to match the evidence.
04031
04031
酉 164.8
15 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00946
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿰亚酉

Support Andrew's comment under #1970.
Residual Stroke Count
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
as the glyph and IDS changed, SC=6, TS=13
02569
02569
生 100.8
13 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00952
Residual Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change SC to 6.
Total Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change TC to 11.
02575
02575
生 100.18
23 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-00953
Residual Stroke Count
Henry CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=18, FS=2, TC=23
00640
00640
口 30.13
16 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00956
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=4
02039
02039
水 85.9
13 · ㇐ (1)
GKJ-00957
IDS
Conifer TSENG
TCA
Change IDS to ⿰氵𠫴.
00113
00113
口 30.4
7 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00962
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 30 口

The RS values for the relevant encoded characters in the evidence are shown as below.

U+20B9B 𠮛 30.1
U+20BA1 𠮡 30.2
U+20BB0 𠮰 30.3
U+546C 呬 30.5
U+3576 㕶 30.4
U+20B9F 𠮟 30.2
U+53ED 叭 30.2
U+3564 㕤 30.2
U+53F6 叶 30.2
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=4 if the radical been changed to 30.0.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=4 if the radical been changed to 30.0.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
FS=4
04521
04521
骨 188.3
12 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00972
Total Stroke Count
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
TS=13
03410
03410
艸 140.12
15 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-00983
Total Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change TC to 16.
03743
03743
見 147.14
21 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00995
FS
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
FS=2
04555
04555
鬼 194.6
16 · ㇒ (3)
GKJ-00998
UK-20785
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=1
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
FS=1



▲ IRGN954AR
04567
04567
鬼 194.12
22 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-01004
UK-20788
FS
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
FS=3
01612
01612
攴 66.10
14 · ㇔ (4)
GKJ-01011
𰗣
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿰𰗣攵
00369
00369
十 24.3
5 · ㇑ (2)
GKJ-01023
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
U+25A1 □ is used as the element of this IDS, which is like the similar issue mentioned in IRGN2413R2 by me.
04117
04117
金 167.10
15 · ㇒ (3)
GXM-00433
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=2
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Change Radical to 167' 钅
04572
04572
魚 195.3
15 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-0061201
Residual Stroke Count
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
SC=4
00495
00495
口 30.8
11 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-0082102
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 18 刀

品 is the semantic element.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=9 if the radical been changed to 18.0
01732
01732
月 74.5
9 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-0092201
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 130 肉

The meaning of this character is "to embrace", that is related to the human body, so the radical should be 130.0.
03355
03355
艸 140.8
11 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-0101302
Total Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change TC to 12.
00727
00727
口 30.17
20 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-0252103
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 196 鳥

The left component is the phonetic element, which the tail vowel has been -t from -n like common sub-dialects of Yue-dialects, and the right component is the semantic element because of the meaning.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=9
02658
02658
皮 107.5
10 · ㇔ (4)
GZ-0271501
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add the second radical as 24.0, because the radical of U+534A 半 is 24.0, which U+534A 半 is the semantic element.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=8 with the second radical as 24.0
01227
01227
巾 50.8
11 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-0361401
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿰中朋
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 2 丨

#1516 shows the rationale.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=11
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=2
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
TS=12
01746
01746
月 74.9
13 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-0381205
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 130 肉

The radical should be the same as 肥.
00010
00010
一 1.10
11 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-0381601
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add the second radical as 30.0, because the radical of U+53F3 is 30.0, which U+53F3 is the semantic element.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=8 with the second radical as 30.0.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=1 with the second radical as 30.0.
00186
00186
人 9.10
12 · ㇔ (4)
GZ-0542402
TB-4931
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
SC=11
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
FS=3
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
TS=13
04383
04383
靑 174.7
15 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-0761402
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add the second radical as 102.0, because the radical of U+7537 男 is 102.0, which U+7537 男 is the semantic element.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=10 with the second radical as 102.0
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=5 with the second radical as 102.0
03895
03895
足 157.10
17 · ㇔ (4)
GZ-1101103
𧾷
FS
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
FS=2
01753
01753
月 74.12
16 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-1152104
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 130 肉

The radical should be the same as 肫 and 胗.
01748
01748
月 74.10
14 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-1221201
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 130 肉

The meaning is related to human and animal.
01741
01741
月 74.8
12 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-1442201
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 130 肉

