Please wait while loading

IRG Working Set 2024v3.0

Source: John Knightley
Date: Generated on 2025-06-15

Show Deleted | Show comments from version: 1.0 2.0 3.0 | Show comments with status: Show All New Only Unresolved Only

Unification

Showing 5 comments.

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
03635
03635
足 157.5.2
GPGLG-2033
VN-F0573
TS 12 · IDS 𧾷
Unification
[ Unresolved from v2.0 ]
01557
01557
手 64.2.1
GZ-1951203
VN-F01E4
TS 5 · IDS
Unification
[ Unresolved from v2.0 ]
02669
02669
石 112.6.4
VN-F03C2
TS 11 · IDS
Unification
[ Unresolved from v2.0 ]
Agree.
03637
03637
足 157.5.2
VN-F0573
TS 12 · IDS 𧾷
Unification
[ Unresolved from v2.0 ]
03635
足 157.5.2
GPGLG-2033
TS 12 · IDS 𧾷
Agree unify to WS2024-03635 as identical shapes.
03963
03963
門 169.9.4
VN-F0606
TS 17 · IDS
Unification
[ Unresolved from v2.0 ]
Agree

Attributes

Showing 41 comments.

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
02604
02604
目 109.7.3
GPGLG-1006
TS 5 · IDS
Total Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed 12.
03024
03024
纟 120′.5.1
GPGLG-1015
TS 1 · IDS
Total Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree TS 8
02605
02605
目 109.8.1
GPGLG-3058
TS 5 · IDS
Total Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed 13
01803
01803
日 72.12.1
GPGLG-4019
TS 16 · IDS
Residual Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree SC=13, TS=17
03059
03059
网 122.9.3
GPGLG-5012
TS 14 · IDS 𬙙
Residual Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed 10
Total Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed 15
01443
01443
心 61.5.4
GZ-0032501
TS 8 · IDS
Residual Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v2.0 ]
Agree SC=6
Total Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v2.0 ]
Agree TS=9
02482
02482
甘 99.12.2
GZ-0052201
TS 17 · IDS
Residual Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree SC=13, TS=18
03609
03609
贝 154′.11.3
戈 62.11.3
GZ-0082105
TS 15 · IDS
Radical
[ Unresolved from v2.0 ]
Agree add second radical.

Yes, 贫 is the phonetic component and 成 the semantic.
04558
04558
鳥 196.10.4
GZ-0091202
TS 21 · IDS
IDS
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree change IDS to ⿺笔鳥.
02366
02366
犬 94.6.5
GZ-0132101
TS 9 · IDS
Residual Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree SC=7, TS=10
03397
03397
虫 142.6.2
GZ-0132401
TS 12 · IDS
Residual Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree SC 7
Total Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree TC 13
03273
03273
白 106.7.2
艸 140.8.1
GZ-0221301
TS 12 · IDS
Radical
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree
Change Radical to 106.0 (白), SC=7, FS=2.
Consider retaining original radical as second radical.
04170
04170
風 182.2.3
GZ-0341301
TS 11 · IDS
IDS
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agrred change IDS to ⿺風卜.
02352
02352
牛 93.11.4
GZ-0472201
TS 15 · IDS
Total Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed TS=16, SC=12
02663
02663
石 112.5.4
GZ-0532301
VN-F03C2
TS 9 · IDS
Residual Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed SC=6, TS=11.
03446
03446
虫 142.16.2
GZ-0611201
TS 6 · IDS
Total Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed TS=22
01159
01159
尸 44.13.5
GZ-0722101
TS 16 · IDS
IDS
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Update IDS to ⿺尼常.
01819
01819
人 9.17.1
GZ-0771402
TS 19 · IDS
Radical
[ Unresolved from v2.0 ]
Agree change radical to 9.0 (人), SC=17 and FS=1.
01827
01827
日 72.5.5
GZ-0862101
TS 9 · IDS
Radical
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed change radical to 72.0 (日)
IDS
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed change IDS to ⿱日召
03343
03343
艸 140.14.4
GZ-1222203
TS 17 · IDS
Total Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed TS=18
02589
02589
皿 108.13.2
阜 170.15.4
GZ-1621102
TS 18 · IDS
Radical
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed change to Radical 170 (阝), SC=15, FS=4.
03424
03424
虫 142.10.4
GZ-2441501
TS 16 · IDS 𦰩
Residual Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed SC=11
Total Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed TC=17
03366
03366
水 85.19.2
艸 140.18.4
GZ-3362401
TS 22 · IDS
Radical
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed change radical to 85.0 (水), SC=18, FS=2
02632
02632
目 109.13.1
GZ-3392303
TS 18 · IDS
Residual Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed SC=14
Total Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed TC=19
00979
00979
女 38.12.5
GZ-3552510
TS 15 · IDS
Radical
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree Change Radical to 38.0 (女), SC=12, FS=5
04569
04569
夕 36.23.2
鳥 196.15.3
GZ-3842501
TS 26 · IDS 𬷨
IDS
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Since 𬷨 is the phonetic and 外 is the meaning the IDS ⿰外𬷨 is clear to those who are familiar with 𬷨, however this does not align with the current radical.
01944
01944
木 75.11.4
GZ-3982201
TS 15 · IDS
IDS
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Change IDS to ⿰染⿱𠆢𠫓
03293
03293
艸 140.9.4
GZ-4021105
TS 12 · IDS
Residual Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed SC=10, TS=14
00253
00253
凵 17.12.5
GZ-4022108
TS 14 · IDS
IDS
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
The IDS should remain as it is because, strange as it may seem at first sight, the established convention is to use 出 (U+51FA) not 岀 (U+5C80) in such cases.
04124
04124
雨 173.20.2
GZ-4122404
TS 28 · IDS
Residual Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed SC=21, TS=29
00242
00242
冫 15.7.4
GZ-4231104
TS 99 · IDS
Total Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed TS=9
03467
03467
衣 145.9.3
GZ-4881101
TS 14 · IDS
Total Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree TS=15
04148
04148
韋 178.9.4
GZ-4901401
TS 19 · IDS
Residual Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree SC 10
Total Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree TC 19
03306
03306
艸 140.10.4
GZA-618185
TS 13 · IDS
Total Stroke Count
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree TS=14

