| Date | Description |
|---|---|
| IRG #63 2024-10-23 (Wed) 11:02 am +0900 Recorded by CHEN Zhuang | no change. |
| Version | Description |
|---|---|
| 2.0 | For 00382, add Discussion Record "No change, IRG 63." |
| Source Reference | Glyph |
|---|---|
| UK-30933 |
| Character Reference | UK-30933 |
| Codepoint | E5D5 |
| Radical | 30 |
| Stroke Count | 4 |
| First Stroke | 1 |
| Total Stroke | 7 |
| IDS | ⿰口𭀖 |
| Variants | 喱 |
| Pronunciation | N/A |
| Normalization Ref. | N/A |
| Total No. of Evidences | 4 |
| Notes | Cursive form of 𭀖 normalized |
| 2nd Radical | N/A |
| 2nd Stroke Count | N/A |
| 2nd First Stroke | N/A |
Review Comments
According to what is stated in the paper, it is written as "㕱".
According to Andrew‘s comment, the length unit '釐' has a complex character shape, and in practical applications, there is a simplified process: “釐-厘-𭀖”. So it's clear that UK-30933 should be the simplification of 喱, and 㕱 must be the wrong glyph of it.
But in the meanwhile, the glyph of 𭀖 and UK-30933 should be reconsidered.
There are 2 kinds of shape for 𭀖: ⿷兀丶 and ⿸㇇⿺乚丶.
And both of these glyphs should be the transliterations of the cursive script of '釐-厘', so the correct shape should be “⿸厂⿺乚丶”.
So the correct glyph for UK-30933 should be normalized to “⿰口⿸厂⿺乚丶”
With that being said, I would also support a separate evaluation of the glyph for 𭀖. I would like to note that the variation of ⿷兀丶 ~ ⿸㇇⿺乚丶 is also recorded for Zhuang (古壮字字典 p. 355 - ndei [dei1] “好” ~ 壮语简志 p. 97 [di1] “好”, respectively).
𭀖 occur in published literature, however ⿷兀丶 is by far the most common form used and found in at least 3 dictionaries, two of which where the sources of the character.
As stated in the submission note the evidences show the cursive form ⿸㇇⿺乚丶 which is generally only seen in hand written documents. A non-handwritten exception showing ⿸㇇⿺乚丶, and perhaps the only non-handwritten case showing ⿸㇇⿺乚丶is 壮语简志 p. 97
and the accompanying footnote says that the exact form of the glyph can vary from place to place.
There is potential for a level 2 ucv of ⿷兀丶, ⿸㇇⿺乚丶 and ⿸厂⿺乚丶.