~⿰月口 (duzgaeuh) is a stable word meant "knee" on the evidence.
00310
00310
刀 18.8
10 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-1521105
Radical
BAI Yi
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
灰 is semantic component so radical should be 火.
Change Radical to 86 火
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=6 if the radical been changed to 86.0 or the second radical been added.
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Change Radical to 86 火

See #1083 by Yi Bai.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
SC=6 if the radical been changed to 86.0 or the second radical been added.
01620
01620
文 67.4
8 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-1521506
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 92 牙

It's the variant of U+2DDCF 𭷏. The semantic element is 牙, and the phonetic element is 文.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=4 if the radical been changed to 92.0.
00241
00241
儿 10.9
11 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-1571301
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
It's better to change the radical to 154.0 because of the semantics.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=4 if the radical been changed.
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
It's better to change the radical to 154.0 because of the semantics.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
SC=4 if the radical been changed.
Radical
WANG Yifan
SAT
Is the character deformed shape of 費? Then the radical should be 154.0 貝.
00011
00011
一 1.10
11 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-1621602
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add the second radical as 32.0, because the radical of U+5728 is 32.0, which U+5728 is the semantic element.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=8 with the second radical as 32.0.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=1 with the second radical as 32.0.
03878
03878
足 157.6
12 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-1651304
𧾷
Residual Stroke Count
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
SC=5, FS=3
02376
02376
犬 94.8
11 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-1691202
IDS
Conifer TSENG
TCA
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
The glyph and IDS should be changed to ⿰犭𮌈.
U+2E308 𮌈
01911
01911
止 77.11
15 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-1702102
齿
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 211' 齿
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=7
03326
03326
艸 140.6
9 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-1721202
Total Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change TC to 10.
03726
03726
衣 145.12
16 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-2041101
Residual Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change SC to 11.
03500
03500
虍 141.11
17 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-2072307
Residual Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change SC to 12.
Total Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change TC to 18.
01735
01735
月 74.6
9 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-2081109
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 130 肉

The meanings are "hip" and "lumbar".
00144
00144
人 9.6
9 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-2081307
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add the second radical as 17.0, because the radical of U+51F9 凹 is 17.0, which U+51F9 凹 is the semantic element.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=7 with the second radical as 17.0.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=5 with the second radical as 17.0.
04939
04939
鼻 209.8
22 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-2211103
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=3
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
TS=22
03868
03868
足 157.3
11 · ㇠ (5)
GZ-2322101
𧾷
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
SC=4
00118
00118
亠 8.10
12 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-2351306
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add the second radical as 36.0, because the radical of U+591C 夜 is 36.0, which U+591C 夜 is the semantic element.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=9 with the second radical as 36.0.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=4 with the second radical as 36.0.
IDS
BAI Yi
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿺夜今
03377
03377
艸 140.10
13 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-2352411
Total Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change TC to 14.
01736
01736
月 74.6
10 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-2382307
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 130 肉

胬~ (noh haeu) is a stable word according to the evidence.
04942
04942
齒 211.4
11 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-2441401
齿
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
The radical should be 211.1, not 211.0.
03315
03315
色 139.5
11 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-2451603
IDS
BAI Yi
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿺色号
03160
03160
羊 123.8
14 · ㇔ (4)
GZ-2471202
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=1
00108
00108
二 7.11
13 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-2472307
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add the second radical as 140.0, because the radical of U+8305 茅 is 140.0, which U+8305 茅 is the semantic element.

BTW, U+4E94 五 reads as haj here.

Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=9 with the second radical as 140.0.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=1 with the second radical as 140.0.
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
TS=13
00419
00419
又 29.7
8 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-2902802
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=4
02909
02909
立 117.5
10 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-2992108
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add the second radical as 20.0, because the radical of U+5305 包 is 20.0, which U+5305 包 is the semantic element.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=8 with the second radical as 20.0
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=4 with the second radical as 20.0
03991
03991
辵 162.12
15 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-3001305
Total Stroke Count
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
TS=16
01628
01628
文 67.8
12 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-3041104
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 75 木

The semantic element is 果, and the phonetic element is 文.
00398
00398
厂 27.6
8 · ㇔ (4)
GZ-3231202
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=3
02920
02920
立 117.18
23 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-3321510
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 8 亠

The radical should follow the RS for U+4EB2 亲.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=21 if the radical been changed to 8.0.

SC=18 if the radical been kept.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=4 if the radical been changed to 8.0.