Evidence

Showing 2 comments.

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
03602
03602
贝 154′.4.2
GPGLG-4017
TS 8 · IDS
Unclear evidence response
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
The character 介 appears 134 times in this book including twice on the same page with reading gaiq aka gai tone 5 (highlighted by green boxes below)

02113
02113
水 85.9.5
GZ-4722601
TS 12 · IDS
Misidentified glyph
[ Unresolved from v2.0 ]
Further investigation confirmed the glyph in the evidences is correct and therefore the submitted glyph and IDS should be change to match the evidences.

Re comments #2119 and #2220: the bottom right should be "且" or, in other words, the right hand part should be U+316B9 𱚹.

Re comment #5928: both ⿰氵𱚹 suz (a hole) and U+316B9 𱚹 sux (to know) are Longzhou Zhuang words. They follow the an established pattern for common and uncommon words.The character used for a common words can not be broken down and is memorised by rote. The character for less a common word consists of a memorised by rote character used as a phonetic combined with a semantic radical and that the tone of the phonetic part is ignored, just the sound is used.

Glyph Design & Normalization

Showing 10 comments.

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
04558
04558
鳥 196.10.4
GZ-0091202
TS 21 · IDS
Glyph design
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree glyph should be modified to ⿺笔鳥 to match the evidence.
03623
03623
走 156.5.1
GZ-0292201
TS 12 · IDS
Glyph design
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agree the lower-right stroke of "本" should be changed.
03202
03202
自 132.7.5
GZ-0501401
TS 13 · IDS 𠬶
Glyph design
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed glyph design should be updated.
01159
01159
尸 44.13.5
GZ-0722101
TS 16 · IDS
Glyph design
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed update glyph to ⿺尼常.
01827
01827
日 72.5.5
GZ-0862101
TS 9 · IDS
Glyph design
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed glyph should be modified.
00121
00121
人 9.6.5
GZ-1471201
TS 8 · IDS
Glyph design
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed, the last stroke should be changed.
02126
02126
石 112.8.4
GZ-1572501
TS 13 · IDS
Glyph design
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
As stated at submission the glyph is normalized in accordance with UCV#247.
03077
03077
羊 123.8.4
GZ-1911102
TS 14 · IDS
Glyph design
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Yes, this is what is meant here by normalized.
Glyph design
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Agreed the 5th stroke should be 横 instead of 提.
01944
01944
木 75.11.4
GZ-3982201
TS 15 · IDS
Glyph design
[ Unresolved from v1.0 ]
Yes the right component is not 会, it is a simplified form of ⿱𠆢镸. The glyph should be modified to match the evidence.

Editorial

Showing 1 comments.

SnImage/SourceComment TypeDescription
03608
03608
贝 154′.10.2
GZA-617001
TS 14 · IDS
Editorial issue
[ Unresolved from v2.0 ]
Agreed, remove 󴉧 (U+F4267) from the similar to.