IRG Working Set 2021v2.0

Source: Xieyang WANG
Date: Generated on 2022-01-19

Unification

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
00278	00278 冫 15.7 9 · ㇐ (1) GDM-00237 ⿰冫麦	Oppose Unification	Agree with Tao Yang.
02899	02899 穴 116.7 12 · ㇑ (2) GDM-00313 ⿱宀总	Oppose Unification	The radical of 𥦗 is 穴 while the radical of ⿱宀总 is 宀, which means the change is important enough.
01153	01153 山 46.9 12 · ㇑ (2) UK-20727 ⿱屾屾	Oppose Unification	They are clearly distinguished in a book named 《同字符合体字汇》： Page11: Page35: So they should be disunified.

Evidence

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
03636	03636 虫 142.13 19 · ㇐ (1) GDM-00224 ⿰虫赖	Evidence	建湖县地名委员会：江苏省建湖县地名志，P96
02871	02871 禾 115.7 12 · ㇒ (3) GDM-00228 ⿰禾岙	Unclear evidence response	Luckily, I get one copy of the book and scan it myself. It is very clear that the character is ⿰禾岙：
02878	02878 禾 115.8 13 · ㇠ (5) GDM-00230 ⿰禾𭖔	Unclear evidence response	The zoomed picture: and page 450 of the same book:
00105	00105 二 7.9 11 · ㇑ (2) GDM-00296 ⿰亚尔	Evidence	The map of 堆龙德庆县， in 《堆龙德庆县志》，北京：中国藏学出版社，2010年7月
		Evidence	And a clearer image of the map
03825	03825 貝 154.9 13 · ㇐ (1) GDM-00316 ⿱不贵	New evidence	陆丰文史 第九辑，p130
01186	01186 山 46.13 16 · ㇒ (3) GDM-00343 ⿱山𤲞	Evidence	I think it's very clear.
03559	03559 虫 142.8 14 · ㇒ (3) GKJ-00435 ⿱牧虫	New evidence	The Ningpo Syllabary（宁波方言音节），P28
04259	04259 阜 170.7 10 · ㇑ (2) GXM-00303 ⿰阝⿱止马	Evidence	汉印文字征·卷十 P1
00272	00272 冖 14.4 6 · ㇑ (2) SAT-08359 ⿱冖龰	Evidence	FYI, this is a 钞本 I found a few days before, which may be not reliable enough. But maybe they can all be used as each other.
00219	00219 人 9.15 17 · ㇐ (1) UK-20357 ⿰亻鞋	New evidence	《日華對譯福州語》

Glyph Design & Normalization

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
00791	00791 土 32.4 7 · ㇒ (3) UK-20858 ⿱从土	Glyph design	The Ningpo Syllabary, P55, the shape is better to be 工 on the bottom according to the evidence provided by UK.

Other

Sn	Image/Source	Comment Type	Description
03443	03443 艸 140.14 18 · ㇔ (4) GDM-00318 ⿱艹⿰氵𫔴	Other	Agree with Andrew.