These is no need to update the FS value if the radical been kept.
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
TS=23
01950
01950
毛 82.9
13 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-3361201
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add the second radical as 86.0, because the radical of U+70B9 点 is 86.0, which U+70B9 点 is the semantic element.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=3 with the second radical as 86.0.
01083
01083
小 42.15
18 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-3382201
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 10 儿

The radical of 光 is 10.0
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=16
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=2
03087
03087
糸 120.10
16 · ㇠ (5)
GZ-3422101
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿰糹能
01749
01749
月 74.10
14 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-3461207
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 130 肉

The meaning is related to "face".
04940
04940
鼻 209.10
24 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-3511102
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=5
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
FS=5
00487
00487
口 30.8
12 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-3712208
Radical
WANG Yifan
SAT
Change Radical to 72 日
01742
01742
月 74.8
12 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-3721101
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 130 肉

~⿰手蒙 (ngamz mungz) is a stable word meant the space between the fingers, which is related to the human body.
01111
01111
山 46.4
9 · ㇠ (5)
GZ-3732202
Residual Stroke Count
LI Yuan
SAT
SC=6.
01733
01733
月 74.5
9 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-3781201
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 130 肉

The radicals of 腻 and the unencoded ⿰肉艾 are both 130.0.
Residual Stroke Count
Conifer TSENG
TCA
SC=6, TS=10
04085
04085
金 167.8
16 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-3822603
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add the second radical as 75.0 because of the semantics.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=12 with the second radical as 75.0.
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Add the second radical as 75.0 because of the semantics.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
SC=12 with the second radical as 75.0.
00969
00969
女 38.6
9 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-3881102
Radical
WANG Yifan
SAT
Change Radical to 130 肉 as the right side is the semantic.
00149
00149
人 9.7
9 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-3901301
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add the second radical as 100.0 because of the semantics
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=4 with the second radical as 100.0.
01055
01055
宀 40.12
15 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-3952101
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add the second radical as 140.0, because the radical of U+82BD 芽 is 140.0, which U+82BD 芽 is the semantic element.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=4 with the second radical as 140.0
03337
03337
艸 140.6
13 · ㇠ (5)
GZ-3991404
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
TS=13
Radical
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Change Radical to 39 子 (more inuitive).
Residual Stroke Count
Ken LUNDE
UTC
Regardless of the Radical, the SC value, 6, is incorrect.
02907
02907
立 117.2
7 · ㇠ (5)
GZ-4051101
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add the second radical as 18.0, because the radical of U+5200 刀 is 18.0, which U+5200 刀 is the semantic element.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=5 with the second radical as 18.0.
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=4 with the second radical as 18.0.
00218
00218
人 9.15
15 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-4122102
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Change Radical to 176 面

The semantic element is 面, which is also more intuitive, and the phonetic element is 來.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
SC=8 if the radical been changed to 176 面.
00123
00123
亠 8.13
15 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-4162103
Radical
WANG Yifan
SAT
Change Radical to 182 風 as semantic.
03909
03909
足 157.14
21 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-4321206
𧾷
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
The IDS should be changed to ⿰𧾷鳯 if the glyph been kept.

The IDS should be kept if the glyph been normalized as #1783 shows.
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC should be kept if the glyph been normalized as #1783 shows.

SC=20 if the glyph been kept.
04429
04429
風 182.7
16 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-4332201
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add the second radical as 59.0, because the radical of U+5F62 形 is 59.0, which U+5F62 形 is the semantic element.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=13 with the second radical as 59.0
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=3 with the second radical as 59.0
00469
00469
口 30.7
10 · ㇐ (1)
GZ-4341508
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 31 囗
01747
01747
月 74.10
14 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-4411201
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 130 肉

The RS for the semantic element 背 is 130.5.
00015
00015
一 1.12
13 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-4452111
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add the second radical as 102.0, because the radical of U+7537 男 is 102.0, which U+7537 男 is the semantic element.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=8 with the second radical as 102.0
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=1 with the second radical as 102.0.
04122
04122
金 167.10
17 · ㇔ (4)
GZ-4532602
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
TS=18
04030
04030
酉 164.7
14 · ㇔ (4)
GZ-4622501
FS
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
FS=2
00327
00327
刀 18.15
17 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-4641301
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
Add the second radical as 167 金
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
SC=9 for the second radical as 167 金
00460
00460
口 30.6
9 · ㇒ (3)
GZ-4711408
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change Radical to 31 囗

The radical should be as the same as U+2D375 𭍵, U+56ED 园 and so on.
00124
00124
亠 8.14
16 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-4931202
IDS
BAI Yi
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿺亮克
04397
04397
革 177.11
17 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-5002401
Residual Stroke Count
NG Hou Man
University of Macau
SC=8, FS=1
02717
02717
目 109.16
21 · ㇑ (2)
GZ-5041101
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=16
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
TS=21
FS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
FS=2
01267
01267
广 53.12
14 · ㇔ (4)
GZ-5072401
Radical
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Add the second radical as 123.0, because the radical of U+7F8C 羌 is 123.0, which U+7F8C 羌 is near-homonym of 姜/薑, and 姜/薑 is the semantic element.
Residual Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
SC=8 with the second radical as 123.0
00056
00056
乙 5.5
6 · ㇑ (2)
KC-00023
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS should be ⿱⿰口匕乙
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00071
00071
乙 5.7
8 · ㇠ (5)
KC-00043
IDS
BAI Yi
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿸尾乙 describes the glyph better.
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
KR will modify the glyph to match the original IDS.
00085
00085
乙 5.11
13 · ㇐ (1)
KC-00081
Total Stroke Count
Eiso CHAN
Individual
TS=12
00257
00257
八 12.5
7 · ㇠ (5)
KC-00252
IDS
BAI Yi
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is incorrect. should be ⿱加八.
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
KR agrees to modify IDS as suggested.
00390
00390
卩 26.4
6 · ㇑ (2)
KC-00355
𰆊
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱內𰆊 will be better.
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
KR agrees to change the second component to U+3018A.
00393
00393
卩 26.5
7 · ㇠ (5)
KC-00358
𰆊
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱加𰆊 will be better.
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
KR agrees to change the second component to U+3018A.
00391
00391
卩 26.5
7 · ㇐ (1)
KC-00359
𰆊
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱古𰆊 will be better.
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
KR agrees to change the second component to U+3018A.
00392
00392
卩 26.5
7 · ㇒ (3)
KC-00361
𰆊
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱白𰆊 will be better.
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
KR agrees to change the second component to U+3018A.
00396
00396
卩 26.8
10 · ㇔ (4)
KC-00366
𰆊
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱注𰆊 will be better.
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
KR agrees to change the second component to U+3018A.
00440
00440
口 30.4
7 · ㇠ (5)
KC-00395
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱又⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00435
00435
口 30.4
7 · ㇐ (1)
KC-00396
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱二⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00441
00441
口 30.5
8 · ㇐ (1)
KC-00402
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱士⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00449
00449
口 30.5
8 · ㇠ (5)
KC-00403
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱也⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00442
00442
口 30.5
8 · ㇐ (1)
KC-00404
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱土⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00461
00461
口 30.6
9 · ㇒ (3)
KC-00412
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱毛⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00464
00464
口 30.6
9 · ㇔ (4)
KC-00413
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱文⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00453
00453
口 30.6
9 · ㇐ (1)
KC-00417
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱五⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00465
00465
口 30.6
9 · ㇔ (4)
KC-00420
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱之⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00470
00470
口 30.7
10 · ㇐ (1)
KC-00428
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱巨⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00475
00475
口 30.7
10 · ㇑ (2)
KC-00432
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱北⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00501
00501
口 30.8
11 · ㇒ (3)
KC-00449
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱多⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00503
00503
口 30.8
11 · ㇒ (3)
KC-00453
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱伊⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00504
00504
口 30.8
11 · ㇒ (3)
KC-00454
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱自⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00505
00505
口 30.8
11 · ㇒ (3)
KC-00456
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱朱⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00524
00524
口 30.9
12 · ㇐ (1)
KC-00461
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱吾⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00525
00525
口 30.9
12 · ㇐ (1)
KC-00464
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱求⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00526
00526
口 30.9
12 · ㇐ (1)
KC-00473
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱扶⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00598
00598
口 30.11
14 · ㇠ (5)
KC-00501
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱建⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00631
00631
口 30.13
16 · ㇐ (1)
KC-00532
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱帶⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00632
00632
口 30.13
16 · ㇐ (1)
KC-00534
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱曹⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00646
00646
口 30.13
16 · ㇔ (4)
KC-00536
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿱許⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00732
00732
口 30.17
20 · ㇔ (4)
KC-00568
IDS
Eiso CHAN
Individual
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
⿸廣⿰口匕 will be better
IDS
ROK
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
IDS is not necessarily unique.
The suggested IDS could be added (not replace the original IDS).
00752
00752
口 30.21